Indian Creek Apartments
#10,999 #4 #251

What is epIQ?

Indian Creek Apartments

421 Lancaster Avenue, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
(24 Reviews)
$1,128 - $1,905/mo

Floor Plans & Pricing

1 Bedroom

1 Bed, 1 Bath

See Floor Plan Details

2 Bedrooms

2 Beds, 2 Baths

See Floor Plan Details

2 Beds, 2.5 Baths

See Floor Plan Details

Disclaimer: Special, prices and availabilities subject to change.

epIQ Ratings

What is epIQ?

The epIQ Index gives you an accurate and authentic understanding of what life at a community is like prior to signing a lease, using a familiar letter grade & report card format.

epIQ Report Card

In partnership with SatisFacts™

Community epIQ Grade

C
C

Renter Ratings

A+

Review Ratings

Noise

5.0

Grounds

5.0

Safety

5.0

Office Staff

5.0

Maintenance

5.0

Neighborhood

5.0

Survey Ratings

SatisFacts™ Tour Survey

SatisFacts™ Move-In Survey

SatisFacts™ Maintenance Survey

SatisFacts™ Renewal Survey

Review Count

D

Number of reviews in the past 365 days

1

Manager’s Review Engagement

F

Percentage of reviews responded to

0.00%

Manager’s Review Reply Time

F

Average time to respond to reviews

N/A

View Community Timeline
View Community Timeline

Indian Creek Apartments Reviews

(24)

4 rating

See Details

24 total reviews

(

Verified

)

Verified
Reviews with the Verified Badge are from residents or prospects surveyed directly from SatisFacts™ at the community, ensuring reviews are from real residents or prospects!

Sort:

  • Newest Activity
  • Recently Lived In
  • Review Rating
Review Author Icon

anonymous

Resident 2022 - 2023

11/2/2023

Peaceful community

I've been living at Indian Creek for over a year now, and I have 0 complaints. ?? it has been peaceful and I'm more than appreciative of it daily. Cathy has been an amazing help with anything needed or any concerns. The maintenance has also… See More>
    Review Author Icon

    KellanHermes

    Resident 2020 - 2021

    11/22/2021

    Jebus Cripes. This apartments are small but nice enough. The neighborhood is sweet. It has a bark park and is a short walk away from a really nice, large community park. The people who work in the office, particularly management, are excessively rude. My dog… See More>
      Review Author Icon

      georgekastanza

      Resident 2013 - 2014

      12/4/2014

      Quiet place to live. Decent apt and nice maintenance. HOWEVER - old apartments and the NEW business owners RAISED the rate after my first year for a ridiculous price for how small my apartment was. I wanted a larger place with better rates than there… See More>
        Review Author Icon

        anonymous

        Resident 2014

        8/17/2014

        I recently moved to Indian Creek and I am totally impressed!!!!! Everyone on staff is very courteous and out going. The maintenance team are very good at getting things done and explaining what they have done to make your stay more comfortable. KEEP UP THE… See More>
          Review Author Icon

          davisbakermcnees

          Resident 2009 - 2014

          4/24/2014

          We moved here expecting to stay 1-2 years, but then the impossible happened, complete happiness. I give Indian Creek 5 stars. This is a quiet, clean, safe community. The office manager is Kristin who is an amazing woman. She definitely goes above and beyond for… See More>
            Review Author Icon

            anonymous

            Resident 2012 - 2014

            4/9/2014

            My boyfriend and I have had the pleasure of living here for 2 years. We are getting ready to resign our lease because these apartments can't be beat! It is quiet and well kept. Our neighbors are friendly and respectful. Kristin and the management team… See More>
              Review Author Icon

              anonymous

              Resident 2013

              1/8/2014

              I was so sad to leave Indian Creek Apartments! If I hadn't moved back to Michigan, I would have stayed here for many years. Kristin and her staff are incredible. I can't say enough nice things about them. The apartments are… See More>
                Review Author Icon

                anonymous

                Resident 2012 - 2013

                7/22/2013

                Indian Creek is situated in a very convenient area (park, supermarkets, restaurants, freeway,)all nearby. The staff is very professional and response to requests promptly. Maintenance is always prompt. Grounds are kept clean. The only problems I have is that the apartments are too outdated. Management (Roger… See More>
                  Review Author Icon

