New Gotham Apartments

New Gotham Apartments

(57 Reviews)
520 West 43rd Street, New York, NY 10036
$3,865 - $5,112/mo

Floor Plans & Pricing

1 Bedroom

1 Bed, 1 Bath

Not Available

Studio

Studio, 1 Bath

Not Available

Disclaimer: Special, prices and availabilities subject to change.

Ratings & Reviews

epIQ Report Card

In partnership with SatisFacts™

Community epIQ Grade

Renter Ratings

N/A

Noise

0.0

Grounds

0.0

Safety

0.0

Office Staff

0.0

Maintenance

0.0

Neighborhood

0.0

SatisFacts™ Tour Survey

SatisFacts™ Move-In Survey

SatisFacts™ Maintenance Survey

SatisFacts™ Renewal Survey

Review Count

N/A

Number of reviews in the past 365 days

N/A

Manager’s Review Engagement

N/A

Percentage of reviews responded to

N/A

Manager’s Review Reply Time

N/A

Average time to respond to reviews

N/A

Verified Residents
Reviews with the Verified Badge are from residents surveyed directly from the community, ensuring reviews are from real residents!

Reviews

(57)

Sort:

  • Newest Activity
  • Recently Lived In
  • Review Rating
  • Original Date
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2013 - 2014

10/27/2014

Good news: Management sprayed every floor of the building today for cockroaches. Bad news: This "luxury" building has cockroaches (has had them for a while) and management did not warn residents they were spraying poisonous chemicals on every floor (other than a paper sign near theSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2011 - 2013

9/4/2013

Bottom line: this place sucks. You can get sooooo much better elsewhere. The apartments are small (one bedrooms are less than 600 sq ft) and they charge more than $3200??!!! Most importantly, the windows are thin and so are the walls. You can hear ALL theSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2012 - 2013

5/11/2013

-------- is terrible. She sucks while she is helping you rent a place because she knows there is 1% occupancy in NYC and takes total advantage of that dynamic. Then she sucks even more after she gets her commission. She is anything but polite. ISee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2010 - 2012

5/11/2013

This place is criminal. My neighbor who still lives at NG (I moved out last year) was contacted to write a review and offered a sweetner. They are either posting fake reviews or soliciting them. Do not believe anything you read here. The problems otherSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2010 - 2012

4/30/2013

I find it very interesting that the manager's names have been censored out of the bad reviews, but have been kept in the "good" reviews. Hmmmmm... I moved out of here last year, and after having lived in numerous apartments in NYC over the last 25See More >
Avatar

klfoxii

Resident 2013

4/15/2013

I've recently moved into New Gotham and, thus far, can only say that my experience has been very positive. Jenny Wu in the leasing office represents the building very well and made a great first impression. She was very polite and accomodating, andSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2004 - 2005

4/11/2013

Is Jenny Wu up for a promotion or something and needs to keep writing in?

Avatar

barinyc

Resident 2010 - 2013

4/11/2013

My experience at the New Gotham over the past 3 years has been amazing. The staff is incredible especially the doormen and the maintenance staff who are always extremely helpful. The amenities are great especially the outdoor sun deck. My roommate and I recently movedSee More >
Avatar

Aghair23

prospectiveVisited 2013

4/10/2013

A few of my girlfriends have been living in the New Gotham I am moving in this week and couldn't be more excited! Leasing agent, Jenny Wu has been super helpful. She made the process easy, and quick. Can't wait to be settled! LookingSee More >
Avatar

kellysmith176

Resident 2010 - 2013

4/10/2013

Have lived at the New Gotham for 3 years and could not have asked for a better experience. My roommate and I decided it was time for a slightly larger space and really wanted to stay in the building. Jenny Wu, the building's leasing agentSee More >
Avatar

Jefe226

Resident 2013

4/10/2013

After reading the outrageous amount of negative comments, I would be lying if I said I didn't have some apprehension, however, by the time I received my keys to move-in, I am flabbergasted by the amount negative reviews. My experience has been nothing short ofSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2013

4/9/2013

Can someone please explain to me how a "luxury" building can't work out how to keep the gym's temperature below 85degrees in the switch over months of April and September? Every 6months it's the same. The gym has no functioning windows that open, so ifSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2009 - 2013

