Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes
#605 #5 #19

What is epIQ?

Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes

720 Buffalo Run Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46227
(420 Reviews & Surveys)
$1,071 - $1,521/mo
Share Feedback
Write a Review
Leave a Video ReviewNew

Floor Plans & Pricing

1 Bedroom

Scarlet

1 Bed, 1 Bath | 653 sq. ft.

$1,131 - $1,181

3 Available Units

See Floor Plan Details

Ruby

1 Bed, 1 Bath | 512 sq. ft.

$1,071 - $1,121

See Floor Plan Details

Crimson

1 Bed, 1 Bath | 690 sq. ft.

$1,271

See Floor Plan Details

2 Bedrooms

Ebony

2 Beds, 2 Baths | 900 sq. ft.

$1,421 - $1,471

3 Available Units

See Floor Plan Details

Raven

2 Beds, 2 Baths | 903 sq. ft.

$1,471 - $1,521

3 Available Units

See Floor Plan Details

Onyx

2 Beds, 1 Bath | 878 sq. ft.

$1,321 - $1,371

2 Available Units

See Floor Plan Details

Sable

2 Beds, 1 Bath | 895 sq. ft.

$1,396 - $1,446

1 Available Unit

See Floor Plan Details

Disclaimer: Special, prices and availabilities subject to change.

epIQ Ratings

What is epIQ?

The epIQ Index gives you an accurate and authentic understanding of what life at a community is like prior to signing a lease, using a familiar letter grade & report card format.

epIQ Report Card

In partnership with SatisFacts™

Community epIQ Grade

A
A

Renter Ratings

A

Review Ratings

Noise

4.4

Grounds

4.4

Safety

4.0

Office Staff

4.5

Maintenance

4.6

Neighborhood

4.6

Survey Ratings

SatisFacts™ Tour Survey

SatisFacts™ Move-In Survey

SatisFacts™ Maintenance Survey

SatisFacts™ Renewal Survey

Review Count

A+

Number of reviews in the past 365 days

58

Manager’s Review Engagement

A+

Percentage of reviews responded to

100.00%

Manager’s Review Reply Time

B+

Average time to respond to reviews

4.17 days

View Community Timeline
View Community Timeline

Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes Reviews

(210)
Verified
Reviews with the Verified Badge are from residents or prospects surveyed directly from SatisFacts™ at the community, ensuring reviews are from real residents or prospects!

Sort:

  • Newest Activity
  • Recently Lived In
  • Review Rating
Review Author Icon

Resident 1143589

Verified Resident 2023

5/23/2023

We only moved in a week ago but any maintenance problem we had (which have only been one minor easy fix problem) it was called and fixed the next day! The apartments are super nice and we feel safe at all times here

    Manager

    5/23/2023

    Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes
    We appreciate your kind review of Buffalo Creek. We strive to provide a great place to live and are glad we are living up to that goal thus far. If you need anything at all, please do not hesitate to reach out. Thanks for choosing to make your home with us!
    Review Author Icon

    Resident 1143565

    Verified Resident 2019 - 2023

    5/23/2023

    People have been nice. Geese can be an issue from time to time around mating season, but that's expected anywhere near a lake/pond. Parking can sometimes be an issue later in the afternoon if you don't have a carport, but that's an easy fix

      Manager

      5/23/2023

      Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes
      Thank you for taking the time to review our community. We're glad that you have found everyone to be nice, we do have good people. The geese are a little crazy, but we try to minimize their issues so they aren't too much of a bother. We'd love to know how we could improve to earn 5 stars. Please reach out if you have suggestions or need anything.
      Review Author Icon

      Resident 1141432

      Verified Resident 2021 - 2023

      5/16/2023

      So far, we are very pleased with our apartment and its surroundings. I am very pleased to see that the roofs are being replaced and that dead trees are being cut down. It is my understanding that perhaps some of the apartments may have… See More>
        Manager

        5/16/2023

        Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes
        Thank you for your kind 5-star review. We appreciate our residents and are excited about the improvements being made. There's a lot of good things in the works at Buffalo Creek and we're glad you are here for it! Please don't hesitate to reach out if you need anything or have any suggestions.
        Review Author Icon

        Resident 1139368

        Verified Resident 2019 - 2023

        5/9/2023

        Quiet and beautiful neighborhood and safe. I ordered online all the time and nothing was ever stolen. Also, maintenance was always friendly and had a quick response. I also liked the trash picked up regularly from the dumpster.