                  landinsmom92

                  Resident 2012 - 2013

                  3/7/2013

                  I adore Indian Creek apartments! Not only are the apartments really nice but so are the staff! Kristin has made our first apartment experience one we will never forget! If we ever need anything maintenance is always really quick and friendly! The pool is great… See More>
                    Review Author Icon

                    anonymous

                    Resident 2011 - 2012

                    11/4/2012

                    I have lived here for over a year and a half and actually enjoy the community. My issue is a very obnoxious and loud neighbor. Last night was the last straw. This individual and her friends did not shut off the music and jumping/bumping until 6… See More>
                      Review Author Icon

                      anonymous

                      Resident 2006 - 2012

                      7/28/2012

                      love to call this place home! great staff, great community!… See More>
                        Review Author Icon

                        ryanstefani

                        Resident 2012

                        5/23/2012

                        wonderful place to live

                        Great place and better people. Thanks for all the hard work!

                          Review Author Icon

                          icet

                          Resident

                          5/3/2012

                          Resident @ 398 Cheyenne Way

                          my experience @ Indian Creek has been nothing but tremendous. Kristin on a daily basis continues to rock. maintenenace personnel are prompt, experienced and response time for any problems are dealt with correctly.I feel secure in this environment and Kristin's management skills and review of… See More>
                            Review Author Icon

                            anonymous

                            Resident 2006 - 2011

                            4/23/2011

                            Kristin is amazing. The landscaping crew rocks. Maintenance is prompt and does fantastic work. I moved here with the intentions of only staying for a year or two, but I never moved, because this is a perfect place to call home.… See More>
                              Review Author Icon

                              anonymous

                              Resident 2011

                              3/29/2011

                              Everything is Wonderful :)

                              I love love love these apartments, its a very quiet neighborhood and the staff is wonderful. We were able to move in right away when we wanted to and rent isn't bad at all. Kristin is wonderful and very helpful with anything! We plan on… See More>
                                Review Author Icon

                                anonymous

                                Resident 2010 - 2011

                                2/28/2011

                                Indian Creek has been a nice place to live. I have always felt comfortable and safe here. The on site management, Kristin and Sara have always been helpful and responsive to any needs. Parking gets a little crowded in my section, but not a big… See More>
                                  Review Author Icon

                                  anonymous

                                  Resident 2006 - 2011

                                  1/15/2011

                                  The last move you'll ever make!

                                  I've lived at Indian Creek since 2006 and can testify that my experience keeps getting better! The new office and maintenance staff always respond promptly to my needs, and I love the layout of my apartment. The many different styles is accommodating to… See More>
                                    Review Author Icon

                                    iwant2review

                                    Resident 2008 - 2010

                                    6/10/2010

                                    Not So Much...

                                    I agree the new management is more personal. However the maintenance team is horrible they do a half job and you have to call and set-up a day for them to come out and get the work done right they should have corrected the first… See More>
                                      Review Author Icon

                                      wombat_17808

                                      Resident 2009 - 2010

                                      3/18/2010

                                      A Great Home

                                      My Fiance and I have lived here for almost a year now and we love it here. This is a place that we are happy to call home, the thing we love the most is that the grounds are well kept, the maintenance team is… See More>
                                        Review Author Icon

                                        chadech62

                                        Resident 2006 - 2010

                                        3/18/2010

                                        This is a Great community

                                        I have lived in Indian Creek community for 5 years, with the new management team it is a pleasure to live here. They seem to make it a point to know you on a personal level and to make sure all your concerns are taken… See More>
                                          Review Author Icon

                                          anonymous

                                          Resident 2006 - 2010

                                          3/18/2010

                                          Happy About the Management Change

                                          I have lived at Indian Creek for 4 years and have seen a lot of change since living here. The best change; however, has been the maintenance and management team. In the past my concerns and complaints were swept under the rug and… See More>
                                            Review Author Icon

                                            anonymous

                                            Resident 1997 - 2003

                                            1/13/2010

                                            Residents, I need your help

                                            I am thinking about renting here after being gone for 7 years. The last review was Jan 09. Have there been any apartment renovations? What are the demographics like? Utilities? Please take a moment and post your reviews. I would like to know. Thanks.

