Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments
#17,824 #1 #315

What is epIQ?

Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments

2 East Garfield Street, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(112 Reviews)
$2,266 - $3,156/mo
Share Feedback
Write a Review
Leave a Video ReviewNew

Floor Plans & Pricing

1 Bedroom

1 Bed, 1 Bath

See Floor Plan Details

2 Bedrooms

2 Beds, 1 Bath

See Floor Plan Details

2 Beds, 1.5 Baths

See Floor Plan Details

Disclaimer: Special, prices and availabilities subject to change.

epIQ Ratings

What is epIQ?

The epIQ Index gives you an accurate and authentic understanding of what life at a community is like prior to signing a lease, using a familiar letter grade & report card format.

epIQ Report Card

In partnership with SatisFactsā„¢

Community epIQ Grade

D-
D-

Renter Ratings

D-

Review Ratings

Noise

1.0

Grounds

1.0

Safety

1.0

Office Staff

1.0

Maintenance

1.0

Neighborhood

1.0

Survey Ratings

SatisFactsā„¢ Tour Survey

SatisFactsā„¢ Move-In Survey

SatisFactsā„¢ Maintenance Survey

SatisFactsā„¢ Renewal Survey

Review Count

C

Number of reviews in the past 365 days

1

Managerā€™s Review Engagement

F

Percentage of reviews responded to

0.00%

Managerā€™s Review Reply Time

F

Average time to respond to reviews

N/A

View Community Timeline
View Community Timeline

Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments Reviews

(112)
Verified
Reviews with the Verified Badge are from residents or prospects surveyed directly from SatisFactsā„¢ at the community, ensuring reviews are from real residents or prospects!

Sort:

  • Newest Activity
  • Recently Lived In
  • Review Rating
Review Author Icon

anonymous

Resident ā€¢ 2021 - 2023

11/16/2023

Filthy apt building and horrible superintendent

This building should be condemned and the superintendent Elvis is a horrible, no talent repairman. He never answers or returns calls, has no idea how to fix ANYTHING in the building and gives you a hard time when you finally get a hold of him.ā€¦Ā See More >
    Review Author Icon

    anonymous

    Resident ā€¢ 2016 - 2020

    3/27/2021

    Warning stay away !! Once they suck you in you are stuck until your lease ends. Apartments have a roach and spider problem, i found homeless people sleeping in my hallway several times. The super Edwin suck and the new super and assist/wife is notā€¦Ā See More >
      Review Author Icon

      anonymous

      Resident ā€¢ 2020

      10/14/2020

      Very unprofessional and rude. The place is infested with problems. The water is so bad I heard the county water department found iron in the water, there is a spider infestation, the maintenance people take forever to do repairs and then retaliate against you forā€¦Ā See More >
        Review Author Icon

        anonymous

        Resident ā€¢ 2015 - 2020

        4/16/2020

        Worst place to live unless you are into deceptive advertising, discrimination against the disabled, maintenance people that litter in front of you, rust, brown water coming out the pipes, constant sewage problems, spider infestations and snakes at the front door!

          Review Author Icon

          anonymous

          Resident ā€¢ 2016

          4/25/2016

          I appreciate hard work and dedication. Edwin is great. He has done a wonderful job making Bay Shore Manor a new and improved community! Lots of good things have come into play. Nothing is perfect but I'm overall pretty satisfied.ā€¦Ā See More >
            Review Author Icon

            anonymous

            Resident ā€¢ 2014 - 2016

            3/2/2016

            Super bright lights. The light above the door is a really nice addition. I'm really enjoying the new cameras in the parking lot as well as the new signs. Laundry rooms look so much better. Ed, is such a great super. Thanks forā€¦Ā See More >
              Review Author Icon

              anonymous

              Resident ā€¢ 2014 - 2016

              1/16/2016

              Lots of great changes. Thanks to Edwin and management. The place has a new look with many improvements. Clean clean and clean. Maintenance is high level, efficient, and responsive. I come home and I feel like it's home. That feeling was missing for a whileā€¦Ā See More >
                Review Author Icon

                anonymous

                Resident ā€¢ 2012 - 2015

                10/7/2015

                My second apartment. I upgraded from a 1 to a 2 bedroom. Recently nice upgrades to bathrooms, and fixtures. Same kitchens. Good all and all. I stay here for the rent. Don't expect a dishwasher or a gym. Simple community.ā€¦Ā See More >
                  Review Author Icon

                  mikeymike1122

                  Resident ā€¢ 2010 - 2014

                  11/15/2014

                  What I love MOST about this complex, is the nature. If you're fortunate to get an apartment backing the grass (which all 3 of mine did). Watching the foliage go from lime green to red, gold and orange in the fall. Watch the snow fallā€¦Ā See More >
                    Review Author Icon

