This place was great overall. The maintenance and office staff were awesome and took care of problems or requests in a timely fashion. Not much noise from neighbors and noise from the railroad tracks at Maple and Eaton wasn't bad at all. The parking lot spaces can be a challenge (assigned parking in small-ish parking spaces) especially if you have large vehicles on both sides of you, but whenever I ran into an issue with this the office staff helped me out. Rent is reasonable especially for around the Birmingham area, and facilities are well maintained.
I'm a bit surprised there were major complaints about management or other staff from some past tenants, but I would guess they weren't totally angelic on their end if they were treated the way they claim. My experience was great with a few issues here and there, but, again, staff helped fix or mitigate those issues as best as possible. The reason I left was to move for a new job, but if I'm back in the area I'd definitely consider renting here again.