Apartment Ratings | Island Club Ratings and Reviews

Island Club: Beautiful Place (Recommending!)

2009-11-07T17:57:52-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I lived here for 5 years. Only left because I got married. The apartments are spacious and attractive. I liked the high ceilings and the fact that there was a place for a washer and dryer within the apartment itself. The view from my balcony was gorgeous. I enjoyed watching ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Great Waterfront Apartments (Recommending!)

2009-07-21T07:45:28-06:00

From -Anonymous-: This is part of a letter I wrote to To Westdale Asset Management in appreciation of the staff and the apartment complex: I have been a resident at Island Club Apartments in Indianapolis, Indiana since July of 2004. At first glance, I thought these apartments were magnificent. The architecture and ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: I LOVE IT HERE (Recommending!)

2009-05-26T10:27:57-06:00

From stassybaby: I recently just moved in and i love these apartments...The price is just right, and i love having a balcony to look out on the water. I feel much safer than the previous place i have been in the past...I'm so proud to be here and invite my friends and ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Such a shame :( (Not Recommending)

2009-03-16T07:11:34-06:00

From ruminate2motivate: I'm going to be fair but honest and hopefully it'll help you. I'm also a professional in my workfield so I thought this place would be awesome. I will list the pro's vs con's at the bottom of this review. First off, when I moved here the end of 2005 ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Appearances Can Be Deceiving (Not Recommending)

2009-01-26T13:37:36-06:00

From -Anonymous-: My first experience living in Indianapolis has been with Island Club. When I first started looking for apartments I was amazed that I found a community this nice (white cape cod type apartments on a lake at a low price ($525 a month for a 1 bed/1 bath))Boy was I ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Nice Place with Great View! (Recommending!)

2009-01-15T16:27:33-06:00

From -Anonymous-: This is aboaut the only place in Indianapolis where I found a great water view and an affordable price. A lot of people think that these apartments are too pricey but never investigate to really find out. They aren't too expensive and have interesting floor plans. I liked having a ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: DO NOT MOVE HERE (Not Recommending)

2008-04-30T08:10:33-06:00

From -Anonymous-: This is the worst apartment complex I have ever lived at! I agree with the past person who said the manager can't get along with anyone. The only half decent person is the younger blonde girl. The older woman is a b**** as well. There is always something wrong with ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Disregard (Not Recommending)

2008-03-05T17:37:22-06:00

From J_JM: Sorry, wrong Island Club. ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Had potential, gone downhill. (Recommending!)

2007-12-06T09:47:59-06:00

From -Anonymous-: My experience here at Island Club has been satisfactory, but not excellent. I consider myself a good tenant: I pay on time every time, I respect others, I am mindful of the amount of noise I make, I understand that this is an apartment complex so I don't have unrealistic ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: DONT MOVE HERE!!! (Not Recommending)

2007-10-03T12:59:51-06:00

From -Anonymous-: This place has gone down hill, and fast! There is horrible noise from apartments above, you can hear every footstep, stomp, kids running and jumping, and neighbors getting it on. The landscape and bushes are half dead evergreens in most places and nobody takes care of them. Maintenence is terrible, ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: A resident's opinion (Not Recommending)

2007-09-18T14:35:05-06:00

From -Anonymous-: For one, the gay manager can not get along with any resident. My neighbor threatened to blow up my house and nothing was done about it! I had my vehicles broken into several times. Windows were broken out on my truck, total cost $900.00. my car stereo was stolen, and ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: You WILL regret it (Not Recommending)

2007-07-19T09:06:41-06:00

From -Anonymous-: If you are a professional,just pass this place up and keep shopping. However, if you are a ghetto bird or trailer trash then by all means, they would love to have you. I lived here for 2 years, and during this time (2001-2003) it turned from a place where young ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: STAY AWAY (Not Recommending)

2007-06-16T00:09:09-06:00

From -Anonymous-: THIS PLACE IS A JOKE I'VE BEEN LIVING THERE ALMOST A YEAR NOW AND I'VE HAD A FEW PROBLEMS TO START MY HEATING BILL OVER THE WINTER WAS OVER 250.00 EVERY MONTH AND MY ROOM STAYED FREEZING COLD WHEN I CALLED THE OFFICE TO COMPLAIN INSTEAD OF THEM COMING OUT ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Please, don't rent at this place!!!!!!! (Not Recommending)

2007-05-16T10:09:16-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Noisy and questionable tenants, nasty grounds, lecherous maintenance people, water leaks, smoke in my apt because the walls were so thin and everyone around me smoked, grounds not well lit, apts being broken into, and just all around not worth the money I was paying, these are just a few ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: No problems yet (Recommending!)

2007-04-19T19:59:18-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I've lived here for a year so far and have not had any problems yet, I've herd about about things but nothing any diferent here then any of the other places around here. Sure the rents a little high but can deal, over all not a bad place I say ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Adequate and Comfortable... (Recommending!)

2007-04-02T15:53:27-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I've read a few of these negative reviews and I have to say something. I lived in Island Club from 2005-2006 and I was one of those tennants with a broke down car sitting in the carport. I am a full time student at IUPUI with a full time job ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Good experience (Recommending!)

2007-02-12T09:38:07-06:00

From madhubora: I lived here for two years by myself, and without a problem. My apartment was in a wooded corner, and gave me ample silence and solitude. The staff was friendly and quick to address every time I called with a problem.
... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Haven't had any big problems (Recommending!)