                    . jazzy1031

                    Resident ā€¢ 2007 - 2014

                    11/5/2014

                    Ok, first off this building is good when it comes to the floorplans, decent fixtures, finishes, plus the apartments are quite spacious. The apartments are large, very well maintained as is the entire building. I was considering moving too many other complexes but I foundā€¦Ā See More >
                      Review Author Icon

                      johnsonemoney

                      Resident ā€¢ 2011 - 2014

                      10/14/2014

                      Location: Garfield street better location than Third Ave. Quiet property, second floor is better Laundry machines are new and work but inconvenient No dishwashers. If you cook, prepare to do the dishes Rent a garage. Parking by sticker in the parking lot is hit or miss, especiallyā€¦Ā See More >
                        Review Author Icon

                        rodgesupta

                        Resident ā€¢ 2011 - 2014

                        10/3/2014

                        We lived in a 2-bedroom apartment at BayshoreManor for 3 years. Long Lease. Very strict credit/application check. Overall, we love the serenity of the surroundings, the convenient location (close to the mall, shopping, highways, and Touro :), the quiet and safe communityā€¦Ā See More >
                          Review Author Icon

                          JenniferLynn07

                          prospective ā€¢ Visited 2014

                          8/27/2014

                          I'm writing a review to make other prospective renters aware of what a nightmare dealing with their corporate office has been. I viewed the properties, which in it's self, was difficult to even schedule an appointment. Once I got to the property, I had to callā€¦Ā See More >
                            Review Author Icon

                            rouseforthe100

                            Resident ā€¢ 2013

                            4/24/2013

                            Hello Ratings! I want to extend my thank you! to the leasing office and Nicki for turning the credit check, application, lease within my two week requested move in date time. You all saved me a huge headache. Looking forward to the first yearā€¦Ā See More >
                              Review Author Icon

                              kcolomba

                              prospective ā€¢ Visited 2013

                              4/18/2013

                              I never lived here. Wait list.

                                Review Author Icon

                                bianca11241980

                                prospective ā€¢ Visited 2013

                                4/17/2013

                                I never lived here. No apartments available. Wait list.

                                  Review Author Icon

                                  ronnyschinder

                                  Resident ā€¢ 2012 - 2013

                                  3/22/2013

                                  Great! staff apartments location rental price service Can we get a pool?? ronnyschinder@Yahoo.com

                                    Review Author Icon

                                    anonymous

                                    Resident ā€¢ 2011 - 2012

                                    10/24/2012

                                    I've had a positive experience at Bay Shore thus far. The apartments are well kept,clean, and impressive. I've looked elsewhere and found the rent to be fairly cheap or decent in comparison to other properties. Charlie- the super tends to be aā€¦Ā See More >
                                      Review Author Icon

                                      Zutara21

                                      Resident ā€¢ 2010 - 2011

                                      4/9/2012

                                      I had written a pretty glowing recommendation here, but after dealing with the staff at BenArt Properties, I would never rent from any of their properties. We had moved out in October 2011. We went through the process of having the apartment checked and madeā€¦Ā See More >
                                        Review Author Icon

                                        kenpokrazi

                                        Resident ā€¢ 2012

                                        2/15/2012

                                        Overall the apartment itself wasn't too bad. Rent was a fair amount we were quiet tenants that kept to ourselves and we never caused or found cause to complain about anything. The move in inspection was pretty run of the mill nothing wasā€¦Ā See More >
                                          Review Author Icon

                                          anonymous

                                          Resident ā€¢ 2010 - 2011

                                          9/8/2011

                                          The Good: The apartment, for the most part is pretty clean. I can never hear anything from my neighbors or the people below us, even one neighbor who has an infant. The price is pretty affordable for the surrounding area without beingā€¦Ā See More >
                                            Review Author Icon

                                            anonymous

                                            Resident ā€¢ 2010 - 2011

                                            8/15/2011

                                            Bay shore manor is infested with bugs in the spring and summer time. I am leaving as soon A s my lease is up The "property manager" Charlie the tard is a MAJOR BS artist!!! Im only trying to prevent anyone with small children toā€¦Ā See More >
                                              Review Author Icon

                                              glavots

                                              Resident ā€¢ 2005 - 2011

                                              2/5/2011

                                              I have lived here-Bay Shore Manor with my spouse coming on six years. I couldn t be more satisfied. The management today is very professional, friendly and helpful. The maintenance men, Charles and Phil, are the best we have known in years of apartmentā€¦Ā See More >
                                                Review Author Icon

