and / or
Search
and / or

Castle Creek Apartments (formerly AMLI at Castle Creek)

5702 Castle Hill Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46250
70%
Rent at Castle Creek Apartments (formerly AMLI at Castle Creek) and get a $200 reward from ApartmentSearch
119
Reviews
70%
Apartment Rating
60%
City Average
03/11/14
Resident

I have lived in over 9 apartments, and I've never lived in one where I could hear my neighbors except for Castle Creek. I know that it's just a part of apartment life, but when your upstairs neighbors sound like they're… Full Review ▶

02/13/14
Resident

Paper thin walls, inconsiderately loud neighbors, poor grounds upkeep. None of the residents with pets clean up after them, even when there are multiple trash and bag receptacles throughout the complex. That's just plain lazy. I've seen dog feces in front… Full Review ▶

09/11/13
Resident

I recently moved in and am ready to break my lease. Cars have been broken into, no security cameras in lots. Parking is HORRIBLE. Poorly developed parking system. I would never recommend this complex to anyone. Full Review ▶

04/16/13
Resident

My roommate and I are new to Indianapolis so we shopped all over the northside for an apartment. We really liked the apartment at Castle Creek, even though it was at the top of our price range. It has proven to… Full Review ▶

02/13/13
Resident

I moved to Indianapolis from out of the area and obviously had a lot of places to choose from. I spent an entire weekend, with my two roommates, looking for an apartment and we could not get Castle Creek out of… Full Review ▶

11/12/12
Resident

Just moved in and apartment is great. Staff and maintenance is very friendly and the location is great for my job. Overall great experience with Castle Creek thus far. Full Review ▶

08/29/12
Resident

I will not recommend Castle Creek Apartments to anyone. My husband and I lived there for 18 months and it was problem after problem. A few weeks after we moved it we started noticing little bugs on the walls, etc. They… Full Review ▶

07/31/12
Resident

Watch out for this place. The make the office and outside look good (during the day) but the apartments are out of date and not well insulated. They will charge you for everything when you move out. They call themselves luxury… Full Review ▶

06/18/12
Resident

All in all, not a bad place. Any apartment you go to is going to have some issues - ability to hear your neighbors, certain aspects that are not up to your exacting standards, but for the price, you get more… Full Review ▶

03/24/12
Resident

I am a student at IUPUI who has been living here for almost one year now and I have been very pleased with my stay. With roommates, it's been very affordable for a really good quality apartment - only downside has… Full Review ▶

01/11/12
Resident

I love the layout of the one bedroom apartments here. The family/dining has so much room and can accommodate my oversized furniture. Some reviews state that you can hear every little noise, but in my opionion is is quiet. Also, the… Full Review ▶

12/07/11
Resident

Castle Creek is the worst apartment complex I have ever lived in. They are masters of curb-appeal only. There are certain apartments (particularly the ones directly on Allisonville Rd) that seem to get broken into about every other month. We have… Full Review ▶

09/09/11
Prospective Resident

I would not recommend this apartment to anyone. The leasing office offers a discount for a month which makes you ready to process application. Then they would be asking 1000$ deposit again which is not refundable in case of breaking lease.… Full Review ▶

07/21/11
Resident

I just renewed my lease for my 3rd year at Castle Creek. The price did go up some from last year, but I know that I couldn't find a nicer apartment in this area for the price. I moved to Indy… Full Review ▶

06/30/11
Resident

The price of my apartment went up this year- not worth what I pay for it. The maintenance staff works damn hard and they have been there whenever I have had a problem. My air conditioning unit freezes up often- I… Full Review ▶

06/15/11
Resident

I have been living at Castle Creek for a month and could not be happier! The best thing about Castle Creek- its' location! We are so close to everything, yet do not have any of the city noise. Move-in went exactly… Full Review ▶

06/14/11
Resident

I love living here, not sure who wouldn't !! I love my pond view, feel very lucky to have my apartment Full Review ▶

05/25/11
Resident

It has been a great living experience at Castle Creek. The staff is extremely helpul and takes care of any issues right away. Very clean grounds, always keeping it up. Great pool and facilities and a lot of friendly people. Full Review ▶

05/24/11
Resident

I lived at Castle Creek for a year right out of college. We fell in love with the place right off the bat with the crown molding, giant bathroom and extra storage closet. When we moved in we were then told… Full Review ▶

