and / or
Search
and / or

Club at Buffalo Creek

720 Buffalo Run Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46227
52%
116
Reviews
52%
% Recommended
60%
City Average
01/03/14
Resident

I've lived in buffalo creek for 1.5 years now. The first year wasn't too bad, but the past 6 months have been hell. Last winter my two years old bedroom window started getting black mold in it. I cleaned it with… Full Review ▶

09/27/13
Resident

I lived in a 2 bedroom-1 bathroom onyx on the first floor. I never really had any problems. When I first moved in the air conditioner didn't work but they fixed it that same day with no issues. My dishwasher never… Full Review ▶

09/18/13
Resident

It's not terrible, but it's not great. Our toilets would constantly overflow, there were often spiders lurking about the apartment, and the property manager will argue with you if you bring anything to her attention. The rest of the office staff… Full Review ▶

09/02/13
Resident

I lived at Buffalo Creek for 2 years and had very few issues. -Staff was extremely nice and always willing to help. -Maintenance was extremely fast, always completed within 24 hours. -Available parking except late at night, but still reasonable. Cons:… Full Review ▶

07/03/13
Resident

We have only lived here about 6 months, but so far we like our apartment, and especially the view of the creek. There are a few problems with unwanted spider guests, and the parking is a bit of a problem at… Full Review ▶

05/19/13
Resident

I sued Buffalo Creek in small claims court b/c they kept my security deposit and charged me an add'l fee. I won...b/c they're ridiculous. I encourage anyone who thinks they have been wronged-to fight this in small claims court (it's only… Full Review ▶

04/24/13
Resident

Where do I begin? This place is sub par all away around the board. The staff seemed uninterested, the apartment itself was made of paper, and the neighbors were absolutely terrible. I lived there for 1 year with my roommate and… Full Review ▶

03/07/13
Resident

Me, my wife and our toddler moved into a downstairs apartment and thought that it was going to be great....but it turned out to be HELL!! First of all we live directly under a loud woman with no kids or responsibility… Full Review ▶

09/23/12
Resident

My sister and I lived at Buffalo Creek for one year. We are a nice and quiet combination as she is mostly working odd hours as a nurse and I am a nerd and play video games all day. Half way… Full Review ▶

06/22/12
Resident

This complex would be a good place to live if not for horrible management. Throughout the course of my lease, every appliance broke. It took at least 3 visits from maintenance, sometimes as many as 6, before my appliances would be… Full Review ▶

11/12/11
Resident

When i first went and looked around the place, it was very nice. My room mate and i signed our lease as fast as we could. We moved in right before christmas and we was super excited. Then everything started to… Full Review ▶

10/04/11
Resident

You can find something 10X better and cheaper!!! I have filed complaints about a neighbor and have even called the police a few times, but the staff at Buffalo Creek has done nothing about it. This is not a just an… Full Review ▶

09/26/11
Resident

First I want to say I DO NOT work for Buffalo Creek and I have worked in leasing in the past and a lot of the small problems people are having with BC are problems with every apartment community. I searched… Full Review ▶

09/09/11
Resident

I have had the same issues that others describe with maintenance. The head manager is SO rude. I have had to have him called out several times and I dread it every time. It is always ...oh well you will have… Full Review ▶

08/27/11
Resident

Overall it's an ok place to live. I feel that it is way over priced. 670 for a two bedroom! It is the smallest two bedroom apartment I have ever seen! The grounds maintence man aka santa claus sticks his nose… Full Review ▶

08/05/11
Resident

I've really enjoyed my time at Buffalo Creek. First and most importantly the staff is beyond nice and all of our maintenance issues have been fixed in an appropriate amount of time. Buffalo Creek is also in a nice location it's… Full Review ▶

07/26/11
Resident

I have lived in these apartments for almost 2 years.... In that time I have been subjected to numerous water leaks resulting in damage to both the aprtment unit and also my personal belongings... the management's pat answer is "I understand,… Full Review ▶

07/15/11
Resident

Great place for those who like it quiet. Management is friendly and helpful and the one time I had to call maintenance, 3:00 am was no problem. Full Review ▶

