Mayfield Green Cooperative

5537 W 44th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Resident of this community?
Tell us what you think!

Check Availability

Mayfield Green Cooperative

 
 
 
 
 
 

ApartmentRatings Property Breakdown

OVERALL SCORE
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
0%RECOMMENDED
THIS PROPERTY
VS
74%CITY AVERAGE

Ratings & Reviews

Filter
  • 5 out of 5
  • 4 out of 5
  • 3 out of 5
  • 2 out of 5
  • 1 out of 5
No reviews match your search.
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
Mayfield Green Cooperative Manager

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2015 - 2017 Not Recommended
Reviewed 04/12/2017
I have never been so disappointed in an apartment complex as I am with Mayfield Green. I can't even explain in words all the stress I've experienced from living there. Management is seriously POOR!!!!! They are all about money/charging expensives but don't even provide a service… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2010 - 2015 Recommended
Reviewed 09/18/2015
All staff are nice Except ONE PERSON IN THE OFFICE THE RUDEST PERSON ON PLANET EARTH VERY UNPROFESSIONAL ALWAYS HAVE A SNOTTY ATTITUDE IM PRAYING GOD HEALS ALL HER BROKEN PLACES, SHE MAKE EVERYONE NOT WANT TO COME TO THE OFFICE FOR ANYTHING HER ATTITUDE AND… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2011 - 2015 Not Recommended
Reviewed 07/08/2015
The office attendants are RUDE for no reason and horribly lack people skills. They talk to you any kind of way and I have had a complaint on my tub open for at least two and a half months. The lining has come up. There has… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
jffj617 • Resident 2001 - 2014 Recommended
Reviewed 04/22/2014
April 19, 2014 SAY WHAT !? . You are not happy living at Mayfield Green. You want to blame the board every time your rent goes up. You say that the board is not complying to your every wish and concerns, well lets take a look… See More
(Resident Photo) Image of Mayfield Green Cooperative in Indianapolis, IN(Resident Photo) Image of Mayfield Green Cooperative in Indianapolis, IN
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2014 Not Recommended
Reviewed 04/10/2014
I would NEVER recommend anyone to live there!!!! They USED to be affordable!! They go up on the rent every 6-8 months stating its for maintenance fees insurance and supplies but NOTHING gets fixed!!!! They have the nerve to do inspections to make sure that the… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
dnow38 • Resident 2011 - 2013 Recommended
Reviewed 07/26/2013
I live in Mayfield green currently, and I feel safe and secure in my home. I love the fact that the sherriff is always around the premises, which I hope it stays that way. I like how the staff keeps the grounds clean. I just hate… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
lovesand6002 • Resident 2004 - 2013 Recommended
Reviewed 07/11/2013
It is very unfortunate that I am moving. Only because I have a better job offer in another state! Mayfield Green is and always be my home. Some of the staff are family and they make you feel like you are part of the family. Thats… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2009 - 2013 Not Recommended
Reviewed 05/30/2013
I'm going to give you the COMPLETE truth about MFG. I lived there for 4 1/2 recently moving out in March. (Thank God)I'm writing this review because I viewed this site before I moved in 5 years ago. So I know its helpful. First, the office… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2009 - 2013 Recommended
Reviewed 05/23/2013
I've lived at Mayfield Green for three years now and I never new they had a website. I actually love it here. My kids goto the center attached everyday. They aren't the quickest to respond to my service request but once I had an emergency and… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2013 Not Recommended
Reviewed 04/30/2013
I wouldn't recommend this place to my enemy. The apartments are worn and outdated in the inside. The office staff are rude. The average employee would be terminated for how they treat their occupants but not them. The whole staff is ran by family memebers. The… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
CommunityMinded • Resident 2012 Recommended
Reviewed 12/12/2012
I have been living in Mayfield Green for several months. I do not have anything bad to say. The grounds are well maintained. The unit size vs. cost is a great deal. And I feel secure in my home. I appreciate the security that is provided… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2012 Not Recommended
Reviewed 06/28/2012
Majority of the staff is related and they play favoritism amoung the residence. Very unproffessional and ignorant See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2011 - 2012 Not Recommended
Reviewed 06/27/2012
I have never been so disappointed in anything in my life! We cannot wait to leave.
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Gaynell • Resident 2012 Recommended
Reviewed 03/18/2012
O my God is all this really happening here. I can't believe all these comments I just read. What a change from what it use to be when I live here over 27 years ago.
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
CARYJONES56 • Resident 2012 - 0 Not Recommended
Reviewed 03/17/2012
I HAVE BEEN A RESIDENT OF MAYFIELD GREEN FOR THE PAST 19 YEARS. IT IS TIME FOR A CHANGE. THE MANAGER,OFFICE STAFF AND THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS THERE NEED TO BE A CHANGE THESE PEOPLE HAVE BEEN HOLDING THESE POSITIONS FOR YEARS. I BELIEVE THAT THE… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2011 - 2012 Not Recommended
Reviewed 03/07/2012
I'm happy that i will be moving soon. I only stayed for a year because they (the staff) are ------. I feel sorry for the people who have had to live here for many years. Things were always breaking down. The cops came out too many… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2001 Not Recommended
Reviewed 07/15/2011
They are alot of coniving people in this neighborhood. You have the maintence that steal when they come in your home. They are all family working in that building so therefore it is really unorganized and unfair. They think that everything is unknown but we all… See More
(Resident Photo) Image of Mayfield Green Cooperative in Indianapolis, IN
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2008 - 2011 Not Recommended
Reviewed 03/28/2011
I have lived in Mayfield Green for a little over 2 years. The staff is nosy and they have no idea how to talk to adults. The are ignorant and petty. They want me to sign another lease while I am waiting to get in my… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2006 - 2008 Not Recommended
Reviewed 09/13/2010
It appears that the staff at Mayfield Green probably haven't graduated from high school, let alone college. They do illegal things like entering your apartment without notice, allowing neighbors to play loud music, make it easy for people to rob you by putting your address on… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2009 - 2010 Recommended
Reviewed 04/19/2010
I've been here for about one year and I am still content. ready to sign for another year. Its safe and clean and cozy.
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2009 - 2010 Not Recommended
Reviewed 02/18/2010
OMG..since day one of my move in this place has been a total nightmare. Management sucks,everyone in the office is in some way related daughter, sons baby momma,sons girlfriend all whom have a lack of respect for the tenants. Board of directors are old folks whom… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2009 - 2010 Not Recommended
Reviewed 01/23/2010
WE MOVED INTO THESE APARTMENTS THINKING WITH A FRESH NEW START N AFFORDABLE NICE LIVING SHOOTTT WE DIDNT KNOW WE WERE COMPLETTELY WRONG -FIRST THEY STOLE CDS FROM OUR CAR -SECOND THEY STOLE OUR CAR!!! -.- -THIRD THE OFFICE STAFF ARE SOO COMPLETELY RUDE NOT HELPFUL… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 1996 - 2009 Recommended
Reviewed 07/28/2009
I have lived in Mayfield Green for over 25 years. I have raised all of my children and now my grandchildren on this beautiful property. Over the last 25 years I have watched various Boards of Directors and Management Company's doing various upgrades, in fact, some… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2009 Recommended
Reviewed 07/27/2009
I've been living at Mayfield a few months now and I really love it here. The community is clean, the staff is helpful, and I feel safe. They keep communication open with the residence and I am just very pleased. My town home is affordable, it… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2003 - 2009 Not Recommended
Reviewed 05/13/2009
They don't enforce the so caleed "no parking" rule for guests of tenants and they NEVER give you sufficient notice of a contractor's arrival. You might come home one day, as I did, and find your entire bedroom closet ramshacked by contractors to the point that… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report

