Apartment Ratings | Island Club Ratings and Reviews

Island Club: I can't believe it! (Not Recommending)

2009-12-02T13:59:16-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I would like to say that although I have not lived at Island Club, I am happy i don't. I had this places chosen between another place based on the sites I have seen. My wife called to get pricing and they laughed and hung up on her. Yes she ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: READ THIS BEFORE YOU SIGN YOUR LEASE (Not Recommending)

2009-10-06T19:08:16-06:00

From hitchiker: This complex was owned by AIMCO earlier btu was sold to connor group...last year. And since then things have gone down hill...The problems:1. Geese shit all over the place... cant bear the stink.2. Clubhouse staff is totally incompetent. They keep changing every month.They dont talk to you properly and give ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Will Rip You Off as Much as Possible (Not Recommending)

2009-09-21T09:33:17-06:00

From am8511: I've lived at Island Club for over three years, and at one point in time I was a happy renter. When previous owners Aimco sold the community a terrible company named the Connor Group, everything went downhill. You must understand that The Connor Group owns an affiliate company named Heartland ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Can't Complain (Recommending!)

2009-07-02T12:55:15-06:00

From buckeyelaw10: I'm a law student at OSU and I've lived here for a yr. I came in when the Conner Group took over and I haven't had any complaints. I heard the previous company went out of business and its probably for a reason. The maintnance staff has always come out ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Stay away from island club! (Not Recommending)

2009-06-02T05:02:09-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I have lived at island club for years, but when the connor group took over everything changed for the worse. I just went to pay my rent and they decided to start a $20 fee just to charge a credit card. Last month the charge was $5 and it was ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: PRIOR RESIDENT OF ISLAND CLUB & CONNOR GROUP PROPERTIES IN GENERAL (Not Recommending)

2009-04-30T00:42:08-06:00

From ohbiteme1961: I lived at Island Club for several years when they were under the old management company and loved it. The Connor Group took over and everything went down immediately except my rent. I was expected to pay as much as new residents. I, too, loved the wildlife. It made the ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Save yourself! New management is terrible! (Not Recommending)

2009-04-29T15:55:37-06:00

From amanda6312: The new management is absolutely terrible! Our disposal stopped working---their maintenance guy says the only way to get it replaced is to complain because they dont want to spend money. No gutters outside above our patio (the whole building) so when it rains, mud runs up on the patio every ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: not nice to foreign peoples (Not Recommending)

2009-04-07T09:08:38-06:00

From india9589: I live columbus for 5 year, never have so many trouble until I move with islnd club. We sign aimco lease, conner group buy property. the trash situation is unbearable, never take the trash, sometime I take my trash to kroger. The big bird put poop all over walking area, ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: New management is no good (Not Recommending)

2009-02-02T09:41:13-06:00

From saynotogoosepoo: My roommate and I really enjoyed these apartments when we first moved in. Nice neighbors, nice management, etc. Then toward the end of our lease when the new management took over, things changed. Billing was always messed up and we never received a timely response. Once we moved out, they ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: GREAT STAFF!!! Amazing Apartment... Great Maintance Staff... (Recommending!)

2009-01-20T10:11:16-06:00

From osubuci4life: I just recently moved into Island Club at the end of NOV. The staff when i first walked in was very helpfull and met me with a smile. I moved to the area for work im currently in military and they helped me to get a place very fast and ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Horrible.... (Not Recommending)

2008-12-03T06:30:58-06:00

From outraged2008: Nothing good to say about this place. We have lived here since April and already want to move out. It was actually descent before the conner group took over.They are extremely rude and have no remorse whatsoever about what is going on.First off, the noise if horrific! I can barely ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Avoid the COnnor Group (Not Recommending)

2008-11-11T07:28:55-06:00

From Tattman72: 2 and half years ago I signed for $544, I fought both raises in my rent up to this years lease of $584. I used to pay $12 for utilities, now its $68!!!! I have an extra $50 on my lease for fees, $20 for a garage, free carport, $20 ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: The worse experience! (Not Recommending)

2009-11-19T07:07:06-06:00

From -Anonymous-: First of all, the staff keeps changing. The staff before was sweet and genuinely carerd about the residents. Now the staff is fake nice and only "cares" about you until they rent to you. The jack your rent up whatever they feel like. I do believe my neighbor went up ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Bogus Fees (Not Recommending)

2008-09-12T18:33:52-06:00

From rainman1004@hotmail.com: I live in Island Club. I've been here for 6 years now. The old aimco staff was courteous and great to work with. When the left and The Connor Group took over somehow fees over $50 extra a month got added. We have to pay a service fee of $10 ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: A Piece of Work (Not Recommending)