06/27/11
Resident

We checked up and down the street but renewed here once again. Best price, best pool, best atmosphere, and last - but not least - the best attitude staff on the planet. We really enjoy our life here, as everyone is… Full Review ▶

06/10/11
Resident

First off I want to say that it's disappointing to myself that I'm writing a bad review because at first this place was beautiful and I thought, safe. The first day we moved in, there were dead spiders everywhere, as if… Full Review ▶

02/02/11
Resident

I've lived here for 8 months (see below for later review), and while there are some issues, I feel overall that this is a great apartment for what they charge. Actually I think it's pretty fantastic for what I pay. ($575… Full Review ▶

01/20/11
Resident

GOOD: Maintenance has always been prompt at fixing problems. Snowy sidewalks are shoveled promptly as well. Quiet are near the front of the complex. Most of the time, parking is not a problem. You cannot hear through the walls (except for… Full Review ▶

12/23/10
Resident

I moved in here in August. I love it. The apartment is smaller than my old one, but I love the layout! Having the bedrooms separated by the living room is wonderful (and the reason I choose Buffalo Creek!) The girls… Full Review ▶

08/25/10
Resident

Was not pleased with my stay. Lived on the ground level and could hear what sounded like wrestling tournaments upstairs consistently. New upstairs neighbors couldnt figure out how to hook up their washer and it flooded causing lots of water damage… Full Review ▶

05/21/10
Resident

I have lived here for about a year and a half. I have no complaints. The floor plans are ample. Large balcony. I am renting one of their 1 bed units, which I believe is extra, but negotiated a good rate.… Full Review ▶

05/17/10
Resident

Stayed in this apartment for a year. Apartments are old and need renovation. Management dont respond to our complaints. So many bugs in the apartment. Dogs poo on sidewalks and nobody ever cleans it. Snow wont be removed for days. Full Review ▶

05/12/10
Resident

BEWARE OF FAKE positive REVIEWS HERE. Looks like all of the positive reviews here are written by apartment management. Whenever a tenant writes a negative review about the apartment. Manager will go ahead and give themselves 5 star rating here. This… Full Review ▶

03/26/10
Resident

Bring your own snow shovel. Maintenance takes for ever to fix small problems, have to keep on them about it. They say clean up after your pet or $100 fine. Yeah right no one does. Parking is horrible, if you get… Full Review ▶

03/24/10
Resident

I moved into a one bedroom apt last June, had to pay a deposit b/c of my credit apparently of $500.00. I have had numerous problems such as leaky faucets, horrible looking old cabinets with chew marks that they refused to… Full Review ▶

03/08/10
Resident

We moved out about a year ago to a smaller, more modest complex, which was fine. But we are moving back next month. I'm so glad! They have bent over backwards to accommodate us and I am happy to give them… Full Review ▶

02/15/10
Resident

I lived here for a little over 2 years. Living in the complex was a great experienece. There are many shopping and food within a two to three mile radius. The staff was very friendly and responsive. If I ever needed… Full Review ▶

01/14/10
Resident

Moved in last week and everything is going great so far. Love my apartment they even had me a gift everyone has been so help full I really feel like I am not just a number! Full Review ▶

11/24/09
Resident

We rented from Buffalo Creek for a year. When we moved out, they charged us $800 to replace a carpet that was already stained. We sent them a check for $500 ($800- the $300 pet fee we paid when we moved… Full Review ▶

10/29/09
Resident

Was Roaming threw the net and was checking out the rating! I cant believe that it is so low for this place. It is a great community. Quiet! Safe! Convient wow. And the prices are lower then most of the areas… Full Review ▶

10/28/09
Resident

If you are thinking of moving into these apartments...don't do it!!! I have lived in four different apartment complexes, and this is the worst one I have lived in. The management was VERY rude. Every time I went in with an… Full Review ▶

06/22/09
Resident

If you enjoy your power going out, careless office help, unfixed repairs, yet high rent, then this is the place for you! I moved in to this apartment complex during the move - in special and was excited about the community… Full Review ▶

