C-

New Colony Apartments

1917 S Shields St, Fort Collins, CO 80526
1917 S Shields St, Fort Collins, CO 80526

Floor Plans

Check Availability

New Colony Apartments

 
 
 
 
 
 

epIQ Report Card

In partnership with SatisFacts™

Community epIQ Grade N/A

Ratings & Reviews (53 Reviews)

Filter
  • 5 out of 5
  • 4 out of 5
  • 3 out of 5
  • 2 out of 5
  • 1 out of 5
No reviews match your search.
Prospective Resident Visited 2020
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
06/26/2020
The manager Carrie is extremely rude and unpleasant to deal with. The maintenance guy Mike is a joke and can't fix things properly or in a timely manner. They think they are above the law and treat everyone like ---- including there staff. Everyone that quits… See More
Useful    0
Thanks for voting!
Report
Prospective Resident Visited 2020
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
05/29/2020
Everything was fine until I spoke with Carey Ellis who was the rudest person I have EVER met. She snapped at me and interrupted me when I asked a simple question about the property. She did not want to be there and it showed. See More
Useful    0
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2019 - 2020
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
05/07/2020
Thanks to the office staff for being so helpful and informative during the quarantine! They referred me to the right agency for rental assistance and I qualified! It's always easy to point out what is wrong but every so often maybe mention what is right. See More
Useful    0
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2020
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
05/04/2020
Great apartments! The apartments are a bit older but for the price and location you can't beat it. There is a great park next to the apartments and the neighborhood is quite even though it is off of Shields. The leasing office staff are extremely helpful… See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2020
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
04/02/2020
IF YOU'RE A CSU STUDENT STAY AWAY! This apartment complex is for poor uneducated people with nowhere left to go. If that's you, then hurray! You've found your getaway! The property is disgusting, there are rats and --- on the carpets. The management and owner is… See More
Useful    0
Thanks for voting!
Report
HiThereYall100 • Resident 2018 - 2019
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
06/20/2019
New Colony is a good apartment complex overall, but there are some downsides to it as well. For the price, it's very good, but it's nothing fancy. The area is safe and parking is always available. Maintenance has always fixed things within a day or two.… See More
Useful    0
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2018
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
07/16/2018
I've never left a review before but I feel I have to in order to protect people from ever moving here. The staff seems friendly at first but if you ever need anything from them they become extremely rude. If something is broken in your apartment,… See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2016 - 2017
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
05/11/2018
Y'all, save yourself for this nightmare of this place. I tried to give them the benefit of the doubt because the place is so old, but they screwed the pooch on that when they threatened to evict us for having a housewarming party. We had 7… See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
renterQ12345 • Resident 2015 - 2016
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
06/19/2017
Do not rent from here if you expect to get your deposit back. They will come up with "reasons" to keep your money. They told us our animals peed all over the living room carpet (not true) and offered to show pictures. We didn't waste our… See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2015 - 2016
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
12/09/2016
New colony is a joke. The apartment walls ooze yellowish brown sludge. I had black mold under my bathtub from half --- plumbing, which went into my closet and they wouldn't even agree it was mold, to them it was "organic growth" and just sprayed bleach… See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2016
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
10/26/2016
I really don't understand these negative reviews. I've had a great experience with New Colony. If you are a good tenant and have your stuff together, they will be good to you and easy to work with. Apartments aren't bad at all for their price, especially… See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
chelseahansen • Resident 2015 - 2016
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
10/03/2016
After my experience of living at and renting with New Colony, I would never recommend it to anyone. I lived here twice, and while the first time was difficult, there were several problems that should have caused me to not rent here again. The second time… See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2012 - 2014
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
07/25/2016
They'll force you out of your apartment to renovate and charge some other poor soul too much money to live there. They'll also make you pay a cleaning fee on your apartment that's about to be renovated, and have zero sympathy when you try explaining that… See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
nee colony are bad • Resident 2015 - 2016
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
01/13/2016
old out dated and falling apart. way over sold and maintenance is a joke my patio colts water and leeks it in to my bedroom See More
Useful    0
Thanks for voting!
Report
Jim1202 • Resident 2015
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
10/17/2015
This place is a poorly managed -----show. They won't hesitate to do you dirty either. It's not worth the headache. There are plenty of other places around town. See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
Swampsnake91 • Resident 2015
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
09/02/2015
This place is awful..rent to expensive things are broken, my car has been broken into its a disaster, I completely regret moving in here April 1st 2015, and if you do anything to "violate" terms and conditions they immediately threaten to evict you.. b i t… See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2014 - 2015
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
01/29/2015
Do not rent here. The landlord Sandy is either an alcoholic or a pill popper and cannot be trusted. She does not care about what actual law is only what she thinks is law in the colony. She also has little minions walking around constantly peeking… See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
Prospective Resident Visited 2014
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
12/06/2014
Agh. Wouldn't recommend to anyone. The manager is hateful. They don't keep up with the upkeep. See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2013 - 2014
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
03/22/2014
New Colony has actually been my favorite place to live during my time in Ft. Collins. The other reviews are all fairly negative, but I simply do not understand why everyone complains so much about it. I absolutely love the location. My unit is on the… See More
Useful    0
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2013
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
10/05/2013
Well, Its odd how the recommendation on this site has gone from less then 3% all the way to 20 % in just three weeks. This is because ----------------------------------- bump it. I worked at this place for about 3 months. I have never seen such a… See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2013
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
10/05/2013
A great place to live with a small family. The park is very close and there are a bunch of nature trails nearby. Very quiet with lots of big beautiful trees. I love being able to sit on my patio and drink a glass of wine… See More
Useful    0
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2012 - 2013
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
10/01/2013
This is an older complex and various units have been renovated at different times since its construction. Because of that you get really good units and pretty 'meh' units for the price. But honestly, my apartment on the south end of the complex is one of… See More
Useful    0
Thanks for voting!
Report
COcouple85 • Resident 2013
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
09/26/2013
We have lived here for several months now and have been very happy. I honestly do not understand why there are so many negative reviews on here. Our apartment faces Rolland Moore park and the Spring Creek trail, which has been great for us in every… See More
Useful    0
Thanks for voting!
Report
Resident 2010 - 2013
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
08/21/2013
When we needed something fixed, they were on it. However the sign outside on Shields Street states "Free Cable" and "Free Rent". I never got free rent and yes there is basic cable. However, and here's the not so fun part, we lived there for three… See More
Useful    0
Thanks for voting!
Report
dudemanner • Prospective Resident Visited 2013
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
07/16/2013
I looked at New Colony, but passed. The first thing that put me off was the management/office staff openly discussing residents and prospective residents financial information over the phone so that all around can hear. While I was there I was treated to an applicants name… See More
Useful    1
Thanks for voting!
Report
 Updated Review
Rating Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Neighborhood
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
Useful    
Thanks for voting!  