02/17/11
Prospective Resident

My current lease is expiring in May 2011. I live in AVON, in a house for 4yrs. I went apartment hunting in December of 2010. I selected 3 communities, Castle Creek was the first. I visited the community on my day… Full Review ▶

11/25/10
Resident

Castle Creek is truly one of the best apartment complexes in all of Indy!! It has the best location on the northeast side in terms of being very near 465 (but without being right next to the Interstate), and being centrally… Full Review ▶

11/22/10
Resident

I have lived here almost 2 years now and love it. I have lived in both a two bedroom and a one bedroom and both have worked out great. The staff is very accomodating and very quick to respond to questions… Full Review ▶

11/21/10
Resident

I have been living at Castle Creek for a few months and have been more than pleased with my experience. Maintenance is extremely prompt, staff very helpful and friendly, exercise room fits my needs, pool is a great social area, and… Full Review ▶

11/21/10
Resident

I have lived at Castle Creek for over a year now and I couldn't be happier. I know that the rent can seem at little high at first but I think I get what I pay for. For an apartment, I… Full Review ▶

11/20/10
Resident

I have lived here for a few months now & I absolutely love it. This is definitely the nicest apartment complex I have lived in. I get so many compliments from all of who visit. The apartments are just beautiful, office… Full Review ▶

11/20/10
Resident

I always feel very safe. The outdoors are well lighted and the grounds are kept nice. Also, maintenance always responds very promptly. They usually fix any problem in less than 24 hours. Full Review ▶

11/20/10
Resident

Castle Creek is, by far, the nicest apartment complex in the area. The floorplans are open & spacious, and the rent is reasonable. The bathroom/kitchen fixtures and appliances are all modern & up-to-date, which makes for a gorgeous place to live!… Full Review ▶

11/19/10
Resident

I have lived here for about 7 months. The staff are wonderful and polite. The grounds are constantly kept clean. If I need repairs, maintenance are always quick to resolve the issue. I really enjoy living here! Full Review ▶

11/19/10
Resident

I am new to Indiana and didn't know much about the area. I chose Castle Creek because it was the best looking apartments in the entire area. It was the best choice. They are very nice inside with cathedral ceilings, amazing… Full Review ▶

11/19/10
Resident

I have lived at Castle Creek Apartments for approximately two (2) months now, and so far, I have found this place to meet and exceed my needs. I agonized over the apartment search initially, and based off location, decided I needed… Full Review ▶

11/19/10
Resident

I recently moved in about 4 months ago and I LOVE my apartment. Yes the rent is a little high, but I live in the biggest 1 bedroom apt and I always feel safe here. all the walkways in apartments to… Full Review ▶

11/19/10
Resident

Castle Creek is the the best apartment I've lived in so far. I have the two bedroom with a sunroom. I love the features that make it just a little different from other apartments...We have a real fireplace, crown molding, garden… Full Review ▶

11/19/10
Resident

I moved to this apartments 6 months ago and I just love it! Great Management Staff, Clean, Maintenance is great! And the neighbors are really friendly and very peaceful to live. Also this is a really safe apartments! I Love Living… Full Review ▶

11/19/10
Resident

A very nice and quiet place to live in ... has some beautiful landscaping and overall a great place to live. Management is very friendly and always smiling :) Full Review ▶

11/15/10
Resident

I've lived in a number of apartments over the past few years, and this is BY FAR the best one! I recently moved from Chicago to Indianapolis, and just happened to stumble upon this complex. First, the staff is AMAZING and… Full Review ▶

11/04/10
Resident

My boyfriend just moved out of Castle Creek due to a job transfer. I loved staying with him at his apartment. Parking was a little tight around his area of the community, but it was a nice place to live. Full Review ▶

09/21/10
Resident

This is the best apartment community in the area. Full Review ▶

09/14/10
Resident

I have been a resident of Castle Creek for 3 months now and I absolutely love it here! I have lived in a few other apartment communities and this is by far the best place I have ever lived. The ladies… Full Review ▶

08/12/10
Resident

Do NOT rent here. The staff is unable to enforce rules and will cut your amenities without cutting back your rent or allowing you to break your lease. Never a parking space available close to my apt and I have had… Full Review ▶