                                                ron0575

                                                Resident ā€¢ 2008 - 2010

                                                8/8/2010

                                                I love my apartment here at Manor. I have lived in other complexes before this one and have to say if you re looking for a reasonable, clean, nice apartment which close to everything, this is the apartment for you. Many apartments are upgraded withā€¦Ā See More >
                                                  Review Author Icon

                                                  lovitt0819

                                                  Resident ā€¢ 2007 - 2010

                                                  1/16/2010

                                                  This has been one of my favorite apartment complexes and would have rated it a 5, but there is always room for improvement. I live in the 5.0 model 2 bedroom floorplan and this place has the best living arrangement. The space it offers is hugeā€¦Ā See More >

                                                    Features & Amenities

                                                    Laundry
                                                    • Laundry On-Site
                                                    Pets
                                                    • Cats Allowed
                                                    Disclaimer: Pet Policy data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive pet policies offered.

                                                    Questions & Answers (2)

                                                    natalynob12
                                                    Asked on: 07/23/2018
                                                    Q:Ā Does anyone have suggestions on ensuring your are approved? i.e. Credit Score?
                                                    Anonymous
                                                    Answered on: 08/17/2022
                                                    A:Ā Simple answer is don't waste your time, the buildings have alpt of problems and you can get a better apartment elsewhere. Several apartments are mold infested, others have rat, spider, or roach infestations. To add to all this your pleas to have something fixed in your apartment will go unanswered. They will make it look nice to suck you in but once you're in you are trapped till your lease is up
                                                    Anonymous
                                                    Asked on: 03/19/2018
                                                    Q:Ā What is security like?
                                                    Anonymous
                                                    Answered on: 08/17/2022
                                                    A:Ā You're highly jnlokely to get it back. The way it works is you give the security and any damages when you leave they will deduct from your security. The landlord ignores your constant please for fixing things and the elvis the super will tell you that you have to call the office. In the end they will procrastinate and do their best to wait for your lease to be up so they can steal your security under the guise of damages

                                                    Frequently Asked

                                                    Based on 112 number of votes by renters, Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments is currently rated 4.3 out of 5 stars.
                                                    Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments is rated 1/5 stars in our renters grounds survey, which is considered poor. The grounds are in a state of disrepair and need immediate attention.
                                                    Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments is rated 1/5 stars in our renters maintenance survey, which is considered poor. The maintenance team is unresponsive and ineffective in addressing issues.
                                                    Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments is rated 1/5 stars in our renters noise survey, which is considered poor. The noise level is consistently loud and disruptive, making it difficult to live in the complex.
                                                    Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments is rated 1/5 stars in our renters safety survey, which is considered poor. The complex is very unsafe and poses serious risks to residents.
                                                    Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments is rated 1/5 stars in our renters neighborhood survey, which is considered poor. The complex is located in a very undesirable and unsafe neighborhood with limited or no access to local attractions and services.
                                                    Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments is rated 1/5 stars in our renters staff survey, which is considered poor. The staff is unresponsive and unhelpful, making it difficult to live in the complex.
                                                    Cats Allowed
                                                    1 Bed, 1 Bath
                                                    2 Beds, 1 Bath
                                                    2 Beds, 1.5 Baths

                                                    Check Availability

                                                    Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments

                                                    March 2024

                                                    Sun
                                                    Mon
                                                    Tue
                                                    Wed
                                                    Thu
                                                    Fri
                                                    Sat
                                                    1
                                                    2
                                                    3
                                                    4
                                                    5
                                                    6
                                                    7
                                                    8
                                                    9
                                                    10
                                                    11
                                                    12
                                                    13
                                                    14
                                                    15
                                                    16
                                                    17
                                                    18
                                                    19
                                                    20
                                                    21
                                                    22
                                                    23
                                                    24
                                                    25
                                                    26
                                                    27
                                                    28
                                                    29
                                                    30
                                                    Beds

                                                    0

                                                    Baths

                                                    0

                                                    Is this your community?

                                                    Claim your community to update listing information, capture leads, and respond to reviews!

                                                    Bay Shore Manor Garden Apartments is an apartment in Bay Shore in zip code 11706. This community has a 1 - 2 Beds, 1 - 1.5 Baths, and is for rent for $3,156. Nearby cities include Islip, Brentwood, North Babylon, Deer Park, and Babylon.

                                                    Your privacy and identity are important to us. Please review the Terms and Guidelines before sharing private or non-public information with matches.