Manager

 
·

Features & Amenities

Laundry

  • Laundry Connections in Unit
  • Laundry On-Site
  • Laundry in Units

Disclaimer: Features and Amenities data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive features and amenities offered.

Pets

  • Dogs Allowed
    Deposit: Required
    Rent: Required
    Restrictions: Breed restrictions apply.
  • Cats Allowed
    Deposit: Required
    Rent: Required

Disclaimer: Pet Policy data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive pet policies offered.

Floor Plans & Pricing

Studio, 1 Bathroom

  • Price
    Price

    $1,804

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    Studio

1 Bedrooms, 1 Bathroom

  • Price
    Price

    $1,136

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    1 Bedroom

2 Bedrooms, 1 Bathroom

  • Price
    Price

    $1,029

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    2 Bedrooms

Disclaimer: Floor Plans data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive floor plans offered.

Questions & Answers (1)

Your question has been submitted!

Please allow up to 24 hours for your answer to be visible to the public.

·
Type your answer:
Please allow up to 24 hours for your answer to be visible to the public.

Are there surveillance cameras on site?

Anonymous · March, 19 2018
Please allow up to 24 hours for your answer to be visible to the public.
No answers yet. Be the first to answer.

Frequently Asked

What are noise levels like at New Colony Apartments?
The community is rated 3.4/5 stars, which is considered having quiet noise levels on average.

How satisfied are residents with the upkeep and overall appearance of the grounds at New Colony Apartments?
The community is rated 3.2/5 stars, signifying much satisfaction on average.

How safe is New Colony Apartments?
The community is rated 2.6/5 stars, which is considered being moderately safe on average.

How satisfied are residents with the neighborhood
The community is rated 3.2/5 stars, signifying much satisfaction on average.

How effective was the maintenance team when resolving your problem?
The community is rated 2.6/5 stars, which is considered being moderately effective on average.

What is the pet policy at New Colony Apartments?
No pet policy available

What types of floor plans are available?
Studio, 1 Bath and 1 Bed, 1 Bath and 2 Beds, 1 Bath


New Colony Apartments Gallery

Resident Uploaded Photos

Similar Properties

Image of Mason Street Flats in Fort Collins, CO

Mason Street Flats

Fort Collins, CO

New Colony Apartments is an apartment in Fort Collins in zip code 80526. This community has a Studio - 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom, and is for rent for $1,029 - $1,804. Nearby cities include Loveland, Windsor, Johnstown, Berthoud, and Ault. 80525, 80521, 80251, 80525, and 80524 are nearby zip codes.

  • Price

  • Sq. Ft.

  • Availability

  • Model

New Colony Apartments

Provided by Property Management

Management Photos (0)

    Provided by Other Residents

    Resident Photos (3)

    • (Resident photo uploaded on 09/26/2013) Image of New Colony Apartments in Fort Collins, CO
    • (Resident photo uploaded on 09/26/2013) Image of New Colony Apartments in Fort Collins, CO
    • (Resident photo uploaded on 09/26/2013) Image of New Colony Apartments in Fort Collins, CO
      Back To Top