06/18/09
Resident

I've been here for over two years and these people crack me up! I have two dogs and paid the $300 pet FEE when I moved in too. If I paid monthly rent of even $20 a month per dog, I… Full Review ▶

06/07/09
Resident

clean, nice, well cared for, quiet, no problems. Full Review ▶

05/28/09
Resident

When we moved in we were told that the $125 deposit was none refundable. We were told that that money would cover all the cost of cleaning and repainting after we moved out. That was fine with us. They also said… Full Review ▶

04/13/09
Resident

I have lived here for almost a year. It's remarkably quiet. And it's in one of the best areas in Indy. Yes, it's a no frills apartment, but considering the low rent and the location, it's a great buy. Thumbs Up… Full Review ▶

03/28/09
Resident

I lived there for 18 months and loved it. Great location and the price is right for what you get. If youre hip, this is the place for you. Full Review ▶

03/06/09
Resident

We checked up and down the street but renewed here once again. Best price, best pool, best atmosphere, and last - but not least - the best attitude staff on the planet. We really enjoy our life here, as everyone is… Full Review ▶

02/28/09
Resident

I have lived at Buffalo Creek for one year. Since they require a 30-day notice to vacate, I called the office more than a month in advance to ask if my rent would go up if I decided to stay another… Full Review ▶

02/03/09
Resident

I have lived at Clubat Buffalo Creek for almost a year and am thinking of renewing my lease. The negative reviews of this complex not accurate. There Is the place fairly new. However the place is a bargain for the price.… Full Review ▶

12/05/08
Resident

not sure if the managment changed or what but theings are def looking better here. I called for a service item and no sooner did i hang up the phone and they were there! Full Review ▶

11/28/08
Resident

There is a reason I have lived in this apartment community for the past 3 years...The reason is because this apartment home community has the some of the best apartments in Indianapolis...The staff is helpful and if something can not be… Full Review ▶

11/24/08
Resident

I was a previous resident and I'm back here. I have enjoyed my previous stay and that's why I am back. The office and maintenance personnel are always helpful and courteous and I feel safe here. The neighborhood is very nice… Full Review ▶

11/04/08
Resident

I was stunned to read some of the stuff on here. I just renewed for my second year and have never had an issue. I have never heard of anyone else that didn't like it here.It is true that the management… Full Review ▶

10/26/08
Resident

I recently jsut moved into my new apartment here at Buffalo Creek and I have enjoyed it. The apartment is very spacious and clean and I love my large patio. I have already meet my neighbors above me and across the… Full Review ▶

10/25/08
Resident

The office staffs posts on this site with false reviews. Look at the reviews. The apartments themselves are crap. They are horrible now that the new management company has taken over. You cannot get ahold of the new company. I tried… Full Review ▶

10/21/08
Resident

The staff at the Buffalo Creek Apartments have been nothing short of wonderful in helping me with my new home in their complex. The staff actively manages these apartments, NOT only when it's absolutely necessary like most other places. A family… Full Review ▶

10/06/08
Resident

I have several friends that live here and I do to. Well I have been in my apartment since June of 2005 and I am staying longer because I really really like it. It is very safe and very clean and… Full Review ▶

09/22/08
Resident

The community is beautiful and very well maintained. You get a great value for your rent. All of my clients have been very happy here. Full Review ▶

09/05/08
Resident

I was a resident at Buffalo Creek for 18 months and ever since the first day on the property I felt welcome and right at home. The grounds are well taken care. The staff is Incredible! they all do a fantastic… Full Review ▶

08/18/08
Resident

great southside location-nice apartment Full Review ▶

08/06/08
Resident

I have lived here for over 3 years and have been very pleased with the maintenance and office staff. My neighbors are quiet and the grounds are beautiful. The office staff is polite and will actually listen to my concerns. Great… Full Review ▶

08/05/08
Resident

I've lived here for 2 years and have no complaints. All of the staff have always been friendly and courteous. (No, I'm not one of them. And they aren't my friends - I don't even know their names.) The maintenance staff… Full Review ▶

07/31/08
Resident

Ironic that there's postings religiously every few days with ALL 5's...are you KIDDING me?? How does anyone think that it's NOT the staff.. they're pretty much identical. ANYWAYS- In short, they don't care what their resident's issue is as long as… Full Review ▶

