Apartment Ratings | New Gotham Apartments Ratings and Reviews

New Gotham Apartments: Great staff/management, facility & location (Recommending!)

2009-09-21T12:45:13-06:00

From ytpatel: I've been living at the New Gotham Apartments since August 2003 and I haven't wanted to move anywhere else. The location can't be any better. Near the Hudson River path and dog park in one direction and Times Square in the other. The restaurants and bars on 9th Ave are ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Good enough for me (Recommending!)

2009-09-10T07:58:23-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I moved into New Gotham a few months ago and have been very happy with my experience. The Studio apartment is generously sized and has a good layout - rectangular rather than square - so you can absolutely have both a sleeping and living area. The kitchen is separate and ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Great building! (Recommending!)

2009-09-04T15:02:52-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I lived in New Gotham for 3 years and I was very happy all along. Staff are really nice and helpful. The leasing of the apartment was smooth, the handymen have always been helpful, and the doormen will be missed. I would have still stayed longer but I had to ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Bad expereince...bad landlord...poor facilities (Not Recommending)

2009-07-08T09:33:32-06:00

From Mac545: I stayed here for almost two years and never had a pleasant experience.The doormen are snobbish, leasing agent has a very, very bad attitude and the management office is all but tenant friendly. The kitchen flooring sucks and always looking dirty because they have some crappy anti slip tiles which ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Ok, but better nearby (Not Recommending)

2009-05-09T00:12:11-06:00

From -Anonymous-: The building is simply not worth the price.- quite far from subways (good 15 min walk)- no pool, gym costs extra per person- no luxury finishes (granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, quality flooring or cabinets, etc.)- no roof deck- laundry facilities constantly in disrepair and closes at night- group home ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: HORRIBLE MANAGEMENT (Not Recommending)

2009-03-31T08:47:43-06:00

From whitehorse10027: BUILDING IS NOT WORTH THE PRICE. CHECK OTHER PLACES BEFORE YOU RENT. ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Great Place (Recommending!)

2009-03-10T08:17:51-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I've been in this place for the past 2.5 years and its been great. People are friendly and rent is not too high. I would definitely recommend it to my friends. ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: about to be a tenant (Recommending!)

2009-02-05T12:13:49-06:00

From milky22: well Im moving in this march into studo apartment Im very scared now that I c all the reviews you know I didnt think there would be so many negative comments but I cant take everyones response as far as my own because I havent expierenced theGotham as of yet ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Good apartment management, though it is noisy (Recommending!)

2008-10-18T16:29:26-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I've lived at the New Gotham for 2 years now. I face the north side and it's definitely noisy. I'm a heavy sleeper though so doesn't bother me much. Management staff has been very responsive and friendly. The unit I'm has a unique feel so I really liked it from ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Biggest Mistake of My Life Renting from New Gotham (Not Recommending)

2008-06-11T23:19:55-06:00

From -Anonymous-: One of the worst mistakes of my life was renting an apartment at the New Gotham. I wanted to sublease my place for the summer, and their requirements for subleasees was an insurmountable obstacle to subleasing the place. Subleasee's must meet ridiculous income requirements, and since most subleasees are college ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: DON'T DO IT!!! (Not Recommending)

2009-10-04T18:45:29-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Ok I wonder where all these great reviews are coming from. Either these are from people who have had horrid experiences at previous buildings, hence have really low expectations or they are plain liars (recruited by the owner/management) to paint false pictures about this building.First of all, there is nothing, ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Great place! (Recommending!)

2007-10-18T16:19:12-06:00

From -Anonymous-: New Gotham is great. The staff and super are always helpful and friendly, fixing any problems as soon as possible. For New York, the rent is appropriate for what you get and the great location. The gym is nice with the basketball court option that you don't see often, and ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Lived here 2005-2006 (Recommending!)

2007-09-19T15:41:34-06:00

From schizm42: I had a wonderful experience living at New Gotham in 2005-2006. I moved to Kentucky due to work, and am now in Phoenix.Excellent value for the quality of the building. Never any problems with pests or the like.living on the 32nd floor facing South, the views were great, the common ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Love it (Recommending!)

2007-07-22T20:23:37-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Really do, the staff is great, from the concierge to the cleaning guy. They do a good job of keeping the building clean and they're friendly. The location is great for me, as I work nearby, and I like the proximity of the Port Authority. It's also convenient in that ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Incredible. (Recommending!)

2006-08-19T21:17:09-06:00

From lilmeals23: I have almost nothing bad to say about the New Gotham. Ever since the moment I arrived at the building to move in, the ENTIRE staff... from the concierge in the lobby to the cleaning staff, were all extremely friendly and willing to help. My friends and I have converted ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: The Best for your money in the city! (Recommending!)

