Mid Island Estates

35 Penataquit Ave., Bay Shore, NY 11706

Floor Plans

Resident of this community?
Tell us what you think!

Check Availability

Mid Island Estates

 
 
 
 
 
 

ApartmentRatings Property Breakdown

OVERALL SCORE
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
0%RECOMMENDED
THIS PROPERTY
VS
60%CITY AVERAGE

Ratings & Reviews

Filter
  • 5 out of 5
  • 4 out of 5
  • 3 out of 5
  • 2 out of 5
  • 1 out of 5
No reviews match your search.
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Grounds
Office Staff
Mid Island Estates Manager

How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Neighborhood
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2016 - 2017 Not Recommended
Reviewed 11/22/2017
Persistent brown water issue. If you don't want to cook, drink, or bathe in brown water, then run. Management is not responsive to the systemic problem. Water should be clear and not dark brown. It is definitely not healthy.
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
tcb110110 • Resident 2009 - 2011 Not Recommended
Reviewed 04/16/2012
I must start by saying that I lived there at Mid Island apartments Bay Shore for two years. The staff was very nice and helpful. Maintenance was very good and fast getting there.The thing I did not like about Mid Island apartments was the very very… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
rentmove • Resident 2007 - 2009 Recommended
Reviewed 12/13/2009
I think that if people would stop expecting the Chateau when they get here, the reviews would be better. The rent is a little higher than it should be and it also increases at the end of each lease term. If you are attending a nearby… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2008 - 2009 Not Recommended
Reviewed 08/10/2009
I lived there for 1 year. Although I agree with other reviewers that it could be worse, it could certainly have been better. security sucks. although they have security cars, clearly they do not do their job because so many cars have been stolen from the… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2008 - 2009 Not Recommended
Reviewed 08/10/2009
Section 8: Many people are on section 8 here. Nothing wrong with that, but unfortunately this does bring in some less than ideal people. Drugs: You will see and smell people smoking pot around the complex, numerous times. It's awkward when you pass them and they… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2003 - 2008 Not Recommended
Reviewed 06/10/2009
Not the best place and not the worse place either. I must agree about hangin' out at the doors and hallways. That's a problem when you have guests coming to visit or simply bringin' in the groceries. A few years ago there was a homicide. More… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2009 Recommended
Reviewed 06/02/2009
Been living here for a while, there is a new manager and things are going good over here. You do not see people hanging out and she is no joke. Plenty of parking spots and any needs are taken care of right away. It's quiet and… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2008 Not Recommended
Reviewed 07/07/2008
My apartment had black toxic mold. This was scary! See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
bayshorequeen • Resident 2004 - 2005 Not Recommended
Reviewed 03/28/2008
I lived here and would not recommend it, from break-ins and drug dealers and police raids I would not recommend it. They say pets are allowed but they only mean cats, so in reality that does not mean dogs and you don't know that until you… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
time2move2007 • Resident 2006 - 2007 Not Recommended
Reviewed 08/02/2007
I live at Mid Island, Bay Shore. The problem is not the staff -- although they can be slow getting things done -- they are courteous and respectful. It's the ------ --- people that move here. There is an incredible amount of garbage thrown in front… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2004 - 2007 Not Recommended
Reviewed 07/28/2007
I have lived here for three years and I am so happy to finally be leaving. The management has a constant turnover and none of them have even been remotely competent. There is no reason to pay premium rate for an apartment when the quality of… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2007 Not Recommended
Reviewed 04/26/2007
Very noisy. The train is very close by and you can hear the horn all the time, all hours day and night. The walls are paper thin and you can hear conversations next door. Not a safe area. The office and maintenance staff very nice and… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2006 Not Recommended
Reviewed 09/20/2006
This place is right next to the train station, which some people might think is a plus until the train passes through at 2am and 3am. The horn is soo loud and these walls are paper thin. I can hear everything in all my neighbor's apartments.… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2004 - 2006 Not Recommended
Reviewed 07/06/2006
we got a new manager and the community is going down fast. when i 1st moved here i loved it now that the old manager is gone nothing gets done.
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2003 - 2005 Recommended
Reviewed 10/17/2005
I lived in Mid Island for two years. The staff there is very pleasant and very helpful...Maintence needs on the apartment was minimal.. I NEVER had any problem with roaches...This is a very clean apartment complex...my only complaint is that the rent is entirely too high… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
3yearshappy • Resident 2002 - 2005 Recommended
Reviewed 08/18/2005
I have lived at Mid-Island for 3 years.<br>I will admit when I first moved in things were not great but over the last 2 years I have noticed things are changing.<br>The lawn and floweres are wonderful. The streets have been redone and the once ugly laundry… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2005 Not Recommended
Reviewed 08/15/2005
PROBLEMS, BAD COMPANY
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2005 Not Recommended
Reviewed 08/01/2005
these apartments are filthy
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2005 Not Recommended
Reviewed 04/28/2005
I rented a one bedroom July 2004. My apartment was emersed with mold two weeks later. The superintenant is very moody and everytime I had called him the man gave me such an attitude. I then called the office because I wanted out of my lease… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2003 - 2005 Not Recommended
Reviewed 02/19/2005
homeproperties suck!<br><br>these people are really rich, they own 40,000 apartments, how can they fix anything or give you attention if they are over worked, over floaded, and understaffed.
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2005 Not Recommended
Reviewed 02/16/2005
terrible!
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 1997 - 2005 Recommended
Reviewed 02/07/2005
I think the office and maint staff are great. They take care of all of us here at mid island.
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
weaver_casey2 • Resident 2004 Not Recommended
Reviewed 02/07/2005
If any one with any sense would read this they would note that:<br>Suddenly there are all of these high scores for Mid-Island, where there were none before. Also that they are almost are written by anonymous people.That could only be the staff trying to clear there… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 1999 - 2004 Recommended
Reviewed 01/26/2005
I do not understand why anyone would write all of the terrible things about where i have lived for 6 years. I am a law sudent and i love it here. I have only had a very possitive experience here. I am proud to call Mid… See More
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report
OVERALL SCORE
See Score Breakdown
Noise
Maintenance
Safety
Construction
Grounds
Office Staff
Resident 2000 - 2004 Recommended
Reviewed 01/24/2005
I have had a very positive experience here at mid island.My family and i will be here for a long time.This is a great place to call home.
How was this review?
Useful
Thanks for voting!
Report