07/09/08
Resident

lots of inprovments going on, nice place, prices still resonable and very close to mall and shopping Full Review ▶

06/25/08
Resident

We've lived here for just over a year and we love it here! Everyone is friendly, and the walls are thick enough you don't hear everything your neighbors are doing. We've never had a problem getting maintenance to come out and… Full Review ▶

06/18/08
Resident

To start off, I searched everywhere looking for an apartment and it was not easy. As soon as I visited Buffalo Creek I loved it!! First off the staff was so friendly and easy to get along with. Not buggy or… Full Review ▶

06/17/08
Resident

We really miss living at Buffalo!! We loved the layout and the openness of the apartments, lots of closets and storage area! We loved the office staff, who were always so nice and helpful. Only occasionally would the hot tub not… Full Review ▶

06/13/08
Resident

I've only been here for 6 months and it's almost time to move out. This is seriously a great place to live. I am a 21-year-old woman, live alone, and always feel safe! Over-all...move here. You will love it. Full Review ▶

06/04/08
Resident

I have been a resident here for almost 2 years. I just renewed my lease for my 3rdyear. I love it here. I The maintenance here is awesome. They do maintenance orders same day. The office staff is courteous and friendly.… Full Review ▶

05/30/08
Resident

i could not be happier with the loction of my place or the area. It's very close to everyinthg, the mall, shopping food etc. I have not used the pool yet but i do use the work out room and its… Full Review ▶

05/20/08
Resident

STAFF WAS SUPER NICE FROM THE START AND STILL IS AFTER ALMOST A YEAR. APARTMENT IS BIG AND COMES WITH A WASHER AND DRYER. LOVE THE VIEW OF THE WATER AND THE WORK OUT ROOM JUST GOT UPDATED WHICH IS AWESOME.… Full Review ▶

05/15/08
Resident

Quiet, comfortable, affordable and SAFE And ABSOLUTELY NO insects or critters of any kind!!!!! Halls & trash areas are cleaned 2-3 times a week. I've lived at Buffalo going on 4 yrs and have only met ONE resident that was anything… Full Review ▶

04/29/08
Resident

Beautiful grounds, lots of nice water views. Solidly built, spacious floor-plans, superb management and maintenance.Convenient to shopping. I never want to live anywhere else! Full Review ▶

04/26/08
Resident

I have been here 4 months and everything has been great. My dryer broke down and they came over and imeddiatly replaced it with a brand new washer and dryer. I called about my garbage disposal and they had it fixed… Full Review ▶

04/21/08
Resident

We have lived at Buffalo for a year now and it has been a fantastic experience! Management goes over and beyond to meet your needs, we have never experienced any maintenance issues, any concerns were handled immedietly, grounds are always clean… Full Review ▶

04/10/08
Resident

Club at Buffalo Creek 720 Buffalo Run Drive Indianapolis , IN 46227 317-885-9300 Full Review ▶

04/01/08
Resident

I've lived in three different apartment complexes in my life, and Buffalo Creek is, by far, the most professional of the three. When I was looking for a place, the women in the office were awesome! They answered all questions (and… Full Review ▶

03/25/08
Resident

Since someone bought this place out its horrible. There is no snow removal. Maint. Staff are morons. Everything in the apartment has been replaced such as the fridge, water heater, heater with used things. Lets talk about the upstairs toilet overflowing… Full Review ▶

02/27/08
Resident

I needed a short term lease and this place fitted the need. I went to several apartments looking and chose Buffalo creek. The staff has been prompt on addressing issues that had been brought to their attention. If I needed an… Full Review ▶

02/20/08
Resident

Here are some photos of Buffalo Creek. Come see for yourself what a wonderful community Buffalo Creek and the surrounding housing addition and patio home addition is. Thank you! Full Review ▶

02/14/08
Resident

I've lived at Buffalo Creek for 2 years now. The Office staff is professional and has handled all of my issues in a timely manner. The Maintenence Staff does a good job in fixing any issues and also handles themselves professionally… Full Review ▶

