McMillen Woods
#11,648 #1 #285

What is epIQ?

McMillen Woods

95 S Westmoor Avenue, Newark, OH 43055
(63 Reviews)
$803 - $1,530/mo
Share Feedback
Write a Review
Leave a Video ReviewNew

Floor Plans & Pricing

Studio

Efficiency

Studio, 1 Bath | 457 sq. ft.

$803

See Floor Plan Details

1 Bedroom

1bd 1bth 725 FL split

1 Bed, 1 Bath | 725 sq. ft.

$992 - $1,052

1 Available Unit

See Floor Plan Details

1bd 1bth garden

1 Bed, 1 Bath | 575 sq. ft.

$897 - $947

See Floor Plan Details

2 Bedrooms

2bd 1.5bth TH with basement 1100

2 Beds, 1.5 Baths | 1,100 sq. ft.

$1,196 - $1,406

3 Available Units

See Floor Plan Details

2bd 1.5bth garden

2 Beds, 1.5 Baths | 975 sq. ft.

$1,044 - $1,119

2 Available Units

See Floor Plan Details

2bd 2bth 1050 FL split

2 Beds, 2 Baths | 1,050 sq. ft.

$1,128 - $1,178

2 Available Units

See Floor Plan Details

2bd 1bth flat

2 Beds, 1 Bath | 937 sq. ft.

$1,044

See Floor Plan Details

2bd 1.5bth ranch 1000

2 Beds, 1.5 Baths | 1,000 sq. ft.

$1,149 - $1,199

See Floor Plan Details

2bd 2bth 1200 FL split deluxe

2 Beds, 2 Baths | 1,200 sq. ft.

$1,175

See Floor Plan Details

3 Bedrooms

3bd 1.5bth TH 1220

3 Beds, 1.5 Baths | 1,220 sq. ft.

$1,280 - $1,430

3 Available Units

See Floor Plan Details

3bd 1full 2 half bth TH 1330

3 Beds, 2 Baths | 1,330 sq. ft.

$1,328 - $1,428

2 Available Units

See Floor Plan Details

3bd 1.5bth TH 1290

3 Beds, 1.5 Baths | 1,290 sq. ft.

$1,280 - $1,530

See Floor Plan Details

3bd 1.5bth TH 1380

3 Beds, 1.5 Baths | 1,380 sq. ft.

$1,359 - $1,509

See Floor Plan Details

Disclaimer: Special, prices and availabilities subject to change.

epIQ Ratings

What is epIQ?

The epIQ Index gives you an accurate and authentic understanding of what life at a community is like prior to signing a lease, using a familiar letter grade & report card format.

epIQ Report Card

In partnership with SatisFacts™

Community epIQ Grade

C
C

Renter Ratings

C

Review Ratings

Noise

3.0

Grounds

2.0

Safety

3.0

Office Staff

2.0

Maintenance

1.0

Neighborhood

3.0

Survey Ratings

SatisFacts™ Tour Survey

SatisFacts™ Move-In Survey

SatisFacts™ Maintenance Survey

SatisFacts™ Renewal Survey

Review Count

F

Number of reviews in the past 365 days

1

Manager’s Review Engagement

A+

Percentage of reviews responded to

100.00%

Manager’s Review Reply Time

B+

Average time to respond to reviews

5 days

View Community Timeline
View Community Timeline

McMillen Woods Reviews

(62)
Verified
Reviews with the Verified Badge are from residents or prospects surveyed directly from SatisFacts™ at the community, ensuring reviews are from real residents or prospects!

Sort:

  • Newest Activity
  • Recently Lived In
  • Review Rating
Review Author Icon

anonymous

Resident 2022 - 2023

6/2/2023

You want a review and a pat on the back for something you should already provide?! Don’t be incredulous. There’s no success in mediocrity. Get to work! And stop begging for a 3rd place trophy in failure.… See More >
    Manager

    6/7/2023

    McMillen Woods
    Hello, While we appreciate you coming with your concerns and frustrations, your review makes us sad as this information is untruthful. Our team works hard to ensure our residents are happy and that our community is beautiful for all to enjoy. We love genuine feedback from our residents, and If you would like to discuss anything further, please reach out privately at residentservicesoh@monarchinvestment.com. Best Regards.
    Review Author Icon

    anonymous

    Resident 2021 - 2022

    10/20/2022

    Not a good experience

    Upon moving in the carpets were disgusting, it took 3 times of steam cleaning them and the water was dark gray. There was a cat urine odor in the kitchen and basement. The downstairs toilet barely ran and clogged. The place was very musty and… See More >
      Manager