2006-09-22T12:13:38-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I've lived here for almost a year with no major issues. I know I'm in the minority here, but I can live with that. The place is a bit more ghetto now than when I moved in but I still think it's fine and I'll be re-signing my lease. Could ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: The manager and the drug dealer (Not Recommending)

2006-09-20T13:54:05-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Don't rent from here! The manager is too busy with her drug dealing boyfriend to be at the office. Even if her car is there she isn't. She spends more time in the drug dealer's apartment than the office.

The security sucks. Our car was broken into twice while we were ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Horrible with a capital Sucks! (Not Recommending)

2006-09-15T11:02:32-06:00

From -Anonymous-: We lived in this complex in 2001. We broke our lease after 6 months. We paid the fee to break the lease and then they charged us $100 to clean the place. My wife and I are NEAT FREAKS. Even while we lived in the apartment there was never a ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Manager is a drug dealer! (Not Recommending)

2006-09-07T16:47:46-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I have lived at Island Club for 2 years and have seen it get worse each day. The manager is dating a resident that is known for drug dealing in the area. The manager is never in the office but is regularly seen at this resident's unit. The office staff ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: No thanks. (Not Recommending)

2006-08-21T23:44:58-06:00

From Buster189: My wife and I rented at Island club in 2003. We had so many problems and hated the place so much we broke our lease 8 months in. Management was slow to respond to even the smallest complaint. At one point oour window facing the lake cracked from pressure during ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: A horrible place to live! (Not Recommending)

2006-07-21T11:57:53-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I have lived at Island Club for a year and I have more complaints than likes. First of all, the apartments are falling apart! The walls have cracks in them. The painting job by the staff is horrible. There are leaks everywhere! The patios are nasty and never have been ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Duh (Not Recommending)

2006-06-30T21:58:56-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Just drive through the parking lot before looking at an apartment model. Do the broken down Cadillacs and other 20 year old cars tip you off as to what type of place this has become? If you still decide to move here after seeing that, you dug your own grave, ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Leaving soon... not that heartbroken either (Not Recommending)

2006-06-08T01:08:38-06:00

From -Anonymous-: When I moved into Island Club, I did not have ample opportunity to find a new apartment. I had just taken a new job requiring me to move to Indianapolis. When I moved in, it seemed nice. I didn't notice anything that would really make me question moving in here.

Over ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Great Experience!! (Recommending!)

2006-04-03T09:27:42-06:00

From -Anonymous-: My family and I lived at Island Club for 1 year before buying a home and had a geat experience! From the time we moved in we felt valued and they never dropped the ball for us. Any maintenance issues were handeled promptly and the office staff were always willing ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Don't Move If You Value Yourself (Not Recommending)

2005-11-10T15:53:05-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Looks can be very deceivingThese are beautiful floor plans, and its great to come home to life on the lake. However, I would agree with everyone else; the management tends to let anyone in to the buildings. Scum and the like are there. Its not safe! Watch your stuff; watch ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Unethical-unprofessional (Not Recommending)

2005-11-05T11:52:19-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Any promises that are made to you from the front office you'd better get in writing. They DO NOT honor their verbal agreements.
Also, when considering a transfer they showed me an uncleaned smelly unit. Also did not get a utility bill for 3 months and then sent me an ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Current resident (Not Recommending)

2005-08-08T00:44:29-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Bogus utility charges. Wasn't given utility bill for 3 months when I moved in. Now they are trying to evict me over the arrearage. Not good. ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: gee, I wonder if the last review was written by the manager (Not Recommending)

2005-08-02T12:55:38-06:00

From -Anonymous-: It's apparent that residents are fed up with the ghetto trash they are letting move in here. It's a shame, because this community could have been very pleasant. ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Great place to live! (Recommending!)

2005-03-14T10:45:45-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I have been renting for a few years and have had my best experience so far at Island Club. The floorplans are really great, and my living room is HUGE! I love my vaulted ceilings. The office staff has always been very pleasant and friendly. I never hear my neighbors ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Glad I'm gone (Not Recommending)

2005-02-21T12:31:16-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I liked the lake, was very peaceful after a busy day, however, the new management made it an easy decision to buy my new home. They lowered the rent and let anyone in. Girl in my building got attacked. We weren't notified, even though we had a "neighborhood crime watch." ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Nice but will never live there again (Not Recommending)

2005-02-01T12:58:51-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I like the apartment office before the new staff started. The apartments are very unique and I liked my floor plan. The new office staff act like they do not know what they are doing here. ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: They jam you up with unfair charges when you move out (Not Recommending)

2004-11-28T17:19:32-06:00

From -Anonymous-: When I had a problem with a neighbor and his loud music at 4 in the morning their advice to me was to switch apartments. After paying the required amount to break my lease, I was charged an additional $100 for phantom cleaning costs. They don't care about their tenants. ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: no regrets (Recommending!)

2004-08-04T00:00:00-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I liked living at Island Club. It is a little expensive, but it was wonderful to sit on the deck and enjoy the view. The apts are a little small, but I had a sunken living room, which added the illusion of more space. The staff was wonderful, especially Anna. ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: It's OK, but overpriced. (Recommending!)

2004-06-23T00:00:00-06:00

From -Anonymous-: The community itself was fairly nice and peaceful. They do have a fitness trail, fitness equipment, a pool, and a nice lake. Not all of the apartments face the lake however.

The apartment was tiny. We could barely fit our dresser and bed into the room. The window in ... [click to read full apartment review]