Oaks of Eagle Creek

5483 Holly Springs Drive West, Indianapolis, IN 46254

Resident of this community?

Tell us what you think!

ApartmentRatings Property Breakdown

RENTER RATING
Based on 196 
Reviews
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
70%RECOMMENDED
THIS PROPERTY
VS
74%CITY AVERAGE

Ratings & Reviews

Filter
  • 5 out of 5
  • 4 out of 5
  • 3 out of 5
  • 2 out of 5
  • 1 out of 5
No reviews match your search.
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 658446 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 06/29/2019
My experience was great we stopped by the property on a very busy day. But they were nice and still acknowledge us while dealing with other customers. However they are a lot of people that drive really fast through the property. Which concerns me especially when… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager07/01/2019

Thank you for your 4-Star review of Oaks of Eagle Creek. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experiences if you would like to discuss this or anything else feel free to give us a call or stop by the leasing office when you have a moment. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 657790 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 06/27/2019
So far so good! Great location and the complex is adding improvements to all of its facilities. Quiet and respectful tenants! Dog barking is not an issue in my unit, currently, but I have experienced it from others, like from across the pond.
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager06/28/2019

Hello, Thank you for your 5-Star review of the Oaks of Eagle Creek. You are a valued resident and we greatly appreciate you taking the time to share your experiences with everyone. Please don't hesitate to contact us, should you need anything at all. Have a wonderful day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 655669 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 06/22/2019
Too early to tell. I just moved in. I like everything so far. Bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbnbnnnnnnnnjjjhgfghjjjjjjjjjjjjjhggjijj
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager06/24/2019

Thank you for the 4-Star review of Oaks of Eagle Creek. We appreciate you as a resident and look forward to having you in our community for a long time. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 650148 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 06/08/2019
Just less than a month now and even before I moved in have heard more good news about the apartment and have seen the Serenity of the environment well structured and painted. The staffs are loaded with care and they courteous.
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager06/10/2019

Thank you for your updated 5-Star review of Oaks of Eagle Creek. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experiences as a valued tenant. Should you need anything anything in the future, please don't hesitate to reach out to us. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 645606 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 05/28/2019
I am very happy with Oaks of Eagle Creek. I chose this neighborhood because it looked nice from the outside and when I took a tour I found the insides were just as nice. The rent isn't too bad and they offer a lot if amenities.… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager05/28/2019

Thank you for the 5-Star review of Oaks of Eagle Creek. We appreciate you as a resident and look forward to having you in our community for a long time. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 643916 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 05/23/2019
I moved into this apartment at The Oaks of Eagle Creek on May 6th of this year. I have never been as impressed with a renting office as I was here. Tasha was the young who handled everything from showing me the apartment to signing my… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager05/23/2019

Hello, Thank you for taking the time to share your experiences with The Oaks of Eagle Creek. As a recent and valued tenant, your feedback is of great importance to us. We're delighted that we're meeting your expectations. Please don't hesitate to call or stop by our office, should you need anything at all. Have a wonderful day! Sincerely, The Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 643148 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 05/21/2019
Staff very welcoming and answered all my questions. Move in was easy and done majority online. Location is great to work and school and neighborhood is quite and pretty. I like the pool area and facilities.
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager05/21/2019

Thank you for the 4-Star review of Oaks of Eagle Creek. We appreciate you as a resident and look forward to having you in our community for a long time. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 642073 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 05/18/2019
From day one I have had nothing, but a positive experience. The staff has been very professional and extremely helpful. The one staff member that I have dealt with from the day one when I walked in the front door has been Karina. She did a… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager05/20/2019

Thank you for such a nice warm hearted review of The Oaks of Eagle Creek. We hope you continue to enjoy your home and if there is anything we can do in the future please don't hesitate to reach out to us. Have a wonderful day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 622885 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 04/03/2019
Overall, this was a pretty painless experience. The staff was helpful and explained most of what I would need to take care of to move in. This is an older community, but for the price it fits my needs perfectly. See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager04/03/2019

Thank you for the 4-Star Review of The Oaks of Eagle Creek. We look forward to having you as part of our community. Have a wonderful day! Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 617434 2018 - 2019 Not Recommended
Reviewed 03/19/2019
First two nights in summer heat and I had no air; that should have been my cue to get out as soon as I could. Windows and inside two bedrooms apartments are outdated. Amenities are also outdated and not well-maintained. Even the pet waste bags seem… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager03/20/2019

We are sorry that your experiences at Oaks of Eagle Creek have been less than satisfactory. We would love to talk with you in a little more detail about any issues you are having with our community and staff so we can get a better understanding of how we can improve for both you and the rest of the residents at our community. Please stop by the office when you have sometime so we can further discuss. We look forward to talking with you. Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2017 - 2019 Not Recommended
Reviewed 03/01/2019
Do not try to stand up for yourself with these people or you will face retaliation. Office staff is a trainwreck. Nothing is ever fixed, only bandaged. Major mold issues in many buildings. GARBAGE is a wreck!!! They FORCE you to pay for someone to get… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager03/04/2019