02/11/08
Resident

don't buy trust me read all the reviews...the good ones are the office staff!!! Full Review ▶

02/10/08
Resident

I have been a resident here for almost 3 years. I just renewed my lease for my 4th year. I love it here. I liked the old staff, and I love the new staff. The maintenance here is awesome. They do… Full Review ▶

01/18/08
Resident

When I first moved to Buffalo Creek everything was ALRIGHT. Not perfect, but ALRIGHT. My neighboors don't socialize with us what so ever, which is fine, but it's kinda sad. My windows leak everytime it rains. And everytime my heat kicks… Full Review ▶

12/30/07
Resident

I've lived in this apartment complex for three years. The first year and a half were good. When I moved into a downstairs apartment though things become a problem. The walls are so thin we can hear the people above us… Full Review ▶

12/23/07
Resident

It is raining tonight and there is water pouring in my window. I've told them twice but these bums can't fix anything around here. The management is to busy smoking up the office and not caring about fixing problems. I'm out… Full Review ▶

11/26/07
Resident

All these recent blog about the "creek" is the office staff. Its funny how they 3 of them were posted the same day. HAH. But read the negative blogs and you will see why these apartments are terrible. Honestly I have… Full Review ▶

11/13/07
Resident

Everyone who keeps saying bad things about this property are ONLY mad cause they didnt pay their rent!! This place is GREAT! I just relocated here and have had nothing but good experiences. I'm a single mom with 2 kids and… Full Review ▶

11/13/07
Resident

I HAVE NOTHING BUT GOOD THINGS TO SAY ABOUT THIS PROPERTY. I HAVE LIVED IN SEVERAL APARTMENTS AND THIS ONE BY FAR IS MY FAVORITE. THE LANDSCAPING IS ALWAYS KEPT UP. THE MAINTENANCE IS THERE AS SOON AS YOU NEED THEM.… Full Review ▶

11/13/07
Resident

i don't understand all the negative reviews this place has been getting. my husband and i have lived here for over a year and have never had a problem with anything being fixed, any noise level, and we've spent many summer… Full Review ▶

11/13/07
Resident

To start off, I searched everywhere looking for an apartment and it was not easy. As soon as I visited Buffalo Creek I loved it!! First off the staff was so friendly and easy to get along with. Not buggy or… Full Review ▶

11/08/07
Resident

Ok well before I move into any apartment i always read reviews for the apartment I am wanting to move into. Well please read this! Me and my fiance just moved in at Oct 31 and OMG what a disaster. It… Full Review ▶

09/03/07
Resident

If one will review the map of criminal activity for last 90 days with city of indianapolis - one will find the back part has had several people arrested, plus other criminal acts. There are a few other events on the… Full Review ▶

09/01/07
Resident

First of all, do not waste you money here...they look nice at first but they are really old and maint. dept doesn't have a clue to what they are doing. For ex. we also had a problem w/ ceiling fans and… Full Review ▶

08/22/07
Resident

It's really nice so far. The newer apartments, which I currently live in, are absolutely great. You can have ceiling fans and was told this before I move in so I spent 200 on 2 fans and when I was having… Full Review ▶

08/01/07
Resident

My wife and I moved into the complex in June accepting a move in special. They got the date to move in wrong and the apartment wasn't ready when requested. Our neighbors downstairs have been loud and noisy since we moved… Full Review ▶

07/13/07
Resident

I HAVE LIVED AT BUFFALO CREEK FOR 1 YEAR AND 3 MONTHS! DURING MY FIRST YEAR THEY WERE GREAT. AFTER I SIGNED MY NEW LEASE FOR THE SECOND YEAR THEY DIDNT CARE IF STUFF BREAKS OR NOT! IN MY LAST APARTMENT… Full Review ▶

05/24/07
Resident

I have lived at Buffalo Creek for approx. 1 1/2 years. I pay my rent on time, I'm a good leaser and I'm not writing this because I'm a horrible renter. I want to warn anyone that is thinking about getting… Full Review ▶

12/04/06
Resident

I have read most of the comments here and I agree with pretty much all of what the negative folks had to say. Lived here for 2 years but and everything started off ok, but things changed.

