and / or
Search
and / or

Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments

2 East Garfield Street, Bay Shore, NY 11706
66%
88
Reviews
66%
% Recommended
29%
City Average
10/14/14
Resident

Location: Garfield street better location than Third Ave. Quiet property, second floor is better Laundry machines are new and work but inconvenient No dishwashers. If you cook, prepare to do the dishes Rent a garage. Parking by sticker in the parking… Full Review ▶

10/03/14
Resident

We lived in a 2-bedroom apartment at BayshoreManor for 3 years. Long Lease. Very strict credit/application check. Overall, we love the serenity of the surroundings, the convenient location (close to the mall, shopping, highways, and Touro :), the quiet and safe… Full Review ▶

08/27/14
Prospective Resident

I'm writing a review to make other prospective renters aware of what a nightmare dealing with their corporate office has been. I viewed the properties, which in it's self, was difficult to even schedule an appointment. Once I got to the… Full Review ▶

04/24/13
Resident

Hello Ratings! I want to extend my thank you! to the leasing office and Nicki for turning the credit check, application, lease within my two week requested move in date time. You all saved me a huge headache. Looking forward to… Full Review ▶

04/18/13
Prospective Resident

I never lived here. Wait list. Full Review ▶

04/17/13
Prospective Resident

I never lived here. No apartments available. Wait list. Full Review ▶

03/22/13
Resident

Great! staff apartments location rental price service Can we get a pool?? ronnyschinder@Yahoo.com Full Review ▶

04/09/12
Resident

I had written a pretty glowing recommendation here, but after dealing with the staff at BenArt Properties, I would never rent from any of their properties. We had moved out in October 2011. We went through the process of having the… Full Review ▶

09/08/11
Resident

The Good: The apartment, for the most part is pretty clean. I can never hear anything from my neighbors or the people below us, even one neighbor who has an infant. The price is pretty affordable for the surrounding area without… Full Review ▶

08/15/11
Resident

Bay shore manor is infested with bugs in the spring and summer time. I am leaving as soon A s my lease is up The "property manager" Charlie the tard is a MAJOR BS artist!!! Im only trying to prevent anyone… Full Review ▶

02/05/11
Resident

I have lived here-Bay Shore Manor with my spouse coming on six years. I couldn t be more satisfied. The management today is very professional, friendly and helpful. The maintenance men, Charles and Phil, are the best we have known in… Full Review ▶

08/08/10
Resident

I love my apartment here at Manor. I have lived in other complexes before this one and have to say if you re looking for a reasonable, clean, nice apartment which close to everything, this is the apartment for you. Many… Full Review ▶

01/16/10
Resident

This has been one of my favorite apartment complexes and would have rated it a 5, but there is always room for improvement. I live in the 5.0 model 2 bedroom floorplan and this place has the best living arrangement. The… Full Review ▶

01/02/10
Prospective Resident

Well worth it at Bay Shore Manor apartments which are managed by BenArt. I'm not sure where some of the negative comments are coming from... I've loved living at Bay Shore Manor. I've changed apartments two times in the last six… Full Review ▶

11/08/09
Resident

The complex is well run and the management is very attentive. All my neighbors seem like very hard workers. People are respectful, professional and friendly. The parking is very easy. It's free unless you want an indoor garage. My rent is… Full Review ▶

09/03/09
Resident

I lived here for 2 years and the 1st year was a nightmare. The apartment below me was overcrowded, noisy and just ridiculous. Many complaints to the super and management, nothing changed, so I moved to another apartment. The second one… Full Review ▶

09/03/09
Resident

noticed overall reviews are dropping on this complex within past couple months used to be 90 percent not no more Full Review ▶

02/19/09
Resident

The Bay Shore Manor property is quiet and comfortable. My buddy emailed me the link thru Craigslist.org . I downloaded their application and the turn around was 1-2 days to receive an approval. When I applied for the apartment the company… Full Review ▶

12/12/08
Prospective Resident

I work with an organization that assists and cosigns for individuals and families with challenged credit. Please contact me for more information. Thank you in advance. Sincerely and Respectfully Submitted, Jean Poitevien Poitevien Enterprises, Inc. PO Box 8111 Washington DC 20005… Full Review ▶

10/07/08
Resident

My wife and I have been tenants at the Manor apartments for over a decade. We love the location, it's very safe and quiet. We pay a very fair rent and the renewal increases are very minimal. The office staff have… Full Review ▶

