Middle Island Apartments 4 Middle Island Apartments have received 71 ratings and reviews by Middle Island, NY renters. View apartments in Middle Island below.
  One bedroom Middle Island apartments currently rent for $1,370 to $1,430 per month. Middle Island renters report average rents are down $130 per month this year.  

Middle Island,NY

1-4 of 4 Listings ordered by
 
35 Reviews
87% Recommended
Stonegate
100 Stonegate Way, Middle Island, NY 11953
Nov 29, 2011 - -Anonymous- said:
Only apartment complex I'll recommend in Suffolk County - The best soundproofing, the grounds are spotless and beautiful with woodlands surrounding most of the complex, excellent gym and facilities,etc. Maintentence is top notch. The 2 BR apartment layout is wonderful. I looked at all apartments in Suffolk County and this is the best! ...Full review of Stonegate
RATING:
Rated Good:Office StaffMaintenanceSafetyGrounds
According to 80% of reviewers small dogs are allowed
4 Reviews
75% Recommended
Fairview at Artist Lake
315 Middle Country Road, Middle Island, NY 11953
Jul 17, 2011 - itsaniceplace said:
Fairview in front of Artist lake - Fairview is neat, clean and maintained. I have been here for years. It is quiet and safe. Updates are always done. Met some nice people. ...Full review of Fairview at Artist Lake
RATING:
Rated Good:NoiseGroundsParkingMaintenance
7 Reviews
33% Recommended
Pinewood Estates
17 Coram-Swezeytown Road, Middle Island, NY 11953
Jan 9, 2012 - flyingtiger said:
Best Place By Far - I've lived in a few complexes in this area, and this one was the best by far. The office staff was always friendly, and helpful. The maintance crew was always prompt and fixed any problems we had. I loved that there was a channel that told you when they were coming to change filters, ect. we were one of the few people that were in our twenties while there. The gym was awesome, ...Full review of Pinewood Estates
RATING:
Rated Good:GroundsMaintenanceConstructionSafety
According to 100% of reviewers large dogs are allowed According to 100% of reviewers small dogs are allowed According to 100% of reviewers cats are allowed
25 Reviews
0% Recommended
Fairfield at Middle Island
248 Lake Pointe Circle, Middle Island, NY 11953
Jan 9, 2012 - flyingtiger said:
Awful!! Do not rent here! - We had a flood in the apartment above us on a saturday, we called all morning to try and get someone to take care of the water falling from the ceiling for hours, the service would not call "a leak" (waterfall) an emergency and could not get a hold of the maintance crew. It took hours to shut off. the drywall was soaked in three of the room, the carpets were saturated, ...Full review of Fairfield at Middle Island
RATING:
Rated Bad:Office StaffNoiseConstructionParking
 
Middle Island Rental Market Trend Graph

Recent Middle Island Apartments Reviews

over 71 Middle Island apartments

Stonegate

recommend:YES | rating:5.00
-Anonymous- says: Only apartment complex I'll recommend in Suffolk County The best soundproofing, the grounds are spotless and beautiful with woodlands surrounding most of the complex, excellent gym and facilities,etc. Maintentence is top notch. The 2 BR apartment layout is wonderful. I looked ..full review of Stonegate

Fairview at Artist Lake

recommend:YES | rating:4.00
itsaniceplace says: Fairview in front of Artist lake Fairview is neat, clean and maintained. I have been here for years. It is quiet and safe. Updates are always done. Met some nice people. ..full review of Fairview at Artist Lake

Fairfield at Middle Island

recommend:NO | rating:1.00
soannoyed.com says: HORRIBLE MANAGEMENT These ppl are horrible... I can't wait until my lease is up so that i can move out !If you want to be treated with disrespect then move here... otherwise find some place else to stay. The only thing that these ppl care about is your money. period ! ..full review of Fairfield at Middle Island

Stonegate

recommend:YES | rating:5.00
friendlysboy@optonline.net says: Good Very Nice Place...................................................... ..full review of Stonegate

Fairfield at Middle Island

recommend:NO | rating:2.00
-Anonymous- says: NOPE!!! I WILL NOT RECOMEND THIS PLACE TO ANYONE, ANGELO DONT RETURN CALLS, THEY DO NOT FOLLOW UP ON COMPLAINTS FROM NEIGHBORS.. THEY LET PEOPLE GET ROBBED AND DONT OFFER ANY TYPE OF IM SORRY I SHOULD NOT HAVE HAD CRACK HEARDS LIVING IN HERE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ..full review of Fairfield at Middle Island

Fairview at Artist Lake

recommend:YES | rating:3.00
comicbookking says: I have been here since 1987 there is no crack problem. But the management leaves little to be desired. They keep raising the common charges with little or no explanation. Also the board members make policies without the input of the people who reside there. ..full review of Fairview at Artist Lake

Stonegate

recommend:YES | rating:3.00
familyrental says: New to community We have been here about a month or so. It's pretty nice here. Very quiet. My only complaint is that there is no playground. i have 2 little kids and this was one of the only communities we looked at that did not have a playground. It wasn't our deciding factor, but a ..full review of Stonegate

Stonegate

recommend:YES | rating:5.00
-Anonymous- says: Great Place To Live I was one of the first people to move into Stonegate. The staff was wonderful, friendly and very very helpful. If you had a problem it was resolved. The grounds are well kept and very clean. My only problem was the terms of the lease, and the constant increase in price. ..full review of Stonegate

Fairview at Artist Lake

recommend:NO | rating:1.00
-Anonymous- says: DRUGS DRUGS DRUGS I'm no saint but this is the crack haven of long island. And I know because I'm a recovering addict. ..full review of Fairview at Artist Lake

Pinewood Estates

recommend:NO | rating:3.00
-Anonymous- says: Unimpressed and Unhappy Predominantly retirement housing - mostly unfriendly, rude and nosy. Apartments are beautiful, but not worth the aggravation. Life is too short to deal with unhappy miserable human beings. ..full review of Pinewood Estates

Stonegate

recommend:YES | rating:5.00
laurena313 says: Wonderful place to live I diligently searched all apartment complexes within 30 mins of Stony Brook University and this was the best by far. The bedrooms are spacious with HUGE walk in closets, utilities are inexpensive because the apartments are well insulated, the staff are incredibly ..full review of Stonegate

Stonegate

recommend:NO | rating:3.00
adam453 says: Un-Impressive This is not a luxury apartment as advertised. It is okay. The apartments are cold in winter and hot in summer... very poor constrution. And the staff as attitude. I lived here for 2 years, and I was indiffrent about the place. Honestly, I would recommend that you contiue your ..full review of Stonegate

Subscribe to new Middle Island reviews with RSS Subscribe to Middle Island, NY feed

tracking gif