06/16/10
Resident

I dont know what I'm paying for. and there is no way this is a "green" community. the recycling bins are always full and I saw a maintenance man empty one of them into the dumpster! The luxury part about living… Full Review ▶

04/23/10
Resident

I lived in Castle Creek for two years before moving out of state for my job. I really liked it. Close to the mall and Moon Dog, and walking distance from Sahm Park. The staff was always nice and the pool… Full Review ▶

03/23/10
Resident

My daughter just moved in.We searched for alot of apartments.And Castle Creek defenitely has the nicest. Full Review ▶

03/23/10
Resident

Ok, if you are wanting to move to Indy Castle Creek is the NICEST apartment complex in the Castleton area! The staff goes above and beyond expectations! Most recently, I needed a package that was delivered to the office because I… Full Review ▶

03/11/10
Resident

I have lived here for over a year and cannot wait to move. The apartments are SO overrated. When you DO have a problem or need to talk to someone I sure hope you don't have a 9-5 job because when… Full Review ▶

02/12/10
Resident

Just moved in last month and really wanted to let everyone know what a great experience I've had so far. The customer service has been outstanding. I chose Castle Creek because I loved the apartment, the interstate is close, and the… Full Review ▶

12/17/09
Resident

The problems are: -Recurring problems and promises unfufilled. It took over a month to get a transition strip between the carpet and hardwood. There were nails poking upward. This was discovered when maintenance was called over to my apt. for a… Full Review ▶

12/02/09
Resident

I don't know if the apartment complex went downhill after becoming NTS owned instead of Amli? I moved in 4 months ago. The apartment I was shown was completely different than the one I got. I live in a one bedroom.… Full Review ▶

12/01/09
Resident

I have been here for 4 years and absolutely love Castle Creek. The location is great and the apartments are nicer than any other I've seen in Indy. Maintenance crew is great and I love the Staff in the office- they've… Full Review ▶

11/20/09
Resident

Both office and maintenance teams excel at resolving issues, display a proactive attitude-in order to eliminate potential problems, demonstrate insightfulness and ingenuity and actively listen to resident's concerns. Further, they display outstanding courtesy and professionalism. Full Review ▶

11/17/09
Resident

Moved in about 3 weeks ago and so far I'm very pleased. My roomate and I love our two bedroom with a sunroom. We've already used our fireplace this year. My upstairs neighbor is loud but he's very friendly so I… Full Review ▶

11/07/09
Prospective Resident

Just considering a move-in and I'm really liking this complex. The management staff has been very attentive and they've been a big help easing my move here. I love the landscaping throughout. The floor plan is really what has attracted me… Full Review ▶

10/28/09
Resident

Moved from Fort Wayne about 6 months ago and so far I'm loving it. I can hear minor noise from the apartment above me but it's an apartment so what do you expect....Great location, great price! Full Review ▶

10/18/09
Resident

I've lived here for just over a year and think it's a great place. Easy access to lots of great things to do. The community is clean and well maintained. Friendly staff that do what they say they will do. Most… Full Review ▶

10/13/09
Resident

Although looking forward to the Florida sunshine, I will miss my beautiful apartment here, and my neighbors. The management has really improved since I first moved in and there have been lots of improvments and updates. Full Review ▶

09/24/09
Resident

I have lived at Castle Creek for 3 years and have had a very positive impression of the community and staff. The community is very pretty and recently has been painted. It has a great location in town being very close… Full Review ▶

09/22/09
Resident

I've lived at Castle Creek for 3 years and I've loved it. I've lived in both the one bedroom and the 2 bedroom with a sunroom. The property was quiet and convenient which is all I'm really looking for. I had… Full Review ▶

11/28/08
Resident

First off when we were looking at this place, we asked for an aparment not on Allisonville Rd, and we got one right on the corner or allisonville and 91st! She lied and when we called in the next day to… Full Review ▶

06/03/08
Prospective Resident

I just graduated from college and plan on moving to Indianapolis this summer. This is the last place I would choose to live though. The management is extremely rude. I have been trying to sign for an apartment here for 2… Full Review ▶

03/30/08
Resident

The community's appearance is very nice but once the management changed from Amli to NTS, the apartment community has gone downhill. - there is a break-in or assault almost every month - maintenance is very incompetent: takes several days before they… Full Review ▶