08/15/08
Resident

The staff is really cool. The supers make you feel comfortable and they never brush you off. If you treat them as human beings instead of talking down to them whenever you need a minor thing in the same day, they… Full Review ▶

07/07/08
Resident

Why would someone write a review that is so false, cruel and misleading? Well, I am a loyal tenant to the Bay Shore Manor apartments and this review doesn't give any factual information. In fact, it is cruel and the writer… Full Review ▶

07/05/08
Prospective Resident

to be honest, that side of bayshore is really bad,next to the train station prostitution, robberies, i lived in Bayshore over 15 years seen it all next to second ave , no way check out apts in Islip or the Bayshore… Full Review ▶

08/18/07
Prospective Resident

Giving up my indoor garage a few months ago was the biggest mistake I made. I have been on the waiting list for about a month now and it's sold out. Parking on the street and in the tenant parking lot… Full Review ▶

08/16/07
Resident

Living in Bay Shore for seven years has always been pleasurable for me. The last comment that says Bay Shore is a dump is extreme. Of course I respect that his opinion differs from mine but a dump is going way… Full Review ▶

03/16/07
Resident

Long Lasting tenant. Lived at Bay Shore Manor since 88. Many positive changes occured during the course of 18 years. Pretty happy here. Nice and quiet. Full Review ▶

09/23/06
Resident

Very reasonable priced apartments. Tony and Charlie are always on the run and very good supers. They are reliable, hardworking, and always cleaning. The office is seasoned and they take care of pretty much anything. There was a light out which… Full Review ▶

08/07/06
Resident

The Bay Shore Manor Complex have made many improvements to the building which surprised most of the tenants including myself. I am a cotent tenant from 1998. When they replaced all the hallways with new luxury carpet, a fancy designed paint… Full Review ▶

06/13/06
Resident

We have a junior (5.0)floorplan 3br, which is good space for us with our young child. It is really a huge 2BR. Kitchens and bath are not over-the-top fancy designer stuff but they are brand new,quality cabinets, ctop, appliances, ceramic and… Full Review ▶

06/07/06
Resident

I have lived in this building for a long time now, since it was taken over by BenArt Management. I have never encountered a single problem. It is kept in top-notch condition, the service is excellent and it has many great… Full Review ▶

05/11/06
Resident

As a long time resident of Suffolk County, I have finally found by diamond in the rough. At first I was skepticle of living in Bay Shore, but after just one month at the Bay Shore Manor Apartments, all my fears… Full Review ▶

03/17/06
Resident

Wow...reading the commentary here by dissatisfied residents really reveals what a snobbish sense of entitlement some people have...

Anyway: I've lived in apt 2c for 5 years. I have a beautiful 2nd floor 2 bedroom in one of the apts with serene… Full Review ▶

10/06/05
Resident

The company is reliable & fast..

I applied for an apartment and the apartment need to be renovated, the management company made sure the apartment was ready when I wanted to move in. Thanks! I just started a new position so I… Full Review ▶

09/16/05
Resident

michael jue "very content here" Full Review ▶

08/05/05
Resident

Lovely Community, Well Groomed, Beautiful grounds, very good staff. Apartments are spacious and town is very nice. Full Review ▶

08/03/05
Resident

I love the new hallways

Mr. Achuw Full Review ▶

08/01/05
Resident

Georgeous"

Lovely Community, all you need is right here

Full Review ▶

07/28/05
Resident

I enjoy it here Full Review ▶

07/27/05
Resident

The below is false, I have lived here for 4yrs. My name is Zhengian Zhong. I have 2 kids and reside in Bay Shore Manor. Everything has been lovely and easy for our family. Yes you do have to install your… Full Review ▶

06/27/05
Resident

1. Half a block from the train station and one block from hospital (noisy)

2. No AC. You can install your own, but only one per apartment and you contractually obligated to use some company that has insurance. Amounts to additional fees.

3.… Full Review ▶

06/15/05
Resident

great community! Full Review ▶

05/27/05
Resident

I call Bayshore Manor my Home.
The Management is very reliable.
The Garages are great and location.