      10/25/2022

      McMillen Woods
      Hello and thank you for sharing your experience. We're sorry to hear about all of the moisture issues in your home. If you would like to discuss your charges, we would be all ears, as we do not know who you are or which home you lived in. We can be reached at residentservicesoh@monarchinvestment.com.
      Review Author Icon

      Trang_L

      Resident 2011 - 2022

      2/5/2022

      I moved in here late 2011. Things were never of tip top condition, but were tolerable for the most part. The staff is friendly but couldn’t seem to help out much due to upper management decisions. Every time there is a management /owners change hand,… See More >
        Manager

        2/8/2022

        McMillen Woods
        Hello, thank you so much for reaching out. We want to start by apologizing for the frustrations you're experiencing due to the weather we had this weekend. The third-party plow crew we utilize were out Thursday night to plow and salt in order to get ahead. Unfortunately, the weather was so bad and for their own safety, they were not able to get back to our community until Saturday morning. We understand the inconvenience and do appreciate everyone's patience while we navigate this together.
        Review Author Icon

        anonymous

        Resident 2020 - 2021

        9/17/2021

        The play ground equipment is broken and/ or boarded up. There are weeds growing out of the downspouts. I've lived in a lot of apartments in my life , I've never had one try to tell me I can't have a grill. Mid pandemic they… See More >
          Manager

          10/6/2021

          McMillen Woods
          While I'm sorry to hear that you're not fully satisfied with our community, I can assure you that we are in the process of updating all playground equipment. Unfortunately, there are some items that are back-ordered due to the pandemic, but we offer four other playgrounds to utilize in the meantime. I did not see you in our system as a past or current resident. If you could please reach out to me via email at residentservicesOH@monarchinvestment.com, I'll gladly work with you to get additional feedback. Best regards.
          Review Author Icon

          anonymous

          prospectiveVisited 2021

          9/9/2021

          Called to get information on availability and pricing. I spoke with Kara and she was very knowledgeable, detailed and friendly. This is exactly what I was looking for when calling around. Great customer service.

            Manager

            10/6/2021

            McMillen Woods
            Thank you so much for your kind words. We really appreciate you taking the time out to share your experience with us here at McMillen Woods. We count ourselves lucky for having Kara as a part of our amazing team! We hope to welcome you soon to our community. We’re here for you!
            Review Author Icon

            Mscad1944@hotmail.com

            Resident 2018 - 2021

            7/31/2021

            I’ve had a water leak in my master bath since July 15 many times maintenance has come over and looked and say they don’t know where it’s coming from but they haven’t checked in the ceiling you can see the water I’ve cleaned up and… See More >
              Manager

              8/2/2021

              McMillen Woods
              While we’re sorry to hear that you're not fully satisfied with our community, we would greatly appreciate the opportunity to discuss this further and make things right. I can assure you we’ll do everything we can to resolve your concerns as our staff is dedicated to fixing any problems that arise. Before we can do that, we will need some more information from you as we did not find you in our system as a past or current resident of our community. If you could please provide us with your full name and number (in a private message to residentservicesOH@monarchinvestment.com) we’ll gladly work with you to get additional feedback. Best regards.
              Review Author Icon

              mikerice14

              Resident 2019 - 2021

              6/8/2021

              My daughter is a current resident and has had ongoing AC issues in her apartment. She has brought this to the attention of management several times showing photos of the 83+ degree temperatures in her apartment. Each time she is told they need to order… See More >
                Manager

                6/9/2021

                McMillen Woods
                Thank you for reaching out with what has been your daughter's experience. We understand that being without air conditioning is inconvenient and we do apologize that this is happening. Unfortunately, we do have to wait for parts to be delivered as many companies are trying to catch up from the pandemic. We do communicate with residents directly as we are legally obligated to only speak to those on the lease. Your daughter is more than welcome to reach out to me directly at residentservicesOH@monarchinvestment.com if she has any further questions.
                Review Author Icon

                anonymous

                Resident 2015 - 2020

                12/4/2020

                my biggest issue is the parking, we have 5 jeeps that live near us and nothing been done about the 2 car limit. just think if everyone violated the lease agreement like they have. I lived here over 5 years. I also lived here in… See More >
                  Manager

                  12/8/2020

                  McMillen Woods
                  Thank you for taking the time to review our community. We do understand the frustration that parking can cause and we are trying to work within our policies and city guidelines to create a better system moving forward. Residents are always welcome to bring these concerns to us so that we can look into them properly. If you'd like to discuss this further, please email us at residentservicesOH@monarchinvestment.com.
                  Review Author Icon

                  Iancole8719

                  Resident 2020

                  11/17/2020

                  Great community. The office staff is helpful and friendly. (Savana is awesome). Apartment is well maintained and spacious with a large basement. Maintenance is timely and efficient. Glad to see the upgrades to the play areas and new on site gym.