          Manager

          5/10/2023

          Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes
          Thank you for your feedback and for choosing us as your place to call home. Our team takes pride in providing top-notch service to all of our residents, so we are pleased to hear that your experience reflects this and that you are happy with the community.
          Review Author Icon

          Resident 1139259

          Verified Resident 2016 - 2023

          5/9/2023

          It's really a nice community to live...the surroundings are very good and clean..the staff is very helpful..I never had any service issues..this community has dog park as well...they have really nice big apartments at the affordable rent..

            Manager

            5/12/2023

            Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes
            We appreciate your review! At Buffalo Creek, we truly value our residents and always appreciate their feedback. Thank you for your compliment about our staff and community. We look forward to providing you with excellent service during your residency and would love to know how we could have earned a 5-stars. Please reach out if we can assist you in any way.
            Review Author Icon

            Resident 1139231

            Verified Resident 2022 - 2023

            5/9/2023

            Poor management, poor maintenance, over priced, overrated. It's better to rent a house than at this community. Waste everywhere, both from dogs and geese. Not to mention the trashy neighbors who are lazy and leave stinky garbage outside their doors for days.

              Manager

              5/9/2023

              Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes
              Thank you for taking the time to provide your feedback. We are so sorry that your experience at Buffalo Creek has not met your expectations. We are under new ownership and would appreciate more information about the issues that you have had. It is our goal to continually improve and we take all resident concerns seriously. Please reach out to the leasing office at your earliest convenience so that we can understand what needs to be addressed.
              Review Author Icon

              Resident 1137354

              Verified Resident 2023

              5/4/2023

              Great experience except for the cleanliness of creek behind my apartment. Creek needs improvement. Every thing else seems to be fine. I liked the greenery around the houses and also the close to nature appearance.

                Manager

                5/8/2023

                Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes
                We are glad you've had a great experience thus far. Our goal is to provide you with a great place to call home. Thank you for bringing the creek issue to our attention, we will most certainly look into that. Thanks for taking the time to review our community, we're happy you're here.
                Review Author Icon

                Resident 1136638

                Verified Resident 2023

                5/2/2023

                The Staff team Heather and Michelle are very helpful and collaborative. The apartment condition loos good. Just the road need to be maintain. Overall, looks a good and safe community to live. --------------

                  Manager

                  5/8/2023

                  Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes
                  Thank you so much for your 5-star review, we appreciate your feedback. We're glad you are a part of our community. If there is anything you need please do not hesitate to reach out.
                  Review Author Icon

                  anonymous

                  Resident 2020 - 2021

                  8/31/2021

                  DO NOT LIVE HERE!! I’ve lived here for over a year and in the past few months struggled with a neighbor harassing me, calling me vulgar names, flipping me off, stealing my packages, and ultimately keying my car. I have gone to the police and… See More>
                    Review Author Icon

                    Sarahy175

                    Resident 2020 - 2021

                    5/25/2021

                    Please do not live here. The manager at this place is awful and extremely rude not to mention she’s probably racist!!! My AC has been bad for several days to be exact almost a whole week, the temp outside is nearly 92 degrees and the… See More>
                      Review Author Icon

                      anonymous

                      Resident 2019

                      8/8/2019

                      This has been one of the worst places I've ever lived. First off, the apartments are entirely too small to be paying such a large amount of money. (They told me the rent was going up when I was moving out!!) outdated appliances, ugly kitchen,… See More>
                        Review Author Icon

                        anonymous

                        Resident 2017 - 2019

                        4/26/2019

                        This was such a bad apartment complex. I lived here for 2 years. They try to get money out of you all the time. They charge if you don't pick your dog poop up which is normal but it doesn't make a difference when there… See More>
                          Review Author Icon

                          anonymous

                          Resident 2015 - 2017

                          11/1/2017

                          There is no way that I would recommend this apartment complex to anyone based only on the management and staff. I refuse to talk to anyone but Amber. I moved in 2 years ago and the management then was great. But as the management has… See More>
                            Review Author Icon

                            anonymous

                            Resident 2010 - 2014

                            9/2/2017

                            I lived here for 3 1/2 years and moved out in 2013 (only because I bought a house). I recently sold my house and started my apartment search to prepare for a possible out of state job transfer in the near future. I looked… See More>
                              Review Author Icon