Very Content

Mr Powers Full Review ▶

05/16/05
Resident

Very Reliable Staff & Supers! Full Review ▶

05/09/05
Resident

good stuff, nice place, right near long island road train, top location Full Review ▶

05/03/05
Resident

I have not lived here but it looks like a nice place to live. I noticed a very clean and maintained property. Good Luck to you. Full Review ▶

05/03/05
Resident

Very quiet...reminds me of the country

new tenant
Mr. Frank Full Review ▶

04/28/05
Resident

I am searching for the 2br 5.0 model that I saw on your website www.benartproperties.com
I would like to rent this apartment but it seems it is never available. I did see a model that was rented but I didn't submit my… Full Review ▶

04/27/05
Resident

I have a been a tenant here at the bayshore manor for 3 years now and the apartments just keep getting better. The management company cares and does a lot of improvements.
The examples are listed

1-ALL NEW WINDOWS
2-ALL NEW LITTERS AND GUTTERS
3-ALL… Full Review ▶

04/19/05
Resident

nice people live here, very quiet,just as we like it

mr. foster

rented 1br thru the craigslist.com

thanks Full Review ▶

04/18/05
Resident

Zhengian Zhang says good garage price. Come home to my apartment from city, park in my garage, no problem. Used to live in Sayville and no parking. At Bayshore Manor Great parking! Full Review ▶

04/13/05
Resident

sensational apartments

good quiet neighbors

well maintained property

reliable supers

sufficient heat-hot water

Garages are really super for my new car

Mr. Hart Full Review ▶

04/12/05
Resident

Just moved in.
They are doing a complete renovation of the building.
New intercom, new roof, new walk ways, my apartment is beautiful. They also replaced all the windows. Highly recommend Full Review ▶

03/14/05
Resident

all the tenants are happy and I am one of them!

mrs. Robins

I am very happy with all new windows, intercoms, doorways, hallways, roofs, what else can I say? Full Review ▶

03/11/05
Resident

good change

nice new windows
nice new intercoms

very content
Full Review ▶

02/19/05
Resident

good location

saez Full Review ▶

02/19/05
Resident

I love the manor apartments because of the size, space, electric is very cheap. I have a garage which fits my car and never have any problems parking. The supers are very knowledgable and respectful. I had a light bulb out… Full Review ▶

02/19/05
Resident

email me if you need a super? looking for job

15 yrs experience
plumbing
heating
painting
carpentry< repairs

Ray Barbarino

RBsuper@msn.com Full Review ▶

02/19/05
Resident

I have been on the waiting list for 5 weeks. I am looking for a 5.0 model 2br. please contact me 917 655-5316 Full Review ▶

02/17/05
Resident

I am a property manager and wish I can own this place.

To the owner:

My name is Frank Geivanni:

I am interested in purchasing this property. I do not know if it is for sale or not but I pass by everyday. Let… Full Review ▶

02/17/05
Resident

Century 21 Herricks is located in Bay Shore. They explained that they had a very lovely community in Bay Shore. I found it thru them. Full Review ▶

02/17/05
Resident

Bay shore manor is very quiet, i found an apartment thru kennedy realty, thanks doreen

mrs huang Full Review ▶

02/16/05
Resident

I was denied an apartment because of credit but very beautiful Full Review ▶

02/16/05
Resident

just lovely renovated- thanks guys

thanks!

nice improvements Full Review ▶

02/16/05
Resident

This lady is obviously a prior tenant who is upset and mad because she did not pay her rent or she got denied from an application, my name is tony, i have been here since 83, all the best to this… Full Review ▶

02/03/05
Resident

Look at all the positive comments. Must be the landlord/employees writing them! Bay Shore in general is a dump! Full Review ▶

01/13/05
Resident

Best of everything, lovely place, lovely grounds, management improved the building with new windows, new doors, intercoms, really beautiful, very georgeous, peaceful, I have nothing troubling to say.

Mike S. Full Review ▶

10/30/04
Resident

THIS LOCATION IS VERY PEACEFUL.
LANDLORD IS VERY GOOD, HE JUST INSTALL NEW WINDOWS, ROOFS, GUTTERS,LITERS. I AM A VERY HAPPY TENANT HERE. Full Review ▶

08/23/04
Resident

Tony and Charlie are great responsible supers. While residing at bayshore manor for 5 years, this building is very well maintained. The rental prices are extremely fair and the renewals too. I love the location because my son goes to Touro… Full Review ▶

05/24/04
Resident

I like it here. I lived at the manor now for 13 years. My rent is very low. The electric and expenses are very cheap. Apartments are well taken care of and I appreciate the attention I get from the management… Full Review ▶

05/14/04
Resident

Living at the manor now for 5 years. Landlord is very fair,the rent is reasonable. I have a family of four living in a large 5 room 2br. I can't complain. Full Review ▶

05/13/04
Resident

I was very surprised with the application process. The process reminded me of when I bought my first house ten years ago. Other than that, the apartment is well worth it. The grounds and insides receive a lot of attention and… Full Review ▶