Features & Amenities

Laundry

  • Laundry On-Site

Disclaimer: Features and Amenities data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive features and amenities offered.

Pets

  • Dogs Allowed
    Deposit: Required
    Rent: Required
    Weight Limit: 25lbs
  • Cats Allowed
    Deposit: Required
    Rent: Required

Disclaimer: Pet Policy data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive pet policies offered.

Floor Plans & Pricing

1 Bedrooms, 1 Bathroom

  • Price

    $1,853

  • SQ. FT.

    N/A

  • Available
    Avail.

    N/A

  • Model

    1 Bedroom

Disclaimer: Floor Plans data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive floor plans offered.

Questions & Answers (1)

Your question has been submitted!

Please allow up to 24 hours for your answer to be visible to the public.

·
Type your answer:
Please allow up to 24 hours for your answer to be visible to the public.

How easy is it to find guest parking?

Anonymous · March, 19 2018
Please allow up to 24 hours for your answer to be visible to the public.
No answers yet. Be the first to answer.

Similar Properties

Image of Devonshire Hills  in Hauppauge, NY

Devonshire Hills

Hauppauge, NY

Image of Alston in Ronkonkoma, NY

Alston

Ronkonkoma, NY

Mid Island Estates is an apartment in Bay Shore in zip code 11706. This community has a 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom, and is for rent for $1,853. Nearby cities include Islip, Brentwood, North Babylon, Deer Park, and Central Islip. 11751, 11717, 11703, 11729, and 11722 are nearby zip codes.

  • Price

  • Sq. Ft.

  • Availability

  • Model

Mid Island Estates

Provided by Property Management

Management Photos (0)

    Provided by Other Residents

    Resident Photos (0)

        Back To Top