2006-08-09T23:47:21-06:00

From Cgirl21: I lived at the New Gothem from 2003 to 2004. I had an Alcove Studio (apt 11C!). After searching and searching for "good" apartments in the city and living in nasty ones (East Village!) I finally found the New Gotham. Back then they offered me $1790 for the alcove, and ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Stars, the River and Coffee Shops - I Love It (Recommending!)

2007-02-10T12:38:36-06:00

From lilnyc: Revised to celebrate one year at New Gotham:

I've happily been living at New Gotham since Feb. '06.

The lobby is beautiful, the concierge professional and nice, and maintenance is quick. They send an email when you place a maintenance request, and another when the request has been fufilled.

Before ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: after one year here... (Recommending!)

2005-09-15T23:00:22-06:00

From -Anonymous-: from what I have heard from friends in other buildings this place is better than most. the construction that has been going on is a nightmare. it usually starts around 7am and sometimes will end as late as 9pm. it wakes me up every morning. eventually the building will block ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Positives Outweigh Negtives (Recommending!)

2005-08-31T15:49:03-06:00

From newgothamtenant: I have not lived here too long but I would like to add my 2 cents. The elevator situation is at times problematic. 2 elevators are routinely out of service with one always being out of usage. If someone happens to be moving in, there may be just one elevator ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Started out good. Gone downhill. (Not Recommending)

2008-04-03T16:34:48-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Rumors abound that the library on 43rd Street is selling, so you can expect a developer on the other side of New Gotham. My laundry gets stolen. Elevators are frequently out. And rent increases are $200-700 depending on the amount you pay now and whether it's a one- or two-year ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Lived here 5 years (Recommending!)

2005-03-17T07:54:34-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I've been at New Gotham for 5 years. Good rents. Super is one of the nicest guys around and he always responds to requests. He seems to know every single person by name in the bldg. My view faces North and is totally unonstructed. Great gym.

Not moving anytime soon. ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: I LOVE IT HERE (Recommending!)

2005-01-18T14:32:53-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I just moved here from California and my friend who is in a apt up the block told me about this cool, hip bldg b/w 10th & 11th Avenue that he wanted to move into but his landlord won't let him out of his lease - I guess this is ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Nice building, some strange people, noisy railway (Recommending!)

2004-09-29T14:34:16-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Building's really nice (despite nasty carpets which, to be fair, are being replaced). Good gym, small and overlooked sun deck.

There's a couple of floors of fairly mentally disturbed people (seriously) but none that have caused any bother (except some uncomfortableness in the elevator).

Doormen are great. As are all the ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: great people, great location, make sure you know what you're getting. (Recommending!)

2004-07-09T00:00:00-06:00

From -Anonymous-: First off, I couldnt say nicer things about the place. I would never have moved had job situation forced me too.

The doormen are especially great. They know you, your friends, and help you out all the time. Never had any problems with maintenance (once the first super left and ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Pretty impressive in a great neighborhood (Recommending!)

2004-04-26T00:00:00-06:00

From -Anonymous-: GREAT doorman and staff. Common areas are clean, any urgent problem is promptly addressed. Views on the higher floors are spectacular, although they are building more high rises nearby and obscuring some views, but from the 25th floor and above facing south you can see the Empire State Building, the ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: (Recommending!)

2004-04-15T00:00:00-06:00

From riverhead: ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: did anyone know the phone number of rental office (Not Recommending)

2004-03-22T00:00:00-06:00

From happybird: I tried the number on this page. It´s no longer in service. Does anyone know the contact info of the rental office? Thanks
a lot! ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Did your concierge disappoint you? This reporter wants to talk to you (Not Recommending)

2004-03-04T00:00:00-06:00

From AnnaSM: I?m a reporter for a NYC daily paper and I?m working on a story about people whose building concierges have disaapointed them. Like the one in Chelsea who told a resident he could get her on the guest list of an exclusive club -- and she learned the hard way ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: Better than most, I think (Recommending!)

2003-09-24T00:00:00-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Been here since the building opened. Doormen are all friendly and reliable. All common areas kept very clean. Dry cleaner in building. Gym also, but two larger ones are within a block. Walls aren´t thin; neighbors aren´t noisy. Only complaint is too many dogs; owners let them urinate and defecate ... [click to read full apartment review]

New Gotham Apartments: A good starting place for young professionals (Recommending!)

2002-11-25T00:00:00-06:00

From -Anonymous-: ... [click to read full apartment review]