                    Manager

                    11/17/2020

                    McMillen Woods
                    Thank you so much for your kind words. We really appreciate you taking the time out to share your experience with us here at McMillen Woods—and we agree, Savana is truly a gem to have on our team! We count ourselves lucky for residents like you. We’re here for you!
                    Review Author Icon

                    anonymous

                    Resident 2020

                    8/28/2020

                    This place is a joke! Haven't been here but a couple of months and my air has been broke for a week now, apparently it's not important enough to fix. Can't get an answer from front office or anybody when it will be fixed. It's… See More >
                      Manager

                      10/6/2020

                      McMillen Woods
                      We are sad to hear that you didn’t have the best experience at our community. Thank you for bringing this matter to our attention. I’m very sorry we failed to meet your expectations- as that is not the norm. We would love for you to reach out via email at residentservicesoh@monarchinvestment.com, so we can make things right.

                      Updated Review

                      Review Author Icon

                      77Mike jones

                      Resident 2020

                      7/27/2020

                      Maintenance is joke... can't fix anything except a light bulb .. no training no common sense... office is worse .. they never answer phone, our pipe has been leaking for 3 weeks and still not fixed... don't live here it's trash ,Not worth it.. office… See More >
                        Manager

                        10/6/2020

                        McMillen Woods
                        We are so sorry to hear about your disappointing experience at our community. We are happy to say that we have brand new staff that will bring about positive changes to the community. We are happy to help with any maintenance issues, please submit work orders so we can take a look. All work orders can be submitted online for the convenience of our residents. If you would like to discuss these items further, please contact me directly at residentservicesoh@monarchinvestment.com.
                        Review Author Icon

                        Melissa_M129

                        Resident 2020

                        1/2/2020

                        This is our 1st apt together. We applied many different places and with the friendly helpful staff (Stacy is awesome) the perks of renting here and the location we chose this complex and do not regret our decision. Any questions we've had they have been… See More >
                          Manager

                          10/6/2020

                          McMillen Woods
                          Melissa, thank you so much for your great review! We're so happy to hear that you love living at McMillen Woods! Please don't hesitate to let us know if there's anything we can do for you.
                          Review Author Icon

                          tgermann1986

                          Resident 2019

                          10/9/2019

                          Do not rent here! This is the worst apartment I have ever lived in. We had to live here temporarily after we moved last minute for my Husband's job. I had friends grow up here years ago and never remember it ever being how it… See More >
                            Manager

                            10/6/2020

                            McMillen Woods
                            I'm sorry to hear that you were unhappy with your past stay at our community. I am happy to say we have since put in place a brand new staff. Our new staff is dedicated to fixing any problems that arise and making the community a better place for everyone. Please feel free to e-mail me directly with details at residentservicesoh@monarchinvestment.com so we can better improve our community operations. Best regards.
                            Review Author Icon

                            anonymous

                            Resident 2018 - 2019

                            8/24/2019

                            We were very disappointed with our experience at McMillen Woods. The office staff was terrible to deal with. They initially held my credit card number on file without processing it for weeks. We were unsure if we even were secure in knowing that we had… See More >
                              Review Author Icon

                              anonymous

                              Resident 2019

                              4/13/2019

                              Apparently the pool is closed this summer yet again our rent went up 2 years in a row now..Funny how we keep paying more for less?? there are pot holes even after they "fixed" them, water is no longer included in rent..the list goes on??… See More >
                                Review Author Icon

                                anonymous

                                Resident 2004 - 2019

                                4/10/2019

                                MAJOR DRUG RING AND TERROR THROUGHOUT CITY 4.2.19 ALL HERE AND FRIENDS WITH OFFICE. DO NOT MOVE HERE Drug ring sponsored by management. Fentanyl a concern at drug house; no more walking barefoot. Armed assaults, vehicular assaults, and physical assaults. neighbor had 2 cars totaled… See More >
                                  Review Author Icon

                                  anonymous

                                  Resident 2015 - 2018

                                  3/28/2019

                                  These apartments are poorly maintained, but the rent is raised significantly every year. Management doesn't work with you, and maintenance is done as cheaply as possible. I don't know if the problem is just this apartment community or Monarch Properties in general, but I advise… See More >
                                    Review Author Icon