03/14/08
Resident

Everything was great when it was AMLI, but 4 months after I moved in the new management was HORRIBLE. The office staff is now a bunch of stuck up, spoiled brats with nothing on their mind but money. One of the… Full Review ▶

01/22/08
Resident

Positives: 1) Nice place, fairly new. 2) Lots of young, friendly neighbors. 3) My experiences with the staff have been positive. Big Negatives: 1) The hallways of the buildings are exposed to the elements. 2) Traffic and access to the complex… Full Review ▶

08/16/07
Resident

I am just about at the end of my lease and I am ready to get out of here. The worst part of it has nothing to do with the actual complex other than it's location, but the traffic is AWFUL… Full Review ▶

07/20/07
Resident

This was the worst place that we have ever lived. I really don't know what else to say, except that if you want to get robbed and have all of your stuff stolen, feel unsafe the entire time, and have the… Full Review ▶

07/20/07
Resident

I recently jsut moved into my new apartment here at Castle Creek and I have enjoyed it. The apartment is very spacious and clean and I love my large patio. I have already meet my neighbors above me and across the… Full Review ▶

07/12/07
Resident

Castle Creek has been the best thing about moving to Indy. The grounds are great. The pool is relaxing. The rent is so reasonable and the staff is so accommodating. I am sad that I have to leave Indy - because… Full Review ▶

07/11/07
Resident

I have lived at castle creek since the beginning of this year and I can now see why NUVO magazine rated it as the best complex in Indianapolis. The staff has always gone out of their way to do whatever they… Full Review ▶

07/06/07
Resident

I lived at Castle Creek for 2 years. I moved because my neighbor that lived below me was an obvious drug dealer and on top of that he turned out to be their new maintenance worker...meaning he was the one fixing… Full Review ▶

06/28/07
Resident

I have lived here for 4 years now. And yes when NTS took over the billing system did change but my utilities (water, sewer, trash and admin) have never been over $25 a month. You may want to look closer at… Full Review ▶

06/27/07
Resident

Have lived here for two years. I am moving because they tried to raise the rent on me by an additional 78 bucks a month. In addition I am supposed to be paying one amount but water, sewage, trash, plus a… Full Review ▶

05/23/07
Resident

Dont get tricked into the price and special they offer. The staff is so rude and the walls are paper thin. The traffic and road noise is terrible. The pool is nice when it is open but thats rare. Dont expect… Full Review ▶

04/28/07
Resident

Rude office staff, parking is a nightmere every night, according to the rules (which pretty much say you cant do anything outside) my boy can't play "ball games on the grounds" - can't hang dry clothes indoors (which would include all… Full Review ▶

03/08/07
Resident

The rent here is a little more than average, but if you are smart about it, you get aLOT of space for the money (plus alot of nice extra details like crown molding). And also, the staff is genuinely friendly and… Full Review ▶

03/07/07
Resident

Okay, honestly, I agree with a lot of what is being said on these posts. Yes, it is true, parking is really awful. It is a total pain to park. It is the worst in the winter months when you have… Full Review ▶

03/06/07
Resident

I've lived in Castle Creek for a little while now and I must definately say that I am completely disapointed. What a joke. It is one of those situations where you can tell that the apartments were built to "look" nice,… Full Review ▶

03/05/07
Resident

Yes, the people are fantastic. The ladies up front are lovely, the maintenance men are (usually) friendly, although (except for Scottie) they are unproductive. My only complaint is that MY FRICKING APARTMENT SMELLS LIKE FECES!

why does my apartment smell like… Full Review ▶

03/03/07
Resident

I have been a resdient at Castle Creek for a while now and I am very disappointed with the way Abbey protrays her professionalism. It is very unpredictible on when you hear from her also. I love my apartment but as… Full Review ▶

02/17/07
Resident

I, unfortunately, would not recommend Castle Creek to anyone. Beginning with the outside... Parking is terrible. Thought should be given to assigning one free space to each apartment number. I doubt that would work though, as I am paying >$40 a… Full Review ▶

01/19/07
Resident

This complex is very pretty, and impressive to your guests who may come and visit. However, parking can sometimes be a nightmare, and there is no way to feel safe in this complex. After a few attacks and SEVERAL break-ins, the… Full Review ▶

