Go To Moderator MenuYou are currently logged in as: 
Log Out
and / or
and / or

Saddle Rock Apartments

1000 Saddle Rock Road, Holbrook, NY 11741
% Recommended
City Average

This place used to be great but has taken a sharp nosedive over the last few years. I'm not sure if the vetting process has changed, but the quality of new residents (for the most part) has dropped significantly. RUDE, and… Full Review ▶


Please read my previous review (below); this one is an add-on, after receiving remains of security deposit. Here is an exempt: Redecorating fee: $350 Removing sticky tape on interior doors: $200 Replaced vertical end piece $100 Replaced blinds $200 Now, comments.… Full Review ▶


I wonder if anyone realizes that there is a woman who works here that has complete access to whos name goes on the reviews! She has been deleting her name from any negative comments about her. Heres an idea lady... We… Full Review ▶


I've lived at Saddle rock for 2 years now, and it's gotten increasingly worse. Ignored or put off maintenance requests, while they renovate other apartments to charge even more for. When it snows they take all day to dig anyone out.… Full Review ▶

Prospective Resident

My husband and I went looking this past weekend for an apartment and were greeted very rudely and unprofessionally by a women ------. Because my husband and I look very young, however we are financially stable and secure with all of… Full Review ▶


When I first moved into Saddle Rock 2 years ago, it was a dream. I've lived in other apartments, and they've all sucked. Noisy neighbors, badly taken care of apartments, etc. Going to a place with tree lined streets, good insulation,… Full Review ▶


BEWARE new residents...What they don't tell you is that your rent is lower than everyone to lure you in and after a year (if you make it that long) the rent sky rockets... Maintenance has gone down hill in the years… Full Review ▶


I have lived here for three years now. I Had nothing but inconsiderable neighbors and a rude management office. Very disappointing. Parking sucks but please do not complain because they could care less. The maintenance people are very unprofessional and noisy.… Full Review ▶


I moved here 9 months ago. I had looked forward to coming to Saddle Rock because so many friends, etc., had lived here at one time or another and said it was a great place to live. I noticed when I… Full Review ▶


They hired ------ to run the maintenance crew a few yrs ago. The mainetence crew themselves are wonderful, but Tony the Super, yikes! And the office crew... Joanne is amazing, but the rest of them are just useless. As others have… Full Review ▶


I have lived in Saddle Rock for almost 2 years in a newly renovated apartment. The apartment has great closet space, a newly renovated kitchen and a washer/dryer. The best part about this place is the pool in the summer. They… Full Review ▶


This has got to be the best apartment complex to live in on Long Island. My family and I have been living here for 3 years. We could not be happier. Joanne, who works in the office is the best. She… Full Review ▶


I have been here for a year and 2 months now... driving home last night I thought to myself, how lucky am I? Spring time is a symphony as the flowers bloom - as each finishes, something else blooms - like… Full Review ▶

Prospective Resident

would love to move here.. Full Review ▶


Saddle Rock is okay. Not great. They do a good job with the grounds. But the build quality of the apartments leaves a lot to be desired. The don't do a good job with the snow removal. The further east you… Full Review ▶


I moved to Saddle Rock almost 6 months ago and absolutely love it. Unlike Avalon communities and Victorian Gardens in Holbrook, the staff treats you with the respect you deserve for the amount of rent you're paying. They are responsive, warm… Full Review ▶


Saddle Rock is probably the best property around. The apartments are large, there is great storage, nice layout. The community is clean, safe and quiet for the most part. Private entries are a dream! There is some noise from Sunrise highway… Full Review ▶

Prospective Resident

Perfect place if you are going to sell your house and move into a townhome. Full Review ▶


We have been living here for 2 months now and it is home. I never want to leave. Full Review ▶

Prospective Resident

$50.00 for a credit check then they put you on a waiting list. Never got the month I asked for and I had to call them and ask what was going on since they don't bother keeping you in the loop… Full Review ▶


I've been here a couple of months and everything is going very well. The apartment was in good shape when I moved in, very clean, nice cabinets, clean carpet, good paint job. The staff has been very friendly and they take… Full Review ▶


I moved into the community a few months ago and so far I have no complaints. Although a bit dark, there is never any issues parking (i park directly outside my unit each night) and the grounds are landscaped often. The… Full Review ▶

Prospective Resident

Apartments appeared to be very nice so I signed for 2 bedroom that started at 1675.oo and was sold the upgrade for an additional 150.00 per month,with new cabinets,rugs etc.I was called back after a week and told that it would… Full Review ▶


I have lived in saddle rock since 2005. My husband has lived here since 2003. I have never encountered problems of any kind here. The office staff and maintenance guys are very polite. Any maintenance or repair problem is solved the… Full Review ▶


I have been here since 2005, and the only reason I'd move is because LI/NY is too expensive. Rent has increased each year, but if you research you will find that other complexes with similar amenities cost the same or more.… Full Review ▶


I will admit, until recently, I had mostly positive things to say about these apartments. So, I will start with the positive: - Apartments are decent-sized, are a fairly good value for the money. - Maintenance staff is very responsive, they… Full Review ▶


My husband and I bought a home last year. Prior to that we lived in Saddle Rock for 5 years. We miss living in Saddle Rock. It was always kept up beautifully. The management onsite was very responsive and friendly. We… Full Review ▶


I've lived at Saddle Rock for one year and I recommend it highly. Management is accessible and the grounds are kept in immaculate condition. The staff in the office (Joanne and Betty) are terrific! Air conditioning filters are changed regularly, the… Full Review ▶


Since this website assisted my family in making a decision as were to move, I have to return the favor and post my opinion about the apartment complex we ended up choosing. All I have to say is that we are… Full Review ▶


Full Review ▶


In looking for an apartment, I saw almost every place possible on Long Island. All I can say is that Saddle Rock is the best out there. Great service, location, and a fair price. Full Review ▶


I lived at Saddle Rock for 4 years and only moved because I wanted an attached garage. If they offered this I would still be living there. Parking was great, never had a problem and if anything went wrong, Joanne in… Full Review ▶

1 to 10 of 32


BedsBathsEstimated Rent
Studio1 $ 2269
11 $ 1940
21 $ 2199
22 $ 2013
22.5 $ 3120


  • Cats Allowed

  • Small Dogs Allowed

  • Pet Deposit Required

  • Pet Rent Required

  • Some Breeds Restricted

  • Laundry On-Site

  • Laundry in Units

Rent Trends

Year Beds Baths Avg. Monthly Rent Range
{{complexPricing.year}} {{complexPricing.bedrooms}} {{complexPricing.bathrooms}}$ {{complexPricing.averageMonthlyRent}}$ {{complexPricing.minMonthlyRent}} - $ {{complexPricing.maxMonthlyRent}}

Disclaimer: Rental rates have been collected from Internet users and represent snapshots of a rental prices over time. These rates may not be a reliable indicator of current rents or the price offered to new residents. How to use this information.

1 Photos

(User photo uploaded on 04/23/2008)

Closest Properties


Nearby Apartments

1 to 10 of 32