                              anonymous

                              Resident 2015 - 2017

                              8/4/2017

                              DO NOT LIVE HERE! This place is a joke. They are a melicious management staff. They add time to your lease contract and retaliate against you when you try to work it out by changing your monthly rent with white out on your lease slip,… See More>
                                Review Author Icon

                                mnmcleish

                                Resident 2016 - 2017

                                6/1/2017

                                I do not usually leave reviews, but I was shocked when I looked at the reviews for Buffalo Creek. I have lived in three apartment complexes in the past 4 years and Buffalo Creek Apartments has been by far my favorite and the best experience.… See More>
                                  Review Author Icon

                                  anonymous

                                  Resident 2015 - 2017

                                  4/24/2017

                                  I highly do NOT recommend. If you are looking for good reviews to appease your mind, go find those and ignore all the red flags that several people are giving you via reviews online. The only thing I would like to state in my review… See More>
                                    Review Author Icon

                                    anonymous

                                    Resident 2015 - 2017

                                    2/3/2017

                                    I have been here for 3 years now and I have no clue why I continue to stay. For the price of what I pay for a 1 bedroom, I could get a small house a little further south of this location. The apartments are… See More>
                                      Review Author Icon

                                      cooperliza

                                      Resident 2016 - 2017

                                      1/3/2017

                                      Lived here for almost a year, the staff is rude at times, and maintenance is okay and comes within a few days. Kitchen t are outdated and barely work, especially my dishwasher that holds water and leaks when used. Cabinets are outdated. MAJOR SPIDER INFESTATION!… See More>
                                        Review Author Icon

                                        mcbj

                                        Resident 2015

                                        10/15/2015

                                        Do not come here. The managing company is rude, dishonest and arrogant. They make issues with the tenant trying to charge fees that they cannot justify.

                                          Review Author Icon

                                          starr12

                                          Resident 2012 - 2015

                                          9/25/2015

                                          I never leave reviews but after checking out some of these reviews I felt like i needed to update this page because I would recommend this property to EVERYONE and I know most of my neighborhood friends feel the same. The maintenance staff is incredible.… See More>
                                            Review Author Icon

                                            sweet1evie

                                            Resident 2011 - 2015

                                            9/1/2015

                                            We're going on year 3 here and we would recommend this place to you. The good: David in maintenance is as good as they come. He has went above and beyond and is very kind even fixed something not on our list because he… See More>
                                              Review Author Icon

                                              anonymous

                                              Resident 2012 - 2014

                                              1/29/2015

                                              TERRIBLE, HORRIBLE, no good management. First week I move in, we brought our own washer/dryer, we hooked it up.ourselves. well little did we know that there was a specific hole to put the tube in when eater gets drained. We'll we accidentally pit it in… See More>
                                                Review Author Icon

                                                black.audrey

                                                Resident 2013 - 2014

                                                1/8/2015

                                                Apart from the good apartment layout (2 bed/2 bath), this place was a disaster. First, we were invested with bugs. Spiders, silverfish, centipedes--from Day 1. The maintenance staff and I became very friendly, because they were out 3-4 times per month. Tammy the manager is… See More>
                                                  Review Author Icon

                                                  Jg44029307

                                                  Resident 2013 - 2014

                                                  12/9/2014

                                                  We have lived in Buffalo Creek for 1.5 years now. This our 2nd apartment in the complex and we absolutely love it here. The apartment itself is well designed with large window that let in a lot of light. The views are amazing as well.… See More>

                                                    Features & Amenities

                                                    Parking
                                                    • Covered Parking
                                                    Pets
                                                    • Cats Allowed
                                                      Fee: $300. Rent: $30. Pet Limit: 2. Comments: We are Pet Friendly! However, certain breed restrictions apply. No weight limit. $300 non-refundable fee per apartment. $30 pet rent per month per pet. Two pets maximum per apartment.
                                                      Less Info
                                                      More Info
                                                    • Dogs Allowed
                                                      Fee: $300. Rent: $30. Pet Limit: 2. Comments: We are Pet Friendly! However, certain breed restrictions apply. No weight limit. $300 non-refundable fee per apartment. $30 pet rent per month per pet. Two pets maximum per apartment.
                                                      Less Info
                                                      More Info
                                                    Other
                                                    • Air Conditioner
                                                    • Basketball Court
                                                    • Clubhouse
                                                    • Courtyard
                                                    • Fitness Center
                                                    • On-Site Maintenance
                                                    • On-Site Management
                                                    • Playground
                                                    • Pool
                                                    • Short Term Lease Available
                                                    Show Less
                                                    Show More