2008-09-06T14:03:18-06:00

From schakett6: I just recently moved out of Island Club after living there for two years. I refused to pay the "extra" fees required by Heartland and only sent partial payments. Now that I have received my Move-Out notice from IC, I see that they deducted any fees owed to Heartland from ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Please don't get stuck in a year lease with this new management, you will likely regret it. (Not Recommending)

2008-08-17T14:50:15-06:00

From -Anonymous-: The Island Club apartment complex has gone downhill since The Connor Group took over. Aimco was great, good customer service, attentive to the tenants needs and prompt resolutions to any maintenance concerns, but now it is literally the complete opposite. The connor group does not provide any type of customer ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: The Connor Group (Not Recommending)

2009-04-30T00:57:23-06:00

From ohbiteme: I lived at Island Club from 03-08. Previous owners took pride in their property. The grouds were very inviting and very well maintained. I simply loved living there. Then The Connor Group took over and everything totally colapsed. The flowers died almost immediately due to lack of attention. Trash started ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: not so smooth change in management (Not Recommending)

2008-08-08T14:54:50-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I have lived in the Island Club for three years and I am so upset about the past two months that I have already decided that I am not renewing my lease. I gave them a 90 day notice instead of the required 60 day because I can't wait to ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Avoid this place (Not Recommending)

2008-08-08T15:10:12-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Island Club changed management and they increased everybody's rent significantly. I wish I didn't sign a renewal lease- I'm stuck here and I'm very unhappy. The water/sewage/trash bill is $40 which is $20 more than I used to pay and nobody told us it would increase that much during the ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Going Downhill Quickly (Not Recommending)

2008-07-23T08:39:29-06:00

From StockWatcher21: Take time to read the other review and comments...New management is bad! Same thing has happened to me. Extreamly unprofessional. The apartments are dated. There are dog urin stains on the stairs in my common area from the neighbors and they never clean up after their dog. After 3 years ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: "We do things diffently because we're new" = bad excuse for doing things wrong (Not Recommending)

2008-09-03T10:10:59-06:00

From gettingoutofislandclub: So Island Club has new management since the beginning of July, and they are TERRIBLE. They don't seem to have a clue what's going on in the office in terms of handling people's rents and dealing with things that can affect people's credit. Before them, IC was a decent place ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: 1 year good, 2nd year not so much (Recommending!)

2007-07-10T15:35:00-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I have lived at Island Club for 2 years and will not be renewing my lease that is up in August for several reasons. The 1st year I had no problems, neighbors were quiet, maintenance issues fixed right away. 2nd year they raised rent $10, when I call to negotiate ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: HOTTIES AT THE POOL (Recommending!)

2007-06-21T11:03:19-06:00

From taylor.805@osu.edu: Island Club must pick the hottest people in town to live there. Just moved in. Love my apartment. Love the staff. Everyone is so friendly. Hung out by the pool the other day and met my neighbors. All so nice. ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: BEWARE!!! Staff are BITCHES!!!!!! Geese are nuts and Maintenance is HORRIBLE (Not Recommending)

2007-06-04T09:32:20-06:00

From -Anonymous-: If you answer YES to one or more of the following questions, Island Club is the WAY TO GO!1.) Do you like your apt staff, big - fat - and BITCHY!!!!!!????? Who will YELL at you for calling? Who forgets she works somewhere that people LIVE????? Not just in an ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: City living without the scariness (Recommending!)

2007-05-20T19:47:40-06:00

From cochran.218@osu.edu: I moved here last year from out of state for Grad School.. thank goodness I found this place, becasue all of my friends at other places had break ins, porch fires and one had her car stolen. This is a great place with a friendly, helpful staff. It's tucked away ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Scary Geese (Recommending!)

2007-05-09T08:35:08-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I love it here but when you walk on the path the geese get on the defence and hiss at you. You don't even have to be doing anything. Scary. Lots of poop from them too....... and no lock on the bottom door knob, just the top. ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Lived here 7 years (Recommending!)

2007-03-05T15:21:02-06:00

From lilbit2272: I have lived in Island Club for 7 years. The staff has always been nice. The maintenance has always been quick. The rent is a bit steep for the size - which is why I'm moving. They've been good not to raise my rent too much over the years, but ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: This place was the worst place I ever lived!!! (Not Recommending)

2007-01-19T17:23:47-06:00

From claudia2007: I had the unpleasant experience of living in this community at the begginning of 2006. However, we had to move out because of our jobs. The AIMCO charged us all kinds of penalties for breaking our lease of 1 year. They made us pay almost $2,000 in penalties for a ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Like the place (Recommending!)