01/12/07
Resident

I recently moved in to Castle Creek and LOVE my new apartment. It is very clean and modern. I can sometimes hear the peoples around me television & radio but nothing that I can't stand cause I am sure they hear… Full Review ▶

12/12/06
Resident

Size of 1 bedroom and layout was nice. Noise level loud from busy Allisonville road next to apartment - which balcony overlooked. Noise level from other neighbors was not a problem, but was on the third level. Parking was not always… Full Review ▶

10/21/06
Resident

I'm not sure where in the complex these people with the scathing reviews are living, because I have almost zero problems in my building. My downstairs neighbor has a dog who barks its head off when she's not home, but it's… Full Review ▶

10/10/06
Resident

This place is so bad. the mananger is not good to deal with. there are several other apartments complexs in the area which are better. take the time and check them out. My apartment never stays warm and my heating bill… Full Review ▶

10/04/06
Resident

I have lived her for a year. I have never felt unsafe even while living in chicago, but after NTS took over I now do not leave my apartment at dark without my fiance. 2 woman have been attacked in the… Full Review ▶

10/03/06
Resident

Granted the apartment was very nice but not worth the cost! I previously gave a great review but after moving and receiving a bill in excess of $800 to replace their carpet--DON'T DO IT!!! My $400 deposit was insufficient- they have… Full Review ▶

09/22/06
Resident

I lived here for 2 years before NTS took over the complex. I like AMLI. I can't stand NTS. I wish I had moved when my lease was up. I will certainly leave after this year. The office staff is clueless.… Full Review ▶

08/17/06
Resident

I just moved in a few months ago and love my apartment. It is very nice and the one time that my AC went out maintanance was there that day to fix it. I think the apartments are extremely nice and… Full Review ▶

07/10/06
Resident

I lived in Amli @ Castle Creek and genuinely loved my apt. I had beautiful big windows and a lot of light. I like the crown molding and the brick exterior. But I have never dealt with a management staff so… Full Review ▶

06/27/06
Resident

Castle Creek an NTS community is awesome. I am very pleased with my experience so far and I would definately recommend this place or and other NTS community Full Review ▶

06/04/06
Resident

When they changed Amli at Castle Creek to Castle Creek by NTS the staff completly changed. They will never return your phone calls. The maintenance staff doesn't clean anything anymore. The pool is nasty, and the hallways always have trash. Your… Full Review ▶

04/09/06
Resident

I have lived here a little over a year. Granted the walls are paper thin (you can here your neighbors as they come and go), I love my apartment. I was surprised to read about the assaults- the management notifies us… Full Review ▶

03/17/06
Resident

Lived for three years. At the end my deposit was not returned due to dog/cat urine stains on the carpet, whereas the truth was I never had a dog/cat in my life. Did not bother to go to court for $200.… Full Review ▶

01/18/06
Resident

If you are looking for an apartment, be careful with what you are shown here.

There is only one trash deposit and it is located in the Southwest corner of the complex. It can be a real inconvenience in the snow and… Full Review ▶

10/19/05
Resident

I love it here...it's beautiful, has crown molding in the apartments,new appliances, HUGE garden tubs, nice and efficient maintenance help. What more could you want?!?! The walls are kinda thin, yes, and it's not always quiet, but it's an APARTMENT!!! get… Full Review ▶

08/31/05
Resident

Office staff posts positive reviews -- don't believe! Full Review ▶

08/31/05
Resident

I could live here forever! Full Review ▶

08/26/05
Resident

After living here for 2 years and reading the reviews below, those negative folks couldn't be more wrong! I absolutely love my apartment...it's gorgeous and I've lived in many many apartments! Maintenance is on it--every time I need something, even the… Full Review ▶

07/27/05
Resident

Two of my neighbors were robbed at gun point this week. Getting out before my lease is up, not the first crime that's happened recently, just the latest. Full Review ▶

06/27/05
Resident

never expect to get your deposis back. they did whatever possible to keep in their pocket. i did far less than normal wear and rear to the carpets but still was charged of $150.

the whole living experience was average. nice location… Full Review ▶

06/24/05
Resident

Not only can you hear all of your neighbors constantly, but traffic noise is terrible. Also since this place is right on a busy intersection it is not the safest. In the past year there have been 2 rapes and a… Full Review ▶