The living room window leaks… Full Review ▶

11/28/06
Resident

I just don't understand all of the negative comments. I have never had any problems with anyone that works at the apt. Vicki is always nice to me when I call for something. The maintenance has always come to my apt.… Full Review ▶

11/03/06
Resident

I would like to be able to break my lease, but I have a few more months left and will wait it out and search for a new place. I have been here for less than a year.
I am actually… Full Review ▶

09/29/06
Resident

seemed like such a good place in the beginning - such high hopes. then it started going downhill.

many of the negative thoughts on here I agree with - like the messy geese who are MEAN when you try to get to… Full Review ▶

09/06/06
Resident

This place is awful. Do not let the office staff fool you when you are looking to move here. They are great until you move in. After that everything is down hill. My biggest problem was the office staff not doing… Full Review ▶

08/29/06
Resident

Don't think about renting here unless you do everything perfectly, never have anything bad happen that is out of your control, and are very happy updating anything out of your own pocketbook.

From paying our rent on time for two years, this… Full Review ▶

08/08/06
Resident

We have lived at Buffalo Creek for almost three years now. A fair amount of the negative reviews on this site are very accurate as you can tell by the similar complaints on certain features of the complex.

Parking:
When you read on… Full Review ▶

07/26/06
Resident

The people living here seem to be getting trashier and trashier. The management doesn't seem to care that the buildings are falling apart. They continue to raise the rent prices, despite that fact. There is junk on porches and patios. Parking… Full Review ▶

06/23/06
Resident

My wife and I moved from Tampa to Indianapolis about two and a half years. We short listed 2 apartments using Rent.com and one of them was The Club at Buffalo Creek (The Club). We moved in (in February) and had… Full Review ▶

06/07/06
Resident

I have lived here 4 yrs (loved them when they were owned by JC Hart), and I'm moving in 3 weeks when my lease is up. Not only have I had to call the board of health several times due to… Full Review ▶

05/15/06
Resident

I have lived here since June 2005 and my lease is almost up I and have had nothing but a good experience. The problems the other people are mentioning in the other reviews are just common issues that would happen at… Full Review ▶

04/06/06
Resident

I have posted a response to another review with specifics of my issues of this apartment community. It is awful and in no way worth the money. Serious problems with the buildings (windows leak and are not installed properly). Insects are… Full Review ▶

04/06/06
Resident

Everything about this place drives me crazy. Other than one really great neighbor my husband has made friends with, we cannot wait to get out of here in a couple months.

Problems - Insulation around doors and windows - nonexistant. We have… Full Review ▶

12/09/05
Resident

I hated Buffalo Creek. It was okay when we moved in, but after a year or so, all sorts of issues arose. The workmanship of the apartments is of low quality. Things break and fall apart all the time. The maintenance… Full Review ▶

09/02/05
Resident

This community is an excellent place to call home. Friendly neighbors. Top value for your money. Very nice basic fitness center. Clean swimming pool and hot tub. Access to all types of shopping needs from Walmart to Target to LS Ayres.… Full Review ▶

07/27/04
Resident

I have currently lived here for two years. I love it here! It is a pet freindly community which is great. Everyone is so freindly here, I have met many friends here which is rare living in an apartment community. I… Full Review ▶

07/12/04
Resident

Full Review ▶

05/26/04
Resident

Great place Full Review ▶

04/26/04
Resident

Full Review ▶

04/14/04
Resident

Full Review ▶

04/07/04
Resident

I previously wrote a bit of a mixed review because of a car break in... I am going to be staying here for another year because despite the minor faults, I do really like this community.

All I can say… Full Review ▶

04/05/04
Resident

When we first moved here it seemed nice enough. In the last two years, however, the quality has gone down signifigantly.
It seems as though they´ve lowered the standards as to who should live here.

Management has changed and the… Full Review ▶

11/24/03
Resident

Overall, Great place to call home. My Fiance and I lived there over a year. No problems at all. Parking is fine, and well lit. The Office staff are all wonderful caring individuals. Full Review ▶

1 to 10 of 116

Nearby Apartments

1 to 10 of 116