3/23/2013

This place is dire. The new property manager is rude beyond comprehension, acts as though tenants' complaints are irrelevant and barely has the courtesy to respond to emails. It is unbelievable that they raise rent like they do. It's always been a young building,See More >
Avatar

nycgirl10

Resident 2010 - 2013

3/6/2013

BED BUGS epidemic in the building, multiple apartments on my floor got hit, including mine. Second I am pretty upset at how management handled some issue. It took them 3-4 months to renew my lease, I had to keep hounding them for it. In the meantime ISee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2013

2/27/2013

Where do I start? This is one of the WORST places I've ever lived in NYC. I'm still living here but am frantically searching for another place cause that's how much I can't stand it. Once they've got your security deposit and signature on thatSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2004 - 2013

1/27/2013

New Gotham used to be a great apartment building. Ever since Rose (2years ago) and the new building manager took over (less than a year), it has gone from bad to worse. We've (my wife and I) lived here for almost 10 years and evenSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2009 - 2012

11/2/2012

Run, don't walk...away from this place. We've lived here a few years, and will be escaping our lease very shortly. Management ignores most if not all residents' concerns. Most notably, there is a resident named "----" who owns a pit-bull mix thatSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2010 - 2012

9/6/2012

I completely agree with Anonymous' review above. New Gotham building is in poor shape. Construction has been ongoing for months. The elevator area is a complete mess. Portions of the building such as the gym area, entrance to the building through a service entrance haveSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2010 - 2012

8/10/2012

Avoid like the Plague! I think the last few post say it all. 20% hike in rent is really disgusting. A nice gentlemen who lived on the top floor for a few years in multiple apartments told me the management flat out toldSee More >
Avatar

dcoo

Resident 2010 - 2012

7/18/2012

We have lived here for almost three years. After 2 years they raised our rent 20% and started "renovations" which were promised to take 3 weeks. Three weeks later they say 3 - 4 months. The hallways are filthy. Two of the doormen are cleanSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 0

2/23/2012

Please pay an additional 200$ a month and buy some peace of mind at a real rental apartment complex. The management is horribly incompetent, takes eons to get back to you on urgent matters and has bureaucracy equivalent to a huge corporation, even though allSee More >
Avatar

cockroachzl

Resident 2011

6/22/2011

I lived there for one year from 2010 in a one-bedroom apartment in the top floor. It is not quite expensive compared to other luxury building in midtown manhattan. The management and super is good and usually respond less than one week.The monthly gym feeSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2009 - 2010

7/20/2010

I live here for a year, and would have renewed my lease if I had stayed in NYC. I got a really good deal for my 1 bedroom. I was paying $730 more/month at The Victory on 10th ave, for a view andSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

prospectiveVisited 2009 - 2010

2/1/2010

This place is INCREDIBLY dated for the price! The kitchens and bathrooms need a major overhaul to match what they are charging. I wouldn't say the place is hell on earth but its DEFINITELY a rip off. I did not rent here butSee More >
Avatar

anonymous

Resident 2004 - 2010

1/30/2010

As Simon Cowell would say on Housing Idol, "You're not cut out for this competition." Meaning the housing competition. New Gotham was priced well just a few years ago. Nearby luxury buildings were overpriced, and New Gotham was underpriced. Because of the recession, the reverseSee More >

Features & Amenities

Laundry
  • Laundry Connections in Unit
  • Laundry On-Site
  • Laundry in Units
Pets
  • Dogs Allowed
    Deposit: Required. Restrictions: Breed restrictions apply.
    Less Info
    More Info
  • Cats Allowed
    Deposit: Required
    Less Info
    More Info
Disclaimer: Pet Policy data have been collected from Internet users and may not be a reliable indicator of current or comprehensive pet policies offered.

Questions & Answers (1)

Anonymous
Asked on: 03/19/2018
Q: How easy is it to find guest parking?

Frequently Asked

What is the pet policy at New Gotham Apartments?
Dogs Allowed
Deposit: Required
Restrictions: Breed restrictions apply.
Cats Allowed
Deposit: Required
What types of floor plans are available?
1 Bed, 1 Bath and Studio, 1 Bath

Check Availability

May 2021

Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
Beds

0

Baths

0

New Gotham Apartments is an apartment in New York in zip code 10036. This community has a 1 Bed, 1 Bath Nearby cities include Manhattan, Mount Morris, Long Island City, West New York, and Weehawken. 10001, 10018, 10019, 14510, and 10069 are nearby zips.