                                                    Leasing

                                                    Located on the south side of Indianapolis, Indiana, across from desirable Greenwood, we are enveloped by lush trees and 5 picturesque lakes. Only moments away from grocery, eateries, and retail with easy access to highways. We offer seven unique layouts with pet-friendly one and two-bedroom floor plans. Enjoy premium features such as stainless steel appliances, updated kitchens with breakfast bar and pantry, large walk-in closets, personal balconies, central air and heat, and spacious closets. See why our apartments for rent in Indianapolis, IN are an excellent choice for you.
                                                    Show Less

                                                    Office Hours

                                                    • Sunday: Closed
                                                    • Monday - Friday: 10:00 AM - 06:00 PM
                                                    • Saturday: Closed
                                                    This community is managed by

                                                    The Ardizzone Group

                                                    A
                                                    A
                                                    Communities
                                                    14

                                                    Questions & Answers (1)

                                                    Anonymous
                                                    Asked on: 03/19/2018
                                                    Q: What is security like?

                                                    Frequently Asked

                                                    Based on 420 number of votes by renters, Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes is currently rated 4 out of 5 stars.
                                                    Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes is rated 4.4/5 stars in our renters grounds survey, which is considered good. The grounds are generally well maintained and attractive.
                                                    Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes is rated 4.6/5 stars in our renters maintenance survey, which is considered excellent. The maintenance team is very responsive and effective in addressing issues.
                                                    Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes is rated 4.4/5 stars in our renters noise survey, which is considered good. The noise level is generally tolerable, with occasional disruptions.
                                                    Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes is rated 4/5 stars in our renters safety survey, which is considered good. The complex is generally safe, with occasional minor safety concerns.
                                                    Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes is rated 4.6/5 stars in our renters neighborhood survey, which is considered excellent. The complex is located in a very desirable and safe neighborhood with convenient access to local attractions and services.
                                                    Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes is rated 4.5/5 stars in our renters staff survey, which is considered excellent. The staff is extremely helpful and responsive to resident needs.
                                                    Managers have responded to 100% of their community reviews in the past year.
                                                    Managers have replied within 4.17 days to their community reviews in the past year.
                                                    The Ardizzone Group
                                                    Cats Allowed
                                                    Fee: $300
                                                    Rent: $30
                                                    Pet Limit: 2
                                                    Comments: We are Pet Friendly! However, certain breed restrictions apply. No weight limit. $300 non-refundable fee per apartment. $30 pet rent per month per pet. Two pets maximum per apartment.
                                                    Dogs Allowed
                                                    Fee: $300
                                                    Rent: $30
                                                    Pet Limit: 2
                                                    Comments: We are Pet Friendly! However, certain breed restrictions apply. No weight limit. $300 non-refundable fee per apartment. $30 pet rent per month per pet. Two pets maximum per apartment.
                                                    1 Bed, 1 Bath
                                                    2 Beds, 1 Bath
                                                    2 Beds, 2 Baths

                                                    Contact Property

                                                    Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes

                                                    April 2024

                                                    Sun
                                                    Mon
                                                    Tue
                                                    Wed
                                                    Thu
                                                    Fri
                                                    Sat
                                                    1
                                                    2
                                                    3
                                                    4
                                                    5
                                                    6
                                                    7
                                                    8
                                                    9
                                                    10
                                                    11
                                                    12
                                                    13
                                                    14
                                                    15
                                                    16
                                                    17
                                                    18
                                                    19
                                                    20
                                                    21
                                                    22
                                                    23
                                                    24
                                                    25
                                                    26
                                                    27
                                                    28
                                                    29
                                                    30
                                                    Beds

                                                    0

                                                    Baths

                                                    0

                                                    Buffalo Creek Apartment Homes is a 512 - 903 sq. ft. apartment in Indianapolis in zip code 46227. This community has a 1 - 2 Beds, 1 - 2 Baths, and is for rent for $1,071 - $1,521. Nearby cities include Beech Grove, Speedway, Warren, Lawrence, and Whitestown.

                                                    Your privacy and identity are important to us. Please review the Terms and Guidelines before sharing private or non-public information with matches.