We have lived in Wyncroft for almost a year and really like it here. For the most part it's quiet. We live in the middle apartment but at this time don't have super noisy upstairs neighbors which is nice.
Pros:
We are lucky and don't encounter a ton of neighbor noise. One of our neighbors plays techno music every Friday, but he turns it off by 10--which is apartment rules and very considerate.
Great location.
Apartments are well maintained. Maintenance requests are answered in 24 hours. They even come change your lightbulbs. For someone who used to own a home this seems like quite the luxury.
Mostly quiet. Sometimes I can hear my neighbors talking outside, or some idiot drives past with their music up high. But for the most part it is quiet.
The staff in the office are nice, always pick up the phone when I call and are always in when it's office hours.
Cons:
I can't believe I haven't seen this elsewhere. The toilet clog every time you do more than pee. Just make sure to have a good plunger.
The ovens aren't full sized. I think they are 3/4 sized. They also run super hot. It took me awhile to figure out how to use it.
The cabinets in the kitchen are outdated. It's a small thing, but when everything else looks so nice it sucks to have old looking cabinets.
I really like these apartments. I've rented in a lot of places and Wyncroft is really nice, and really affordable.