05/11/04
Resident

Bayshore manor is in a very convenient location,I work in manhattan and take the lirr train everyday, which is 30 seconds from the property. Parking garages are also included with the rent. The property is well maintained. The supers are very… Full Review ▶

05/11/04
Resident

The apartments are really well taken care of. I saw a 1br and 2br and the prices were really fair. The floors are hardwoord, very shiny, freshly painted, had new stove,new fridge, lots of closets. I found the place on apartments.com… Full Review ▶

05/11/04
Resident

everything is here in terms of the long island railroad,ferry,south shore beach,south shore mall,highways,gyms,cleaners,shopping,
I would say give it a go! Full Review ▶

04/20/04
Resident

Bay Shore Manor is in the middle of the projects. You see crack heads on the street as soon as it gets dark outside. The day i moved in i saw a heroin needle laying in the grass. The constant traffic… Full Review ▶

02/21/04
Resident

Found Bayshore manor thru a friend of mine..
When I saw the size..I grabbed my own..
Good price,good location. Full Review ▶

02/19/04
Resident

The supers are on top of their game at the bayshore manor while the green grass shines and all is maintained to the highest point feasible. The parking garages are reasonable and rents are even more reasonable. I was impressed with… Full Review ▶

01/23/04
Resident

This location is really cool. I haven´t lived in an apartment more centrally located than the bayshore manor. You got the lirr train, ymca, beach, ferry, which is nice to go to fire island on the weekends and of course the… Full Review ▶

12/31/03
Resident

Bay shore manor was very helpful and informative when I first moved here. I found it on apartments.com and contacted the management office. I saw the apartment the same day and put a deposit down. Some things you know what you… Full Review ▶

12/30/03
Resident

I have lived here for 4 years and the rents are very reasonable. The location is great and Im content with my living space. Full Review ▶

12/30/03
Resident

GREAT RENT PRICES~
I could not believe the 1br was that big for that price but when I saw it
I was stunned. very spacious apartments- Full Review ▶

12/19/03
Resident

a lovely all around community Full Review ▶

08/15/03
Resident

I LIVED AT BAY SHORE MANOR FOR 5 YEARS NOW, I THINK THE APARTMENTS ARE BEAUTIFUL, LANDLORD IS VERY FAIR AND APPRECIATIVE OF HIS TENANTS. SERICE IS GOOD, I GOT GREAT RESPONSE FROM THE SUPERS, I LOVE THE GROUNDS, THEY ARE… Full Review ▶

08/09/03
Resident

The surrounding area is sort of run down, poor neighborhood, parking lot (extra charge) floods but mainly tenents park on the street which is a problem when it snows, because you get buried in by the snow plow, too close to… Full Review ▶

06/17/03
Resident

When I moved to Bay Shore, I originally lived in another apartment building where the size didn´t even compare to the manor apartments. I have a very spacious apartment, large kitchen and living room. I would totally say Bay shore is… Full Review ▶

06/08/03
Resident

I discovered Bay Shore Manor on Rent.com
I went to see the apartment and was impressed with the brochure they give you when you view the apartments. The pictures I saw were right on with how the apartment looked like. The… Full Review ▶

05/22/03
Resident

I LOVE IT HERE, THIS IS THE ONLY APARTMENT I HAVE LIVED IN WHICH I KNOW THAT IM NEVER GOING TO LEAVE Full Review ▶

04/24/03
Resident

so quiet, convenient location, nice staff, apartments are well taken care of
i love the neighborhood
i can´t say enough! Full Review ▶

1 to 10 of 88

Units

BedsBathsEstimated Rent
11 $ 1350
21 $ 1625

Amenities

  • Cats Allowed

  • Laundry On-Site

Rent Trends

Year Beds Baths Avg. Monthly Rent Range
{{complexPricing.year}} {{complexPricing.bedrooms}} {{complexPricing.bathrooms}}$ {{complexPricing.averageMonthlyRent}}$ {{complexPricing.minMonthlyRent}} - $ {{complexPricing.maxMonthlyRent}}

Disclaimer: Rental rates have been collected from Internet users and represent snapshots of a rental prices over time. These rates may not be a reliable indicator of current rents or the price offered to new residents. How to use this information.

2 Photos

(User photo uploaded on 04/15/2008)
(User photo uploaded on 03/16/2007)

Closest Properties

Distance

Nearby Apartments

1 to 10 of 88