                                    anonymous

                                    Resident 2018 - 2019

                                    2/7/2019

                                    A lot of college students live here, however they really treat them as 3rd class citizens. The have ridiculous policies that I've never heard of any apartment complex having. There are better options in Newark. Avoid this one as they are only there to collect… See More >
                                      Review Author Icon

                                      anonymous

                                      Resident 2017 - 2019

                                      1/30/2019

                                      Apartments are falling apart. Maintenance has a "priority list" that no matter whatever your issue is it will never be a priority. They have trees literally falling have damaged several cars and every time you bring it to their attention "theybare workomg on it" or… See More >
                                        Review Author Icon

                                        anonymous

                                        Resident 2018

                                        7/29/2018

                                        I've been living here around a month. Pros: The unit I live in provides a stackable washer/dryer. When mine stopped working, they bought me a brand new one. Good neighborhood Very pet friendly Amenities like a gym membership to a local, off-site gym Small fenced… See More >
                                          Review Author Icon

                                          anonymous

                                          Resident 2017 - 2018

                                          5/13/2018

                                          Coming up on the end of our year lease here... If you want to move here and pay $705 a month for a 500sqft apartment with AC that breaks at least ONCE a week, so the apartments are a comfortable 82° inside, mcmillen woods is… See More >
                                            Review Author Icon

                                            ceg2059@yahoo.com

                                            Resident 2015 - 2017

                                            12/13/2017

                                            The new management in mcmillan woods is HORRIBLE. If you complain about parking they tow YOU. The hold rent payments until mid month then if there is an issue they refuse payment unless Rent $105 in fees is paid by cashier check . They refused… See More >
                                              Review Author Icon

                                              anonymous

                                              Resident 2017

                                              10/12/2017

                                              We moved in to this complex the beginning of May we were told when we moved in that it was a quiet neighborhood. That the speed limit was enforced and that it is a safe place to raise a family. However no one watches their… See More >
                                                Review Author Icon

                                                renne1979

                                                Resident 2016 - 2017

                                                5/18/2017

                                                Horrible. That pretty much sums up these apartments. The inside needs remodeling. You will be paying anywhere from $900-1100 a month for a home that you will be miserable in. And rent increases 25-50 dollars each year while they take privileges away each month. So… See More >
                                                  Manager

                                                  6/2/2017

                                                  McMillen Woods
                                                  I am sorry that you are unhappy with your residency here. We apologize for any inconveniences or difficulties you've experienced. We would be happy to meet and discuss any issues they are having.
                                                  Review Author Icon

                                                  onemanwarrior33

                                                  Resident 2008 - 2016

                                                  11/28/2016

                                                  I have lived at McMillen Woods close to 10 years. I enjoy it here and have had no problems really with anything. The neighbors are friendly. They fix things for you real quick. I have a couple of Goldens and McMillen Woods have been extremely… See More >
                                                    Manager

                                                    11/29/2016

                                                    McMillen Woods
                                                    Thank you for your feedback! Please let us know if there is anything else we can do to make your stay here more enjoyable.

                                                    Features & Amenities

                                                    Laundry
                                                    • Laundry On-Site
                                                    • Washer/Dryer
                                                    • Washer/Dryer Connections
                                                    Parking
                                                    • Garage
                                                    Pets
                                                    • Cats Allowed
                                                      Fee: $350. Rent: $45. Pet Limit: 2. Comments: Visit our pet policy page or contact our office for more information.
                                                      Less Info
                                                      More Info
                                                    • Dogs Allowed
                                                      Fee: $350. Rent: $45. Pet Limit: 2. Comments: Visit our pet policy page or contact our office for more information.
                                                      Less Info
                                                      More Info
                                                    Other
                                                    • 1st Floor
                                                    • 2nd Floor
                                                    • Air Conditioner
                                                    • BBQ and Picnic Area
                                                    • Basement
                                                    • Basketball Court
                                                    • Carpet
                                                    • Clubhouse
                                                    • DishWasher
                                                    • Finished Basements
                                                    • Flexible Monthly Rent Payments with Flex Rent
                                                    • High-Speed Internet
                                                    • Large Closets
                                                    • On-Site Maintenance
                                                    • On-Site Management
                                                    • On-site Gym
                                                    • Package Receiving Service
                                                    • Patio
                                                    • Playground
                                                    • Pool
                                                    • Premium Appliances
                                                    • Refrigerator
                                                    • Secured Community
                                                    • Short Term Lease Available
                                                    • Tanning
                                                    Show Less
                                                    Show More

