520 West 43rd Street, New York, NY 10036
Check Availability WEBSITE save favorite
AVERAGE RATING
recommended by:
42%

overall rating:
3.5
3.3
3.33 Parking:
3.9
3.88 Maintenance:
3.5
3.45 Construction:
3.2
3.21 Noise:
3.3
3.27 Grounds:
3.7
3.7 Safety:
3.7
3.7 Office Staff:

Opinions 33 of 33 Write a review Manager Reply
*
DATE & OPINION
Sorted by date
*
RECOMMEND
*
*
RATING
*
06/22/2011Noisy outsideNO2.0
 I lived there for one year from 2010 in a one-bedroom apartment in the top floor. It is not quite expensive compared to other luxury building in midtown manhattan. The management and super is good and usually respond less than ... more
07/20/2010Worth it if you get a good deal on your leaseYES3.0
 I live here for a year, and would have renewed my lease if I had stayed in NYC. I got a really good deal for my 1 bedroom. I was paying $730 more/month at The Victory on 10th ave, for ... more
02/01/2010So agree with the last post!NO2.0
 This place is INCREDIBLY dated for the price! The kitchens and bathrooms need a major overhaul to match what they are charging. I wouldn't say the place is hell on earth but its DEFINITELY a rip off. I did not ... more
01/30/2010Too Much CompetitionNO2.0
 As Simon Cowell would say on Housing Idol, "You're not cut out for this competition." Meaning the housing competition. New Gotham was priced well just a few years ago. Nearby luxury buildings were overpriced, and New Gotham was underpriced. Because ... more
10/04/2009DON'T DO IT!!!NO1.0
 Ok I wonder where all these great reviews are coming from. Either these are from people who have had horrid experiences at previous buildings, hence have really low expectations or they are plain liars (recruited by the owner/management) to paint ... more
09/21/2009Great staff/management, facility & locationYES4.0
09/10/2009Good enough for meYES4.0
09/04/2009Great building!YES5.0
07/08/2009Bad expereince...bad landlord...poor facilitiesNO1.0
05/09/2009Ok, but better nearbyNO3.0
View all 33 opinions about New Gotham Apartments.

About

New Gotham Apartments is an apartment community located in New York , NY . The following apartment communities are located nearby: Riverbank West ( 0.1 miles), Victory Apartments ( 0.1 miles), and 420 West 42nd Street ( 0.2 miles).

Up to: New York apartments
           New York apartments *
          


What's New On OH MY APARTMENT

   Your Renter’s Rights to Repairs: How To Negotiate Before a Signing a Lease - Oct 17
   Ceiling Storage: Your Highest Stowing Potential - Oct 10
   Who’s Liable for Bedbug Infestations and Bacteria–You or Your Landlord? - Oct 03
   6 Ways to Declutter and Rework a Room for Good - Sep 28
   4 Ways to Find a Roommate - Jul 15
   10 Things Smart Renters Know About Apartment Hunting
   How to Break Your Lease Legally
tracking gif