We take mold very seriously and if you are having a mold problems within your apartment home please let us know so we can address the issue immediately. We would be more than happy to talk with you about any other issues that you are experiencing at our community so that we can resolve them for you as soon as possible. We look forward to talking with you soon. Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 609922 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 02/28/2019
My family and I decided to move from the Quad Cities in Illinois to Indianapolis, Indiana because of great job opportunities. The leasing agent that handled my move in was GREAT. They had an application fee special at the time as well! The moving process was… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager03/01/2019

Thank you for the 5-Star review of Oaks of Eagle Creek. We appreciate you as a resident and look forward to having you in our community for a long time. Have a great day! Sincerely Oaks of Eagle Creek

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 605490 2017 - 2019 Not Recommended
Reviewed 02/18/2019
You do not want to ask me about my move in nightmare, the fumes help put me in the hospital. Thanks for repainting the kitchen counter tops right before I moved in, in fact they were still tacky. I hope this enough characters. See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager02/19/2019

We are sorry to hear that Oaks of Eagle Creek has fallen short of pleasing you as a new resident. We would like the opportunity to make things right and we encourage you to visit or call the leasing office to discuss your situation in a little more detail and we hope to be able to turn this around for you. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 602940 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 02/10/2019
The apartment complex is located in a great neighborhood...The office staff was great.!!They were all friendly.Karina(I hope I spelled her name correctly lol) was very professional and knowledgeable.!!She answered every question I had...To be honest..Nowadays you have to check reviews for anything you purchase!!Trust me this… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager02/11/2019

Thank you for the 5-Star review of Oaks of Eagle Creek. We appreciate you as a resident and look forward to having you in our community for a long time. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 601863 2018 - 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 02/07/2019
I like the quiet nature of the community, for the most part. I also like how close it is to downtown, but far enough away. I like that neighbors are friendly, but they don't bother you if you don't want them to. The staff is friendly.… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager02/11/2019

Thank you for your 4-Star review of Oaks of Eagle Creek. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experiences as a valued tenant. Should you need anything anything in the future, please don't hesitate to reach out to us. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 598853 2017 - 2019 Not Recommended
Reviewed 01/31/2019
Living in the apartments for 6 years I have seen many things change! The TRASH is one big issue that hasn't been addressed still. Also the rent for what you get is a little expensive with fees that pop up such as trash service and the… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager02/01/2019

Hello, Thank you for your review of Oaks of Eagle Creek. At your earliest convenience, we would love for you to call or stop by our office and let us know what we can do to further improve your living experience here. Have a wonderful day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 595686 2011 - 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 01/22/2019
Since Birge and Held acquired this property, I have seen so many improvements within each unit, each building as well as the overall properly. I am extremely pleased and look forward to seeing what else gets taken care of in the future.
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager01/22/2019

Thank you again for following up your review with this warm hearted 5-Star Review. We work hard to make this community a great place for all of our residents and it's always nice to hear such kind words. We look forward to having you in our community for a long time to come. Have a great day! Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 591452 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 01/10/2019
VERY GOOD EXPERIENCE. Staff was very nice my apartment was ready and the move in was fast. I love my apartment. the parking is good and I feel safe in the community. I will recommend to friends and family See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager01/10/2019

Hello, Thank you for your 5-Star review for Oaks of Eagle Creek. We greatly appreciate your time and feedback. Should you need anything at all, please don't hesitate to contact us. Have a wonderful day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 588967 2001 - 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 01/02/2019
I am very comfortable here I love the improvement with the lighting that we have on the outside again my biggest concern is all the trash out from the dumpsters and how much the rent increase is going to be other than that I'm very please… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager01/02/2019

Thank you for your 4-Star review of Oaks of Eagle Creek. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experiences as a valued tenant. Should you need anything anything in the future, please don't hesitate to reach out to us. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 588849 2018 - 2019 Not Recommended
Reviewed 01/01/2019
Terrible mess. Garage piles up. Potholes are a hazard. Maintenance leaves messes behind when they do bother to come do the work. They don't call ahead even though they know you have pets and put on the request to call ahead. Office staff doesn't take any… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager01/07/2019

We are sorry to hear that Oaks of Eagle Creek has fallen short of pleasing you as a resident. Since this review is anonymous and we can't look up your information, we can't fully address this issue. We would like the opportunity to make things right and we encourage you to visit or call the leasing office to discuss your situation. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 587630 2011 - 2018 Recommended
Reviewed 12/27/2018
Great effort has been made recently to further improve the apartments. The staff both office and maintenance are top notch. I think it is a good place to live. Neighbors have been friendly and I haven't had the least problem with anyone. See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager12/27/2018