                                              Review Author Icon

                                              junk2008

                                              Resident 2005 - 2008

                                              1/13/2009

                                              Apartments are OK but neighbourhood is not good.

                                              I lived in these apartments and they are old but OK to live. Recently roof top has been changed for all apartments. Windows are not good, I don't think they were ever changed after apartments were built. Note that they charge extra for water and… See More>
                                                Review Author Icon

                                                anonymous

                                                Resident 2008

                                                5/15/2008

                                                pretty decent

                                                the apartment im in with my mother, has two bdrms and 2 1/2 baths. its very nice for the price but you can tell in a couple yrs the neighborhood is going to be hood.but for right now its very close 2 almost any store… See More>

                                                  Features & Amenities

                                                  Laundry
                                                  • Laundry Connections in Unit
                                                  • Laundry On-Site
                                                  Pets
                                                  • Dogs Allowed
                                                    Weight Limit: 25lbs. Comments: Dogs $250.00 deposit refundable and $25.00 monthly pet fee. Cats $200.00 deposit refundable and $10.00 monthly pet fee
                                                    Less Info
                                                    More Info

                                                  Questions & Answers (1)

                                                  Anonymous
                                                  Asked on: 03/19/2018
                                                  Q: What is security like?

                                                  Frequently Asked

                                                  Based on 24 number of votes by renters, Indian Creek Apartments is currently rated 4 out of 5 stars.
                                                  Indian Creek Apartments is rated 5/5 stars in our renters grounds survey, which is considered excellent. The grounds are well kept and beautiful.
                                                  Indian Creek Apartments is rated 5/5 stars in our renters maintenance survey, which is considered excellent. The maintenance team is very responsive and effective in addressing issues.
                                                  Indian Creek Apartments is rated 5/5 stars in our renters noise survey, which is considered excellent. The noise level is consistently low and does not cause any disturbances.
                                                  Indian Creek Apartments is rated 5/5 stars in our renters safety survey, which is considered excellent. The complex is very secure and safe, with no major safety concerns.
                                                  Indian Creek Apartments is rated 5/5 stars in our renters neighborhood survey, which is considered excellent. The complex is located in a very desirable and safe neighborhood with convenient access to local attractions and services.
                                                  Indian Creek Apartments is rated 5/5 stars in our renters staff survey, which is considered excellent. The staff is extremely helpful and responsive to resident needs.
                                                  Dogs Allowed
                                                  Weight Limit: 25lbs
                                                  Comments: Dogs $250.00 deposit refundable and $25.00 monthly pet fee. Cats $200.00 deposit refundable and $10.00 monthly pet fee
                                                  1 Bed, 1 Bath
                                                  2 Beds, 2 Baths
                                                  2 Beds, 2.5 Baths

                                                  Check Availability

                                                  Indian Creek Apartments

                                                  May 2024

                                                  Sun
                                                  Mon
                                                  Tue
                                                  Wed
                                                  Thu
                                                  Fri
                                                  Sat
                                                  1
                                                  2
                                                  3
                                                  4
                                                  5
                                                  6
                                                  7
                                                  8
                                                  9
                                                  10
                                                  11
                                                  12
                                                  13
                                                  14
                                                  15
                                                  16
                                                  17
                                                  18
                                                  19
                                                  20
                                                  21
                                                  22
                                                  23
                                                  24
                                                  25
                                                  26
                                                  27
                                                  28
                                                  29
                                                  30
                                                  31
                                                  Beds

                                                  0

                                                  Baths

                                                  0

                                                  Is this your community?

                                                  Claim your community to update listing information, capture leads, and respond to reviews!

                                                  Indian Creek Apartments is an apartment in Reynoldsburg in zip code 43068. This community has a 1 - 2 Beds, 1 - 2.5 Baths, and is for rent for $1,905. Nearby cities include Pickerington, Blacklick, Whitehall, Canal Winchester, and Groveport.

                                                  Your privacy and identity are important to us. Please review the Terms and Guidelines before sharing private or non-public information with matches.