                                                    Leasing

                                                    Retreat to your corner of the world at McMillen Woods Apartments. We offer enormous floor plans to fit every lifestyle, and we are located in Newark, OH just 30 minutes east of Columbus. We have Studios, 1, and 2 bedroom single-story apartments. We also have 2 and 3 bedroom townhome apartments for rent. All homes are cable ready and have central air conditioning. Select homes contain washer-dryer connections, full basements, and private patios.
                                                    Show Less

                                                    Office Hours

                                                    • Sunday: Closed
                                                    • Monday - Friday: 09:00 AM - 06:00 PM
                                                    • Saturday: 10:00 AM - 03:00 PM
                                                    This community is managed by

                                                    Monarch Investment & Management Group

                                                    A-
                                                    A-
                                                    Communities
                                                    321

                                                    Questions & Answers (0)

                                                    Frequently Asked

                                                    How is McMillen Woods Rated?
                                                    Based on 63 number of votes by renters, McMillen Woods is currently rated 2.7 out of 5 stars.
                                                    How satisfied are residents with the upkeep and overall appearance of the grounds at McMillen Woods?
                                                    McMillen Woods is rated 2/5 stars in our renters grounds survey, which is considered poor. The grounds are in a state of disrepair and need immediate attention.
                                                    How effective was the maintenance team when resolving your problem?
                                                    McMillen Woods is rated 1/5 stars in our renters maintenance survey, which is considered poor. The maintenance team is unresponsive and ineffective in addressing issues.
                                                    What are noise levels like at McMillen Woods?
                                                    McMillen Woods is rated 3/5 stars in our renters noise survey, which is considered below average. The noise level is often disruptive and affects quality of life.
                                                    How safe is McMillen Woods?
                                                    McMillen Woods is rated 3/5 stars in our renters safety survey, which is considered below average. The complex has significant safety concerns that need immediate attention.
                                                    How satisfied are residents with the neighborhood?
                                                    McMillen Woods is rated 3/5 stars in our renters neighborhood survey, which is considered below average. The complex is located in a neighborhood with significant safety or desirability concerns, with few access to local attractions and services.
                                                    How satisfied are residents with the staff at McMillen Woods?
                                                    McMillen Woods is rated 2/5 stars in our renters staff survey, which is considered poor. The staff is unresponsive and unhelpful, making it difficult to live in the complex.
                                                    How often does management engage with reviews?
                                                    Managers have responded to 100% of their community reviews in the past year.
                                                    How quickly does management engage with reviews?
                                                    Managers have replied within 5 days to their community reviews in the past year.
                                                    Who manages McMillen Woods?
                                                    Monarch Investment & Management Group
                                                    What is the pet policy at McMillen Woods?
                                                    Cats Allowed
                                                    Fee: $350
                                                    Rent: $45
                                                    Pet Limit: 2
                                                    Comments: Visit our pet policy page or contact our office for more information.
                                                    Dogs Allowed
                                                    Fee: $350
                                                    Rent: $45
                                                    Pet Limit: 2
                                                    Comments: Visit our pet policy page or contact our office for more information.
                                                    What types of floor plans are available?
                                                    1 Bed, 1 Bath
                                                    2 Beds, 1 Bath
                                                    2 Beds, 1.5 Baths
                                                    2 Beds, 2 Baths
                                                    3 Beds, 1.5 Baths
                                                    3 Beds, 2 Baths
                                                    Studio, 1 Bath

                                                    Contact Property

                                                    McMillen Woods

                                                    March 2024

                                                    Sun
                                                    Mon
                                                    Tue
                                                    Wed
                                                    Thu
                                                    Fri
                                                    Sat
                                                    1
                                                    2
                                                    3
                                                    4
                                                    5
                                                    6
                                                    7
                                                    8
                                                    9
                                                    10
                                                    11
                                                    12
                                                    13
                                                    14
                                                    15
                                                    16
                                                    17
                                                    18
                                                    19
                                                    20
                                                    21
                                                    22
                                                    23
                                                    24
                                                    25
                                                    26
                                                    27
                                                    28
                                                    29
                                                    30
                                                    Beds

                                                    0

                                                    Baths

                                                    0

                                                    McMillen Woods is a 457 - 1,380 sq. ft. apartment in Newark in zip code 43055. This community has a 1 - 3 Beds, 1 - 2 Baths, and is for rent for $803 - $1,530. Nearby cities include Heath, Granville, Pataskala, Johnstown, and Frazeysburg.

                                                    Your privacy and identity are important to us. Please review the Terms and Guidelines before sharing private or non-public information with matches.