Hello, Thank you for taking the time to share your experiences with Oaks of Eagle Creek. As a valued resident, your time and feedback are greatly appreciated. Please don't hesitate to contact us, should you need anything at all. Have a wonderful day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 2018 - 2019 Recommended
Reviewed 11/27/2018
It's a very good apartment and very quite place and also neat environment. The office staff are excellent, they take their time to listen to you and find a solution to any problem. Maintenance are also great See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager11/28/2018

Thank you for your updated 5-Star review of The Oaks of Eagle Creek. You are a valued tenant so your living experience is important to us. Your time is greatly appreciated and we look forward to hearing from you, should you need anything at all. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 576289 2018 Recommended
Reviewed 11/27/2018
I moved into a lovely 1 bedroom apartment at this community 6 months ago. It has a fireplace and a wonderful view of an artificial lake with fountain with lovely trees. On one of the first days here I got lost trying to get to the… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager11/28/2018

Thank you for your 5-Star review of The Oaks of Eagle Creek. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experiences as a valued tenant. Should you need anything anything in the future, please don't hesitate to reach out to us. We look forward to having you as part of our community for a long time to come. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 570631 2012 - 2018 Recommended
Reviewed 11/13/2018
The complex is a good place to live. It is right off of the highway, close to shopping, downtown and other parts of the city. The apartments are nice and roomy. The new owners have taken great time in improving the complex. See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager11/13/2018

Thank you for the 5-Star review of Oaks of Eagle Creek. We appreciate you as a resident and look forward to having you in our community for a long time. Have a great day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Verified Resident 567407 2017 - 2019 Not Recommended
Reviewed 11/06/2018
Rotting soffits and eaves existed and nothing was done to repair them. Now racoons have infested the attic area. Traps were set according to management but have been unsuccessful. Management says there is nothing else they can do. You hear racoons running around and fighting every… See More
Oaks of Eagle Creek Manager11/19/2018

We are sorry to see that your experiences here at Oaks of Eagle Creek have been that of just 1-Star. Please contact the leasing office and explain your situation in a little more detail so we can attempt to rectify it. Have a wonderful day! Sincerely, Oaks of Eagle Creek Management Team

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report

Features & Amenities

Laundry

  • Laundry Connections in Unit
  • Laundry On-Site
  • Laundry in Units

Disclaimer: Features and Amenities data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive features and amenities offered.

Pets

  • Dogs Allowed
    Deposit: Required
    Rent: Required
    Restrictions: Breed restrictions apply.
  • Cats Allowed
    Deposit: Required
    Rent: Required

Disclaimer: Pet Policy data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive pet policies offered.

Floor Plans & Pricing

1 Bedrooms, 1 Bathroom

  • Price

    $794

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    1 Bedroom

2 Bedrooms, 1 Bathroom

  • Price

    $903

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    2 Bedrooms

2 Bedrooms, 1.5 Bathrooms

  • Price

    $833

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    2 Bedrooms

2 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms

  • Price

    $934

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    2 Bedrooms

3 Bedrooms, 1.5 Bathrooms

  • Price

    $1,143

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    3 Bedrooms

Disclaimer: Floor Plans data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive floor plans offered.

Questions & Answers

There are no questions yet for this property!
Be the first to ask.

Your question has been submitted!

Please allow up to 24 hours for your answer to be visible to the public.

·
Type your answer:
Please allow up to 24 hours for your answer to be visible to the public.
Please allow up to 24 hours for your answer to be visible to the public.
· Just Now

Oaks of Eagle Creek Gallery

Manager Uploaded Photos
Resident Uploaded Photos

Similar Properties

Image of Pebble Point in Indianapolis, IN

Pebble Point

Indianapolis, IN

Oaks of Eagle Creek is an apartment in Indianapolis in zip code 46254. This community has a 1 - 3 bedroom, 1 - 2 bathroom, and is for rent for $794 - $1,143. Nearby cities include Whitestown, Beech Grove, Speedway, Warren, and Pike. 46278, 46228, 46224, 46224, and 46222 are nearby zip codes.

  • Price

  • Sq. Ft.

  • Availability

  • Model

Oaks of Eagle Creek

Provided by Property Management

Management Photos (2)

  • (Manager photo uploaded on 12/29/2015) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Manager photo uploaded on 12/29/2015) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN

Provided by Other Residents

Resident Photos (14)

  • (Resident photo uploaded on 01/11/2014) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 01/11/2014) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 01/11/2014) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 01/11/2014) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 01/19/2012) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 01/05/2009) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 01/05/2009) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 01/05/2009) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 01/05/2009) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 01/05/2009) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 01/05/2009) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 06/20/2007) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 06/20/2007) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  • (Resident photo uploaded on 01/19/2016) Image of Oaks of Eagle Creek in Indianapolis, IN
  Back To Top