2006-12-20T15:00:59-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I just renewed my lease at the Island Club because I really like it here. I have lived here for over 2 years and receive prompt service from maintenance. The office staff is very helpful.

There are a lot of geese but anyone can see that when they move in. ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: What a Joke! (Not Recommending)

2006-12-02T15:38:01-06:00

From reallybadshitman: I just want to make everybody perfectly aware of some of Island Club's "professional" policies.

First of all, you aren't guaranteed any parking spots. If you happen to find a spot anywhere near 50 meters of your entrance, on a regular basis, you should consider yourself priveleged.
Secondly, the duck/goose maneur ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: (Not Recommending)

2006-06-19T21:08:37-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I can hear everything that goes on in the apartment above me. I hear conversations, arguments, and occasionaly will smell cigarette smoke. ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: (Recommending!)

2006-04-30T20:49:22-06:00

From jimjumbo: i have lived at the Island Club for one year and have been very satisfied with my home. the apartment is very quiet, the entrance way is clean, and the office staff has gone above and beyond to make my stay pleasant. i had a minor issue one time and ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: 60/40 (Recommending!)

2006-02-02T16:11:29-06:00

From -Anonymous-: The first issue we have with the Island Club,is parking. Not completely sure that it's the Island Clubs fault...Do people living here realize what a parking space is and what is not?! Many a time I have come home to find plenty of parking spaces open(albeit far from your front ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Great place, Great Staff (Recommending!)

2007-06-10T13:02:44-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I LOVE Island Club! It is a very nice place to live and the staff there is so friendly!!! A PLUS!!!! ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: aimco.com (Not Recommending)

2004-03-24T00:00:00-06:00

From gotogirl: i would suggest that you forget talking to the office staff and going straight to aimco.com click on "resident relations" and email them to tell them your situation. I have heard many people complain about not getting things done etc. but as soon as they email the head aimco people. ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Island Club is illegal company. (Not Recommending)

2004-02-19T00:00:00-06:00

From mros: Hi

My name is Je Gyun Chon who lives in 5422 Bermuda Bay Dr. Apt. 3C. (Island Club on Columbus Ohio)

I am a doctor and came from Republic of Korea on March, 2003 and I have lived in Island Club.
However, I must move out on march/31/2004 because my researches finish ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Nice Place to Live (Recommending!)

2004-02-11T00:00:00-06:00

From clubrenter: This apartment was very nice, and it was clean. The only problem that I had was a bad outlet that smoked when I blew dried my hair-but maintence was quick to fix the problem. The scenery there of the two ponds is very nice. My apartment had cathedral ceilings and ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: The matience people steal! (Not Recommending)

2003-11-13T00:00:00-06:00

From -Anonymous-: I currently live at the Island Club Apartments. Everything seemed okay at first, but soon after items were missing from my apartment. I fully believe it was the matienence man, he was the only one in there. Also, when I complained, the staff was unconcerned. The geese are a problem, ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Worst Decision for a Graduate Student (Not Recommending)

2003-06-25T00:00:00-06:00

From -Anonymous-: If you like loud noise, bass music, puke, garbage in the hallways, and the smell of urine, you would like living here. This is worse than the frat houses at my undergraduate school. I can never study here. Falling asleep is usually not an option either. I signed a two ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: trash club is right (Not Recommending)

2003-04-15T00:00:00-06:00

From -Anonymous-: this place seems to work well for the people who don´t care about how clean their homes are. One of my neighbors throws his junk mail on the ground in front of the mailboxes every day - he fits in well.
The management care nothing about this - when I ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: geese are a serious problem (Not Recommending)

2003-04-06T00:00:00-06:00

From -Anonymous-: Impossible to walk anywhere without stepping in goose shit. They really need to do something about these animals! Everything else is not too bad though. Management is pretty unorganized - sends out handwritten bills made with black marker on the back of paper that is totally unrelated to the bill ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Great Place to live (Recommending!)

2002-10-04T00:00:00-06:00

From -Anonymous-: My husband and I just moved in for 2 months and we love here a lot! Itﾴs on a great location (on COTA bus line & easy to access to OSU): convenient but quiet. Neighbors are mostly graduate students and professionals. The management office is good, and you can reach ... [click to read full apartment review]

Island Club: Island Club should change its name to Trash Club (Not Recommending)

2002-06-22T00:00:00-06:00

From LIVINGINHELLic: I have lived at Island Club for 1 year, and there is no chance in hell i would ever renew my lease. If you like to look out your window and see a bunch of rusty twisted pieces of metal they call carports, have huge gusts of wind come into ... [click to read full apartment review]