04/19/05
Resident

I lived in AMLI At Castle Creek just under a year ago. This was by far my favorite apartment. I am currently looking for an apartment in Tennessee and I am trying to find somewhere just like AMLI @ CC. The… Full Review ▶

11/12/04
Resident

I have lived at Amli at Castle Creek for 6 months. I couldn't be happier! I've read the reviews below that mention the noise, but I have had none of that. My apartment is extremely quiet. The staff is friendly and… Full Review ▶

09/23/04
Resident

I have lived at AMLI at Castle Creek apartments for a year now and have nothing but wonderful things to say about this place. The leasing staff is very helpful and the maintenance staff is on the ball. My apartment is… Full Review ▶

06/29/04
Resident

I enjoyed living at Castle Creek very much.
I was almost always able to park right in front of the entrance to my building, the office and maintenance staff was always very courteous, the grounds were beautiful, and it was VERY… Full Review ▶

06/16/04
Resident

I lived here for a few years, but am gladly out now. Yes, I did live illegally in a one bedroom with a roomate, but that doesn't alter the validity of my complaints. It was a guy I met last summer… Full Review ▶

06/10/04
Resident

I've had a great experience with the management. They have been very understanding. The apartment is nice and has many amenities. My only complaint is the noise from the neighbors. Full Review ▶

03/26/04
Resident

I have lived at Castle Creek for over 2 years. Every maintenance request has been completed the same day. The office has went out of its way to accomodate any request that I have made. They are professional and always happy… Full Review ▶

03/24/04
Resident

I lived here for all of 2 months. The staff is not well managed at all. I had a detached garage with my apartment and one day I came home and my things were GONE. Someone else was in my garage.… Full Review ▶

02/10/04
Resident

Truthfully, I would prefer not to be paying 850 for a one bedroom apartment, but its gorgeous. It is light, very spacious, the walk-in closet is huge as well as the bathroom. I have only had one maintenance issue and it… Full Review ▶

12/05/03
Resident

I have been completely disappointed from day one. It appears to be a nice, new complex. BUT, the breezeways are filthy. I have lived in the complex for a year, and I have not one time seen any evidence that the… Full Review ▶

11/21/03
Resident

I will say that the maintenance people are great! They are so friendly, and have called my apartment after a service call to make sure that they fixed whatever had needed the repair. I have not had much interaction with the… Full Review ▶

04/20/03
Resident

1. Rent is hefty; apartment is not luxury.

2. You need to leave AC on all year long: heating in winter and AC in summer. Electricity bill was more than $100/month in winter months for a small two bed apartment.

3.… Full Review ▶

02/04/03
Resident

I´ve lived here for about 6 months, and so far it hasn´t impressed me, nor has it totally turned me off. The one thing I have noticed, is that the walls/windows are SO poorly insulated that as I sit here by… Full Review ▶

02/01/03
Resident

Generally this apartment complex is a good value. The main issue has to be the noise from other apartments. This place is just built poorly! I lived in a first floor apartment and could hear every step from my neighbor above… Full Review ▶

10/30/02
Resident

It?s a very nice apartment and the problems I´ve experienced are very minor compared to other places I´ve lived. However, for the amount of money I?ve paid, I´m a bit underwhelmed.

It?s generally clean and quiet. The tenants here seem… Full Review ▶

10/29/02
Resident

I have lived here for over two years and would not be happy living anywhere else. The office staff and maintenance staff are very friendly and helpful. I recommend it very highly. Full Review ▶

08/20/02
Resident

I love living here. The staff is always helpful, and the maintenance staff responds very quickly. The grounds look better than most all other places I have lived. I hope to live here a long time. Full Review ▶

08/08/02
Resident

These aqpartments are not what they appear to be. The walls are so thin you can hear everything. If you have someone living above you, you can hear every footstep due to creaking floor joists. The entry-ways are filty and never… Full Review ▶

05/16/02
Resident

I have lived at this complex now for 6 months, and have no complaints. Everyone is professional, courteous and very accomodating. I would definitely recommend living here. Full Review ▶

04/13/02
Resident

The office staff were very friendly and helpful until I signed the lease. I have an excellent credit history yet they still required more info on my job status then my mortgage company. The grounds and repair staff were very friendly… Full Review ▶

1 to 10 of 119

Nearby Apartments

1 to 10 of 119