Features & Amenities

Laundry

  • Laundry Connections in Unit
  • Laundry in Units

Disclaimer: Features and Amenities data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive features and amenities offered.

Floor Plans & Pricing

Studio, 1 Bathroom

  • Price

    $909

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    Studio

1 Bedrooms, 1 Bathroom

  • Price

    $676

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    1 Bedroom

2 Bedrooms, 1 Bathroom

  • Price

    $869

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    2 Bedrooms

2 Bedrooms, 1.5 Bathrooms

  • Price

    $786

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    2 Bedrooms

3 Bedrooms, 1.5 Bathrooms

  • Price

    $895

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    3 Bedrooms

3 Bedrooms, 2.5 Bathrooms

  • Price

    $883

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    3 Bedrooms

Disclaimer: Floor Plans data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive floor plans offered.

Questions & Answers (1)

Your question has been submitted!

Please allow up to 24 hours for your answer to be visible to the public.

·
Type your answer:
Please allow up to 24 hours for your answer to be visible to the public.

Can you hear your neighbors?

Anonymous · March, 19 2018
Please allow up to 24 hours for your answer to be visible to the public.
No answers yet. Be the first to answer.

Similar Properties

Image of Abney Lakes Apartments in Indianapolis, IN

Abney Lakes Apartments

Indianapolis, IN

Mayfield Green Cooperative is an apartment in Indianapolis in zip code 46254. This community has a Studio - 3 bedroom, 1 - 2.5 bathroom, and is for rent for $676 - $909. Nearby cities include Whitestown, Beech Grove, Warren, Speedway, and Pike. 46278, 46228, 46224, 46222, and 46224 are nearby zip codes.

  • Price

  • Sq. Ft.

  • Availability

  • Model

Mayfield Green Cooperative

Provided by Property Management

Management Photos (0)

    Provided by Other Residents

    Resident Photos (2)

    • (Resident photo uploaded on 04/22/2014) Image of Mayfield Green Cooperative in Indianapolis, IN
    • (Resident photo uploaded on 07/15/2011) Image of Mayfield Green Cooperative in Indianapolis, IN
      Back To Top